Joseph Schumpeter died in 1950, a despondent, self-declared failure, in part because Keynes had upstaged him as the premier economist of the twentieth century. A half century later, his intellectual standing is improved while Keynes's has declined. Lawrence Summers even predicts the twenty-first century will be Schumpeter's: optimistic if based on his positive contributions to economics, but less so if based on his contribution to ongoing ideological and methodological disagreements besetting economics since his death. Adding to the interest in Schumpeter is his deviation from the standard putdown of the economist as a fellow who likes to play with numbers but lacks the personality to be an accountant. Schumpeter was, indeed, an early promoter of mathematizing economics and a cofounder of the Econometric Society, but his fascinating, contradictory character belies the latter half of the putdown. A skillful phrasemaker, he left a voluminous, if contradictory, record of generous scholarship, magisterial public pronouncements, and despairing private diary entries to intrigue the psychologically curious. He displayed his multilingual erudition in classroom and seminar with an aristocratic posturing softened by self-deprecating wit, and with an easy spontaneity that usually hid carefully prepared showmanship. He needled senior stuffed shirts at Harvard despite sharing their political conservatism, while extending tolerance and generous assistance to the younger faculty and graduate students who formed his intellectual circle despite their radical “visions” and derivative policy views that he privately despised.
As interest in Schumpeterian ideas has risen, the postmortem homages from colleagues and friends have been augmented by more fully researched biographies drawing on his unpublished diaries and correspondence, interviews and memoirs. This material supplements the master's publications, including his massive, posthumously published History of Economic Analysis that his third wife, Elizabeth Boddy, struggled heroically until her death in 1953 to shape for publication, which was achieved the following year through the efforts of Wassily Leontief and other close friends from his Harvard circle.
Prophet of Innovation draws heavily on the late Robert Loring Allen's Opening Doors: The Life and Work of Joseph Schumpeter (Transaction Publishers, 1991) and on Richard Swedberg's Schumpeter: A Biography ( Princeton U. Press, 1991). McCraw focuses in greater detail on the tensions between Schumpeter's public persona and private turmoil and tragedies than do his predecessors. The Straus Professor Emeritus of Business History at the Harvard Business School, McCraw is a fine stylist, and the outcome is a gripping biography of an economist no less. Pulitzer awarded to it the 2007 prize for biography, betting it will appeal to the broad reading public.
The more narrowly scholarly reader, on the other hand, will find inconsistencies between McCraw's somewhat hagiographic assessments (shared with Loring Allen) and those of more jaundiced predecessors and reviewers. Robert Solow, who attended Schumpeter's advanced graduate theory and history of analysis seminars after World War II, reports that his theory lectures “bordered on the incoherent; they alluded to everything but analyzed nothing,” and the history course “felt like a stage display of multilingual erudition.” (“Heavy Thinker,” The New Republic, May 25, 2007). Solow accepts that this could reflect the despondent Schumpeter during his last years, although McCraw reports no such postwar decline in Schumpeter's enthusiasm for teaching. Schumpeter's hatred from the get-go of FDR and his policies, his Cliveden-like view of Hitler and the Axis as essential barriers to Bolshevism, and his dislike of Churchill for bamboozling the United States into fighting the wrong enemy are noted by all three biographers, but more apologetically by McCraw than by Swedberg. The latter records over a hundred of Schumpeter's aphorisms, published and unpublished, dating from 1936, and on the premise that “an aphorism is an attempt to express a general truth about the world and human affairs,” concludes that Schumpeter's adages collectively expressed “a universe of few and strong values, such as love and hate and victory and revenge. But there was no morality, no mercy, no forgiveness in Schumpeter's world. These were all signs of weakness: and weak people were subnormals, just as idealists were fools . . . . It was an inhuman universe and it lets us understand how Schumpeter must have suffered from having to live in it” (Swedberg, 191–93 and appendix 1). I lack the knowledge to judge which assessments are more valid, but the example illustrates the ambiguities of his character.
What was Schumpeter's most important contribution to economics? Mainstream economists, Solow, for example, single out his theory of economic development, which stressed the innovating entrepreneur and the business cycle as the essential driving forces of capitalist growth. First advanced during his pre-World War I youthful days, he revised and expanded it during the interwar decades, culminating in his Business Cycles: A Theoretical, Historical, and Statistical Analysis of the Capitalist Process (McGraw-Hill 1939). Economists tend to dismiss this riposte to Keynes's General Theory as a needless subtraction from Schumpeter's otherwise praiseworthy growth theorizing. McCraw, on the other hand, singles out Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy (Harper & Bros. 1942), revised in 1947, enlarged in 1950, and translated into some 14 languages, as Schumpeter's most influential work, at least for sociologists and political scientists. It has been described as Marx turned on his head. The endogenous market forces that would cause capitalism to evolve into socialism were not deepening class inequalities and class conflict, but the inexorable transference of the innovating function from the individual entrepreneur—building his family fortune from the temporary monopoly advantages of his big idea—to the large corporation competing in oligopolistic markets. The transfer is inexorable, because innovations in overall management, R & D, marketing and finance to exploit economies of scale and scope intensify under pressure of oligopolistic competition. This accelerates economic growth and the growing dominance of the corporation over family-owned business, but it also weakens the ideological support for capitalism's unequal distribution of the material gains. Since most of the skilled cadres needed to operate capitalist corporations would continue to operate them were the corporations socialized, many prefer the greater social peace from accepting rather than fighting off egalitarian reforms. Thus the move to socialism will be gradual and largely peaceful, rather than violent and revolutionary.
McCraw thinks this was not Schumpeter predicting the inevitability of socialism through other channels than Marx's, but rather citing warning trends for fellow conservatives to heed. However, it also further complicated another Schumpeter project dating back to his youth: to guide economists methodologically toward the development of a general scientific theory of economic change that integrated sociological, historical, econometric, and mathematical analysis. Capitalist innovating alters risk/return prospects and its institutions endogenously, creating narrow aggregation and ergodic limits to the usefulness of the econometric and mathematical components of the effort. In his later years, Schumpeter preached that economics would have to rely primarily on economic history and institutional research to advance its scientific program.
Mainstream economists paid him little mind. Graduate students of six top US economics departments responded overwhelmingly to a late 1980s survey that excellence in mathematics was very important, while a broad knowledge of the economics literature, or of the economy, was not (McCraw, 500). The picture may be changing somewhat. The 2007 Edward Elgar Publishing Catalogue of Heterodox Economics lists six recent titles on aspects of Schumpeterian economics, including a 1000-page collection of articles on different aspects of “Neo-Schumpeterian Economics.” Having already earned a “neo,” Schumpeter may be on his way to fulfilling Summers's forecast, because of his sensitivity to the many ideological and methodological disagreements with real world policy implications increasingly besetting economics, and the likelihood that it will all persist through at least much of the new century.
