Robert Morrison's book, Islam and Science, is the first important study of the works of Nizam al-Din al-Aʾraj al-Nisaburi (1270–1330), an Iranian polymath born in Nishapur to a Shiʿi family. Very little is known about his biography. In 1304 he went from Nishapur to Tabriz, where he was patronized by the Ilkhanid minister Saʿd al-Din al-Savaji (d. 1312) and seems to have maintained good relations with al-Savaji's co-minister, Rashid al-Din (d. 1318). Nothing is known about his life after the death of the Ilkhan Öljaytü (1304–16), although he seems to have stayed somewhere in India during the later stages of his life.
Al-Nisaburi was a scholar of religious sciences and astronomy, an interest not uncommon for the epoch. Nasir al-Din al-Tusi (d. 1274) and Qutb al-Din al-Shirazi (d. 1311), both extremely influential thinkers in al-Nisaburi's scholarly life, were preoccupied with the same subjects. The latter was al-Nisaburi's master, while al-Tusi was the author of the Tahrir al-Majisti and Tadhkira fi ʿIlm al-Hayʾa. Al-Nisaburi wrote commentaries on both works—Sharh Tahrir al-Majisti (1305) and Tawdih al-Tadhkira (1311)—and a Persian work on the Ilkhanid Tables, prepared in the Maragha observatory by al-Tusi (Kashfi Haqaʾiqi Ziji Ilkhani, 1308–1309). The language used is significant and agrees with an idea put forth by George Saliba in a book published in 1988 that Arabic was used for theoretical astronomy (Tahrir al-Majisti) and hayʾa (cosmology, Tawdih al-Tadhkira), disciplines not necessarily related to astrology and that corresponded to books that could be used for teaching in madāris. Morrison has established that Tawdih was actually studied in institutions of this kind. In contrast, Persian was the language for composing canons of zījes, a kind of astronomical literature whose main purpose was to compute planetary positions when casting a horoscope.
Apart from astronomy, al-Nisaburi wrote books on arithmetic, Arabic morphology, and rhetoric, and a commentary on the names of God. Morrison's study, however, largely focuses on the aforementioned astronomical works and the commentary on the Qurʾan (Gharaʾib al-Qurʾan wa-Raghaʾib al-Furqan). This is because Morrison's purpose is to explore interrelations between religion and science (mainly astronomy) and to prove that in al-Nisaburi's time both forms of knowledge were compatible and exerted mutual influence.
Al-Nisaburi seems to have been a moderate Shiʿa who was attracted by the shāfiʾî madhhab, due to the influence of his master, al-Shirazi. Morrison points to the fact that his scientific reasoning was often influenced by fiqh techniques and its technical terminology. He was also interested in Ashʾari kalām. In fact, his Gharaʾib al-Qurʾan clearly shows marks of the works of Fakhr al-Din al-Razi. Morrison studies carefully al-Nisaburi's opinions on polemical topics such as the eternity of the Qur'an and the divine attributes, but most of the book under review is dedicated to the influence of scientific doctrines in his interpretations of the Qurʾan. Al-Nisaburi analysed the attitudes of falāsifa and mutakallimūn and dealt with the problems of giving scientific explanations of natural events without excluding God's omnipotence. He rejected the atomism of the mutakallimūn and accepted the four elements of the falāsifa; these elements are secondary causes through which God acts over the world. The matter of heavens is different from the terrestrial one, but contrary to the opinions of the falāsifa, the heavens are not inviolable, for this would limit God's power to alter them. His interest in interpreting the Qurʾan in agreement with science led al-Nisaburi to give esoteric or metaphorical interpretations (taʾwīl), which he added to literal ones (tafsīr). Thus, when he discussed sura 67:5, “And we adorned the lower heaven with lamps,” he recalled that Fakhr al-Din al-Razi interpreted these lamps as stars and, consequently, considered the possibility of the existence of fixed stars below the orb of the Moon. As al-Nisaburi believed, in agreement with the opinions of astronomers, that the fixed stars are found in a single orb beyond the orb of Saturn. Indeed, he commented on the passage saying the lamps are uncertain beliefs created by God to delude astrologers. Taʾwīl and tafsīr were used by al-Nisaburi throughout his commentary, in which he distinguished carefully between the two techniques.
Astronomers have always tried to insist on the applications of astronomy to Islamic worship through the specialized discipline of mīqāt, which deals with problems such as the visibility of the new moon, the determination of the times of prayer, or the direction of the qibla. Al-Nisaburi was not concerned with these but insisted on the altogether different idea that astronomy provides information on God's creation. An example of this is his remark that God inclined the path of the Moon to that of the Sun in such a way that there are not eclipses every month. Therefore, God plays a role in determining when eclipses occur, and the same can be said about other astronomical phenomena. This attitude led al-Nisaburi to another surprising conclusion: astrology is permitted (mubāḥ) in Islam if one considers that the heavens act as an intermediary in God's control over the world. In a chapter of his Kashfi Haqaʾiqi Ziji Ilkhani, he argued that the stars act as secondary causes and that their influence is not the result of their own nature. Hence, astrology provides men with conjectural knowledge of how God controls the world through celestial motions, and, thus, intelligent people may draw conclusions about future events by way of intuition (ḥads) and experience (tajriba). Therefore, in al-Nisaburi's view, both astronomy and astrology are disciplines that can help scholars to understand God's creation.
Knowledge of God's world depends on having a firm understanding of the universe's configuration. This was exactly the purpose of hayʾa, studied in the Tawdih al-Tadhkira, which presented the best possible theoretical models for explaining God's control over celestial motions. Al-Nisaburi's need to describe a real world was an obvious consequence of his religious attitude and marks a difference between his approach and the position of later authors such as Shams al-Din al-Khafri (d. 1550). For his part, Shams al-Din al-Khafri designed four different but mathematically equivalent models for Mercury, all of which agreed with the principles of hayʾa but could not be considered more real than the others. In contrast, al-Nisaburi introduced five fundamental principles, largely derived from Ptolemy's Almagest (I, 3–7), which he based on observational and physical (not metaphysical) arguments. His insistence on observation is important: in order to be considered real, his planetary models had to have the same predictive capacity as the Ptolemaic ones. Human errors could be avoided by relying less on falsafa and more on observation. Al-Nisaburi dealt with the ishkālāt (ambiguities or, better, inconsistencies) in the Almagest, a basic topic of the hayʾa tradition, which had to be avoided in planetary models. Thus, he presented models proposed by al-ʿUrdi (d. 1266), al-Tusi, and al-Shirazi. To choose between equivalent models, al-Nisaburi adopted a principle of economy exemplified by his argument that there exist seven (instead of nine) orb cosmos or by his method of choosing between mathematically equivalent hypotheses (eccenter or epicycle for the sun). (His need to justify the motion of the solar apogee led him to prefer the eccentric solar model because the physical explanation was simpler.)
Al-Nisaburi's interest in observation led him to study astronomical instruments like the dioptre, the meridian ring, and the mural quadrant, and to consider their lack of accuracy in determining, for example, the diameters of the Sun and Moon or the timing of annular solar eclipses. He also discussed the exactness of different historical determinations of the obliquity of the ecliptic (the angle formed by the ecliptic and the equator), which seems to have diminished between Ptolemy's time and that of al-Nisaburi. This subject is often related to the historical estimations of precession, which, if past observations are considered accurate, led to the need for designing a model with variable precession (trepidation). Al-Nisaburi's approach was far more critical than that of Andalusian and Maghribi astronomers from the 11th century onward who blindly accepted the exactness of previous observations and designed trepidation and other models justifying a historical decrease of the obliquity of the ecliptic.
On the whole, Morrisson's book is most interesting and should attract the attention of all scholars interested in Islamic thought. To the best of my knowledge, it is the first serious approach to the historical interactions between science and Islam. Further studies of a similar nature on other scientists of the 13th and 14th centuries interested in religious knowledge could enlarge our knowledge of the subject. The book can be read without too much knowledge of the technical aspects of astronomy, which are described in appendices on observation and theoretical astronomy. The volume is well presented with a complete chronology of al-Nisaburi's works. I only wonder why publishers insist on printing the footnotes as endnotes, before the bibliography and the index; it is most frustrating for a reader interested in both text and notes.
