The book under review is the revised version of a doctoral thesis, some parts of which have appeared already in several publications (xv–xvi). In the introduction, Marden F. Nichols presents her aim: to understand how Vitruvius, in his De Architectura, constructs at the same time both his own figure and his imagined reader, by contextualising his self-representation within the literary culture of his time. The study focuses mainly on the prefaces which begin each of the ten Books of the treatise, and on Books 6–7, dealing with houses and their decoration.
Ch. 1 is devoted to the interrelation between ‘Greek knowledge and the Roman world’. N. shows that Vitruvius vindicates a continuity between Roman culture and the Greek past, thus defining Romanness as a dynamic concept, which involves both the import of materials from across the Roman empire and the recognition of their origin. The following chapter tackles issues of social self-fashioning. N. compares the self-presentation of Horace and Vitruvius. Both have similar social status, as both had been apparitores, and more precisely scribes. Both claim to be unknown, but for both the issue is not fame but rather means of becoming famous. N. concludes this chapter by emphasising Vitruvius’ strategy of double distinction: he dismisses ‘false’ architects, whose existence compels patrons to engage in the architectural process, but he displays also his superiority over laymen, inasmuch as technical discourse allows him to define and enhance his own authorial power.
Ch. 3 is devoted to the role played by the house in the construction of the image of its owner. A survey of the works of Cato the Elder and Plautus shows that already in the second century b.c. a house could be envisioned as ‘a potential site of sumptuary vice’ (111), but that at the same time it was possible to evaluate luxurious building positively. Regarding the first century, N. uses Cicero and Horace to put Vitruvius in context and demonstrates the interdependence, in the works of all three authors, between their criticism of domestic display and the self-construction of their own authorial figure. Consequently, these writings cannot be taken as simple expressions of shared values among Romans. Ch. 4 deals with the famous Vitruvian criticism of iconographic change in painting (7.5). Rhetorical and literary tradition is the key to interpreting this passage. The story of Apaturius of Alabanda (7.5.5–7) allows Vitruvius to emphasise the dangerous character of the illusionistic painting and, by rejecting the artifices of the painters who represent things that cannot exist, to demonstrate his own honesty. The last chapter focuses on another anecdote in Book 7: the story of the vermilion walls of the scribe Faberius (7.9.2–3; cf. P. Gros, Arethusa 49/2 (2016), 359–60). N. proposes to read this story in the light of the tradition of Roman political invective. In this tradition, the house is used as a metaphor for its owner. Therefore, the common function of this anecdote and Apaturius’ story is to show that the public image of the owners depends upon their access to architectural knowledge, which in turn depends upon the reading of Vitruvius’ treatise. In an epilogue, N. compares Vitruvius and Mamurra, praefectus fabrum under Julius Caesar. She argues that the values and behaviours assigned to these two opposed figures derive from norms and prejudices surrounding professional conduct.
N.'s book is not only very interesting and instructive but also pleasant to read (despite some repetitions), and it offers a useful contribution to Vitruvian scholarship and to the study of the Roman house and Roman society as reflected and re-shaped by literature. However, some criticism is possible. In the case of 6.pr.5, frequently referred to by N., the individual whose expression changes by asking for something doubtful (petendo rem suspiciosam) is not the patron, as N. argues, but the architect (69–71); concerning the same passage, the suggestion to read ambigunt instead of ambiunt (188) is unconvincing, as it ignores the play on reciprocity across the whole sentence (rogant … ambient … rogatum … rogantem … dantes … accipientes … ambiuntur).
More importantly, the selection of materials implies some bias. A few examples follow. The construction of Vitruvius’ authority as a writer is closely linked to his self-presentation as an architect, and therefore to his presentation of the ‘true’ architect. It is a pity not to have properly used his description of the basilica he built in Fano (5.1.10, cf. 117 n. 134). A closer reading of this text could also allow us to understand better Vitruvius’ conception of the interplay between architectural skill and magnificentia. In Book 1, the passage related to the knowledge of law (1.1.10) would have been helpful to contextualise Vitruvius’ self-presentation as a mediator (13–14) and to understand the emphasis placed by Vitruvius on the leges (contracts) in 7.5.8 (177). Consideration of Book 5 suggests also some nuance to the view that ‘Vitruvius locates its audience in the city of Rome’ (14–15), inasmuch as it pertains no less (or even more) to Italy than to Rome. On a more theoretical level, it could have been useful to use Bourdieu's concept of the ‘field’ (champ) in order to go further in the analysis. Despite such remarks, N.'s approach is promising and thought-provoking, and her book deserves recommendation.
