A popular topic in art history for more than a decade has been how to write a global history of art. Because of this trend, scholars and students have become more aware of the formation of canons in existing art history survey books and consider it important to include non-Western art in the grand narratives.Footnote 1 Recent studies on twentieth-century Japanese art also reflect this trend, engaging in the ongoing dialogue on the global history of art and the position of Japanese art. One major challenge for non-Western art historians is the problem of temporality and originality. As Keith Moxey points out, this is related to the fundamental methodology of art history. Art historians tend to locate the point of creation, and then label the visually similar but chronologically later as copies or derivatives.Footnote 2 This methodology has two problems: first, it treats Europe as the center of history, and second, it espouses the European notions of temporality and originality. Furthermore, it suggests a hierarchical structure: the marginal is insignificant, because it does not affect the center. In this prescribed system, there is little value for non-Western art to be incorporated into the narratives of twentieth-century art in the West. Thus, Japanese art can be argued to be important in a local context, but it does not affect the art production in Europe and America.
In response to this situation, scholars of non-Western art have interrogated the assumptions of temporality and originality. Authors like Alicia Volk, Ming Tiampo, and Bert Winther-Tamaki all endeavor to expose the structure of modern art canons; question the definition of “originality”; advocate temporality that values synchronism; and stress that regional, cultural, and gender differences should be taken into account.Footnote 3 Volk writes: “Western art history has long recognized the impact of non-Western cultures such as Japan, which it once classified as ‘primitive,’ on the development of Euro-American modernism but has not fully escaped its own Orientalist agenda.”Footnote 4 Tiampo asks: “How is it that Gutai is considered derivative of Jackson Pollock, but Pollock not derivative of Wassily Kandinsky or André Masson? What is the difference between derivation and family resemblance?”Footnote 5 Both authors explicitly voice dissatisfaction with modern art canons, which are embedded in the power relationship rooted in colonialism. In her study, Volk argues that Japanese artists such as Yorozu Tetsugorō had opposed the binary model of East and West and experimented with ways to move beyond it, for although Tetsugorō’s work was informed by European discourses, it also expanded the possibilities of modernism. Tiampo, inspired by theories of economics and in particular Adam Smith's critique of colonialism, coined the term “cultural mercantilism” to address both sides of such encounters. Her book exposes the previous structure of modernism, which characterized European inspiration from other cultures such as Japonisme and Primitivism but rejected the production of other modernisms by describing them as derivative, and analyzes Japanese artists like the Gutai group's responses to global contemporary art. In his book, Winther-Tamaki considers oil painting as a transcultural medium that allows for connections and resonances across regions. The reciprocal interactions and international rivalries between artists in Japan, Europe, and other parts of Asia formulated multilateral contact zones with blurring boundaries, which were features of imperialism and globalization.Footnote 6
Furthering this momentum, recent studies continue to offer stimulating theoretical frameworks and case studies to connect Japanese art meaningfully with European and American scholarship. Michael Lucken begins his book, Imitation and Creativity in Japanese Arts, by revealing the cultural construction of “originality” and “genius.” Lucken astutely points out:
Modern Japanese art depends on a heuristic that fits into neither the classical scheme of imitation → individuation → creation, where creation is the result of the self's maturation process through a prolonged contact with its models, nor into the modern agenda of rejecting imitation → creation → individuation, where it is only breaking from his models that the artist can expect to find his way. (p. 3)
He argues that the idea that Japanese art is produced through imitation is rooted in Romantic ideals of originality and “criticism of Japanese imitation belongs very clearly in a power struggle” (p. 13). After deconstructing the myth of “originality,” Lucken selects four representative works from painting, film, photography, and animation to explore Japanese artists’ reflections on the nature of creation: Kishida Ryusei's concepts of realism, photography, and the images of ghosts; Kurosawa Akira's pursuit of universality through a localized narrative; Araki Nobuyoshi's photographs that represent the banality of daily life in a remarkable way; and Miyazaki Hayao's stake of “oblique” as a creative intervention to the rational-based perspectives, a symbolic form associated with the West. Lucken's major argument builds upon his previous book, L'art du Japon au vingtième siècle (The art of Japan in the twentieth century),Footnote 7 as both strive to bring out the uniqueness of Japanese culture in contrast with the European models. Lucken identifies the artists’ unique sensibilities that drive their creations and highlights the complexity and insufficiency of the binary model of imitation and creation. His writing style gracefully yet convincingly reminds the reader to be vigilant when applying those familiar terms such as realism and originality to evaluate Japanese art.
Chelsea Foxwell's Making Modern Japanese-Style Painting provides another model to reconstruct the history of Japanese-style painting (nihonga) and make it relevant to scholars outside the field. Previous study on nihonga in English scholarship tended to focus on Okakura Kakuzo (1862–1913) or the ideology of nationalism.Footnote 8 In contrast, Foxwell reframes the emergence of nihonga in an international context. She argues that “the creation of the concept of ‘Japanese painting’ reflected the global nineteenth-century impulse to divide painting and other arts into national schools, but it also reflected the stance of foreigners such as William Anderson, Louis Gonse, and Ernest Fenollosa, whose position as non-Japanese made it natural for them to designate all of Japanese painting as a single entity” (p. 5). Her book is concerned with issues of how painting was changed and what the mechanism of that change was. She aptly argues that it was not so much that painting changed as that “the idea of how a painting should be legible to its audience changed” (p. 143). The most important factor, according to Foxwell, was the emergence of exhibition culture in the nineteenth century, which profoundly reconfigured the relationship between artists and the audience. The exhibition culture first prompted a need to visualize Japaneseness for political and economic considerations at the overseas venues. As the domestic exhibitions became more systematized and matured, the style of nihonga also changed to satisfy the domestic demands. Foxwell treats exhibition as an event, a space, and a mechanism that constantly rearranged and recontextualized an artwork, recreated different viewing conditions, and stimulated public discussions on the notion of art, Japaneseness, and the like, in addition to facilitating the existing citational practice in which artists freely appropriated the images from what they had seen at the exhibitions for their own works. From this perspective, the meaning of a work is always in flux among various social, political, and economic forces. Her thoughtful interpretations link together different, seemingly independent phenomena to direct our attention to how nihonga came to be what it looks like today. Her study informs us of a dynamic art world within and outside Japan.
Although there is a general consensus that gender identity should be incorporated into the narratives of art history canons, much research remains to be done. For example, Foxwell's study is well-researched and elegantly articulated, but does not mention what role female painters such as Uemura Shōen (1875–1949) played in the development of nihonga. Namiko Kunimoto's The Stakes of Exposure fills in this gap, highlighting the individual experiences in postwar Japan of female artists who primarily worked within the country over those who worked outside and thus achieved an international reputation earlier, like Yayoi Kusama (b. 1929) or Yoko Ono (b. 1933). This book explores the relationship between gender and nationhood from the 1950s to the 1970s, following three threads: the nature of gender and nation, the political stake of art, and the anxieties that characterized postwar Japanese art and politics. Kunimoto takes the body as her focal point to bring in various artistic practices and notions of democracy and individualism to illuminate the three themes. The carefully selected, well-balanced case studies of four artists lay out critical artmaking strategies for political intervention. Katsura Yuki's allegorical assemblages, Nakamura Hiroshi's vibrant paintings of trains and schoolgirls, Tanaka Atsuko's electric mappings of circuits and circles, and Shiraga Kazuo's violent spectacles all charted new artistic territory. Kunimoto's study aims to challenge two dominant research paradigms of postwar Japanese art: the problem of periodization and the emphasis on art groups. By focusing on artists whose careers stretched from the prewar to the postwar periods and demonstrating artists’ shifting political agendas and engagement with social issues, her book sheds light on the complexity of the domestic Japanese art world.
Kunimoto's focus on individual artists’ careers has its advantages and disadvantages. On the one hand, it effectively challenges the simplified periodization that typically considers the year 1945 as the “rebirth” of Japan following the atomic bombings, implicating a rupture from the past. She intentionally traces the selected artists’ extensive careers to manifest the impossibilities of using political events to demarcate artistic and cultural changes. On the other hand, it risks glorifying individual artists as masters, whose creations are consequently “thoughtful masterpieces” that do not need justification. For instance, when explaining why Katsura Yuki did not choose a radical art form such as performance art in the 1960s to express her political stance, Kunimoto writes: “It is possible that she was aware of just how easily the mainstream could reject, or worse, ignore radical art. Her own priorities, I propose, involved seeking painterly change by walking the line between established art modes and avant-garde art” (p. 63). While it is possible that Katsura's reluctance to utilize a new medium was due to concern about public reception, I would have preferred a discussion of Katsura's understanding of the characteristics of the specific media that proposed reasons for Katsura's insistence on a relatively traditional medium to express her progressive political stance. Nevertheless, Kunimoto's book elucidates the uneasy political relationship between Japan and the United States from the 1950s to the 1970s, as well as that between an individual and the nation. Even though The Stakes of Exposure focuses on the domestic art world, it involves the changing international situation in the postwar era, thus framing postwar Japan to be part of the larger global history.
While the previous authors look inward to examine the vibrant and even turbulent art world in Japan, Christine Guth's book, Hokusai's Great Wave, looks outward to see what happens when a Japanese art object is circulated worldwide and invites us to contemplate what a global art history means. Taking a single print, Hokusai's Under the Wave off Kanagawa, as her primary object, Guth analyzes the reinterpretation and transformation of the print around the world. Her case study raises an important question: what if the center of temporality is in Asia? Guth further complicates this model of temporality by presenting an enormously dispersed global circulation of images. She begins with discussing the multiple readings of the Great Wave in 1830s Japan, and then moves on to explore the reception of the Great Wave in Europe, where this print was renamed La Vague, signifying its transformation from Japanese particularity into French visual culture. The following chapter turns to discuss the reaction to and recreation of the Great Wave against the backdrop of the changing US-Japan relationship. The final chapter concerns the representation of the Great Wave on the wall in local communities in England and Australia, where this image has become a recognizable global icon that also speaks to local identity. In the conclusion, Guth reflects on the Great Wave's meaning for the Japanese after the tsunami in 2011.
Guth's study expands the previous study of Japonisme from Western Europe to include more regions across the globe and to extend the time duration from the nineteenth century to the twenty-first. She sees the image of the Great Wave as an active producer of meaning embedded in the network of relationship (p. 8), and argues that it creates a “third space,” both reinforcing and critiquing Japan, besides serving as a local, national, and global icon. Her research shows that it is no longer possible to determine a certain point of “creation” and “imitation,” which is essential in establishing the chronological order and assigning the value of “originality” to objects. Although her case study is very peculiar—indeed, few artworks have gained such a huge success as the Great Wave—it is still revealing to reconsider current models of cross-cultural interaction. Recognizing the fact that objects move multi-directionally and link with local consumption culture, Guth urges us to be aware of the impact of globalization.
As a result of scholars’ unremitting efforts, the ways in which twentieth-century Japanese art is conceived and connected with art productions in Europe, America, and other parts of the world are understood very differently from twenty years ago. Moving away from the model of nationalism, we also see increasing scholarship dealing with the regional history of East Asia, and the relationship with regions other than Europe and America. While embracing the approach of comparative studies and macro-history of art, the construction of a global history of art steps beyond incorporating more non-Western art objects into the European and American narratives of modern art. Another dimension, I contend, also includes the respect of and communication with divergent disciplines in other regions. For instance, art historians in Japan tend to adopt a micro-history approach to read images closely and emphasize new materials in contrast to working out new theories in English scholarship. To some degrees, the urgency of developing new methodologies for global art history responds more to the past scholarship in the West than to the art historical narratives in Japan. How to interpret and evaluate objects from different approaches in other regions should be also be a consideration of ours while contemplating what a global history of art means.
