The Byzantine and Early Islamic Near East: Elites Old and New is sixth in a series of volumes representing workshops held at the University of Birmingham. This volume contains ten articles (plus introduction and conclusion) from several important and well-known scholars including Averil Cameron, Nadia Maria El Cheikh, and John Haldon. The articles (as well as the corresponding workshops) examine who formed the elite in late antiquity and how they both gained and displayed their power. As John Haldon states in the introduction, the collection of essays “examine[s] the ways in which the form and structure of social, political, cultural and economic elites at this time overlapped… In particular, we were concerned to locate the processes of change, to see how individuals—in their own particular patterns of behavior and response to change, and inflected by their own self-perception and group identities—made a difference” (p. 2).
Taken together, the essays cover a wide range of life and culture in late antiquity. For example, William and Fidelity Lancaster discuss bedouin societies in the Arabian Peninsula, Elizabeth Jeffreys examines Umayyads as depicted in Byzantine texts, and Zeev Rubin discusses the later Sasanian monarchy. All of the articles challenge scholars of late antiquity and the Byzantine world to think about elite groups in more complex terms. First and foremost, the authors prove that “elite” does not always refer to a sociopolitical group existing in a hierarchical relationship with a “nonelite” group largely excluded from public power. Instead, what constitutes an elite group is seldom fixed and almost always dependent upon lateral alliances as well as hierarchical power relations. The most important contribution of this volume is that the authors capture moments of cultural transition and political revolution that result in new expressions of elite identity.
Although I cannot review each individual article in the space permitted here, I would like to discuss three essays that demonstrate the book's wide range of methodological approaches. In the first essay Hugh Kennedy examines landed property and collection of its revenues as a major source of income for the Umayyad and early ʿAbbasid elite. Kennedy surveys an impressive array of primary sources to discuss the ways in which elite groups received land grants and then put that land to use. He demonstrates that Umayyad caliphs distributed many urban and rural land grants at no cost to themselves (from unclaimed or “dead lands”), especially to minor court officials such as chamberlains and local tax collectors. These land owners then cultivated the grants with urban development (e.g., bookstores, baths) or rural agriculture. In effect, they became an elite group mostly independent of the state. Abbasid leaders later claimed many of these land grants from their Umayyad counterparts but, on the whole, they still remained fairly independent of the state (at least during the 8th century).
The third article in the collection uses a very different methodology to examine the elite in early Byzantine Thessalonike. Leslie Brubaker studies the images and self-representations of donor-patrons evident in the 6th- and 7th-century mosaics of Hagios Demetrios. After discussing the difficulties in dating the various mosaics and artistic styles, she concludes that extant images reveal a subtle shift in elite self-representation. The images that she dates as early 7th century present Saint Demetrios as a general healer to individual petitioners and their families; later 7th-century images, on the contrary, show Demetrios as a civic hero responding to town officials who offer more “civic-minded” prayers. Brubaker links this iconography with the general shift from an aristocratic urban elite based on kinship ties to more structured civic and ecclesiastical hierarchies recognized by the “state.”
In the collection's final essay, Michael G. Morony examines elite status in Iraq and Iran after the Islamic conquest. He explains that Iranian elites did not disappear after the Arab invasions; instead, the conquests allowed for a larger range of social statuses for (former) Sasanian nobility and priests alike. He also demonstrates that Arab conquerors even relied upon (thus continuing) Sasanian symbolism in displaying their new authority: for example, postconquest stuccos of Sasanian style hunting scenes. This essay, oddly perhaps, epitomizes the collection's major strengths and weaknesses. Morony includes a convincing argument, accessible to both undergraduates and graduate students, with solid historical scholarship. In contrast, the essay tries to encapsulate in twenty pages a complex critique of religious texts (specifically apocalyptic literature) and Persian/Arab material culture. The essay—like the book—thus often seems scattered, lacking context or central argument, although this is probably unavoidable in a text that covers such a wide range of both geography (from Persia to Rome) and time (from late antiquity to the 9th-century ʿAbbasid state).
