Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T19:52:15.568Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Evidence that uniform momentum zones originate from roughness sublayer structure interactions in fully rough channel turbulence

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  30 June 2022

Y. Zheng
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Texas at Dallas, Richardson, TX 75080, USA
W. Anderson*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Texas at Dallas, Richardson, TX 75080, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: wca140030@utdallas.edu

Abstract

Fully rough wall-sheared turbulence is composed of an inner and outer layer, the former occupied by sinuous structures sustained by the well-known autonomous inner cycle, the latter occupied by inclined parcels of momentum deviations relative to the average. The outer-layer structures are also known as uniform momentum zones (UMZs), where the presence of successive UMZs manifests instantaneously with a distinct ‘staircase’ pattern in streamwise velocity. Direct numerical simulation (DNS) of fully rough channel turbulence was recently used to interpret UMZs as wakes originating from antecedent bluff-body-like interactions within the inner layer (Anderson & Salesky, J. Fluid Mech., vol. 906, 2020, A8). Wake-scaling arguments agreed precisely with instantaneous results from DNS. Foremost among these results was evidence that the instantaneous wall-normal gradient of streamwise velocity exhibited scaling of ${\sim }x_3^{-1/2}$, where $x_3$ is wall-normal location; this is in contrast to logarithmic scaling, which requires the wall-normal gradient of streamwise velocity to scale as ${\sim }x_3^{-1}$. Herein, wake-scaling arguments have been advanced and compared against results from wall-modelled large-eddy simulation (LES). New results from the ‘bottom up’ wake-scaling arguments agree with LES results, such that the shear associated with the instantaneous staircase-like streamwise velocity follows a clear trend. We have leveraged conditional sampling during LES – predicated upon instantaneous low-frequency, high-magnitude surface stress values known to correspond to large-scale inertial-layer coherence – to further assess the predictive value of the wake-scaling arguments. Model results compare favourably.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Conceptual schematic of dynamical and hierarchical nature of hairpin packets originating within roughness sublayer and emanating into outer layer. Dark to light parcels of red and blue correspond to successive realizations of a relative streamwise momentum excess and deficit at a series of successive times (annotations provided), which manifest at later times as UMZs. Yellow line denotes inclination angle, $\gamma$, which sets the origin of a local Cartesian coordinate system, $\widehat {\boldsymbol x} = \{\hat {x}_1, \hat {x}_3 \}$. Grey region denotes interfacial shear between vertically adjacent UMZs, with vorticity thickness shown and idealized instantaneous (thin solid black) and Reynolds-averaged (thick solid black) streamwise velocity shown. Inset shows vorticity thickness and wake deficit. Superimposed is a yet-older parcel of streamwise momentum deficit (light blue). Abscissa and ordinate shown in linear and logarithmic scale, respectively, for illustrative purposes.

Figure 1

Table 1.Summary of simulation attributes; $u_\tau = 0.45$ m s$^{-1}$, $\delta = 1000$ m and $Re_\tau \sim {O}(10^{6})$.

Figure 2

Figure 2.First- and second-order turbulence statistics recovered a posteriori from LES of the cases in table 1. Vertical profiles of plane- and time-averaged (a–c) streamwise velocity and (d–e) streamwise–wall-normal stresses, for cases A (a,d), B (b,e) and C (c,f). In (a–c), green profile denotes logarithmic profile for predefined roughness length, $\ell /\delta = 1 \times 10^{-5}$, which is identical to the prescribed roughness length with each LES (see also § 3). In (d–f) profile colours correspond to: subgrid-scale stress, $\langle \tau _{13} \rangle _{12t} / u_\tau ^{2} (x_3)$ (black); resolved stresses, $\langle \tilde {u}_1^{\prime } \tilde {u}_3^{\prime } \rangle _{12t} /u_\tau ^{2} (x_3)$ (grey); and total stresses, $\langle \mathsf T_{13} \rangle _{12t} / u_\tau ^{2} (x_3) = \langle \tilde {u}_1^{\prime } \tilde {u}_3^{\prime } \rangle _{12t} / u_\tau ^{2} (x_3) + \langle \tau _{13} \rangle _{12t} /u_\tau ^{2} (x_3)$ (light grey). Resolved fluctuations are defined via standard protocols for channel turbulence, $\widetilde {\boldsymbol u}^{\prime } = \widetilde {\boldsymbol u} - \langle \widetilde {\boldsymbol u} \rangle _{12t}$.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Instantaneous velocity data from case C (table 1). Colourflood contours of resolved streamwise velocity fluctuations with (a) linear and (b) logarithmic ordinate scaling. In (a), the complete range of $\tilde {u}^\prime$ values at the arbitrary time step are shown; isocontours of the limiting 5 % values of vorticity thickness (equation (4.1)) are superimposed, for perspective, where $\delta _\omega$ has been signed by the local gradient and where positive and negative values correspond to solid black and solid grey isocontours, respectively. In (b), for perspective, zones of $\tilde {u}^\prime < 0$ and $\tilde {u}^\prime > 0$ are shown with solid zones of dark and light grey, respectively, with isocontours of $\partial _3 \tilde {u}_1^\prime = 1$ (red) and $\partial _3 \tilde {u}_1^\prime = -0.2$ (blue) included for perspective. In (a,b), solid yellow lines denote inclination angle, $\gamma = 16^{\circ }$ (Marusic & Heuer 2007). Instantaneous (c–g) streamwise and (h–l) vertical velocity profiles at locations ${\bigcirc{\kern-6pt 1}}$ to ${\bigcirc{\kern-6pt 5}}$ (locations denoted by vertical green lines in (a,b)). In (c–g) and (h–l), green profiles correspond to Reynolds-average streamwise velocity profile (logarithmic, based on $\ell /\delta = 1 \times 10^{-5}$, see also figure 2(a–c) and accompanying discussion) and vertical velocity profile ($\langle \tilde {u}_3 \rangle _{12t}(x_3) = 0$), respectively.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Vertical profiles of instantaneous velocity statistics from an arbitrary survey of streamwise–spanwise locations for cases A (a–c), B (d–f) and C (g–i), for (a,d,g) $\partial _3 \tilde {u}_1 ({\boldsymbol x}_l,x_3,t_i)$, (b,e,h) vorticity thickness (4.1) and (c,f,i) vertical velocity, $\tilde {u}_3 ({\boldsymbol x}_l,x_3,t_i)$. In all panels, red lines denote Reynolds-averaged profiles, i.e. $\mathrm {d}_3 \langle \tilde {u}_1 \rangle _{12t} (x_3) = u_\tau /(\kappa x_3) \sim x_3^{-1}$ (a,d,g), $\langle \delta _\omega \rangle _{12t} (x_3) = C x_3 \sim x_3$ (b,e,h), where $C$ is a proportionality constant used only for the purpose of illustration, and $\langle \tilde {u}_3 \rangle _{12t} (x_3) = 0$ (c,f,i). In (a,d,g), green profile represents the maximum value of $\partial _3 \tilde {u}_1 ({\boldsymbol x}_l,x_3,t_i)$ at each elevation. In addition, yellow profiles in (a,d,g) and (b,e,h) correspond to $\partial _3 \tilde {u}_1 ({\boldsymbol x}_l,x_3,t_i) \sim x_3^{-1/2}$ and $\delta _\omega \sim x_3^{1/2}$, respectively. The results in (a,d,g) and (c,f,i) are consistent with (2.20) and (2.15a,b), respectively.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Statistics of space-local surface stress, $\tau _{13}^{w} ({\boldsymbol x}_c,t)/\rho u_\tau ^{2}$, at central location, ${\boldsymbol x}_c = \{L_1/2, L_2/2 \}$. (a) Results for case B over an arbitrary sampling period during LES. (b) Resultant probability density function for all cases, where black, red and blue lines correspond to cases A, B and C. In both panels, light and dark grey lines illustrate sampling thresholds, $\tau _\alpha$ and $\tau _\beta$, respectively, used in subsequent conditional sampling (equation (4.2a,b); discussed in the text).

Figure 6

Figure 6.Conditionally averaged results for case B based on application of the conditional-sampling protocols outlined with (4.2a,b) for $\tau _\beta$ (a,c,e,g) and $\tau _\alpha$ (b,d,f,h). (a,b) Vertical gradient of conditionally sampled streamwise velocity normalized by $\varLambda = A x_3^{-1/2}$ (yellow lines) and $\varLambda = B x_3^{-1}$ (red lines), where $A$ and $B$ are proportionality constants used only to illustrate dependence upon $x_3$. (c,d) Conditionally sampled vorticity thickness alongside profiles $A x_3^{1/2}$ (yellow lines) and $B x_3^{1}$, where $A$ and $B$ are proportionality constants used only to illustrate dependence upon $x_3$. Colourflood contours of (e,f) conditionally sampled streamwise velocity and (g,h) vertical gradient of conditionally sampled streamwise velocity; yellow profile in both denotes structural inclination angle, $\gamma = 16^{\circ }$.