For any given historical context, the boundary between the natural and the supernatural defines the scope of natural inquiry (and also of theology). In his Wiles Lectures at the Queen's University of Belfast in 2006, Robert Bartlett addressed the nature of this boundary in the Middle Ages. The book under review collects these lectures as four loosely related chapters.
The opening chapter takes up some of the theoretical questions involved in distinguishing the concepts of natural and supernatural in the period. An obvious criterion for making the distinction centres on the nature of causation: natural events have causes that exist entirely in the natural, created order; God directly causes supernatural events. For medieval thinkers, miracles were prime examples of supernatural events. According to Aquinas, miracles fell into three categories: ‘above nature’, ‘beyond nature’ and ‘against nature’ (p. 8). Christian thinkers also defined miracles by three criteria: by their causation, by the sense of wonder they produced and by their function as signs. Miracles played an especially important role in the process of canonization, in which it became necessary to ascertain the legitimacy of claims that the would-be saint had actually performed miracles, and that the cures or other purportedly miraculous effects had not resulted from natural causes alone. Establishing genuine miracles thus required knowledge of the workings of the natural order. In this way, Bartlett shows (with specific examples taken from the literature on saints), knowledge of the supernatural depended on knowledge of nature.
Natural and supernatural intertwine in a different way in the third chapter, on the inhabitants of the world. A common medieval distinction classified them as follows: ‘God created three kinds of living spirit: one which is not enclosed in flesh; another which is enclosed in flesh but does not die; and a third which is enclosed in flesh and dies with the flesh’ (p. 72). Angels were of the first kind; humans, because they possessed immortal souls, the second; and animals the third. Bartlett's discussion of angels and demons leads to an extended discussion of witches and medieval views about the reality of their ability to fly at night and perform other magical deeds. For a reader not thoroughly grounded in the medieval Church's changing attitude towards witchcraft – calling the allegations illusory in the tenth century and later prosecuting witches for the magical powers acquired from the Devil as a reward for their heretical worship of the Prince of Darkness in the fifteenth century – this part of his discussion might prove to be confusing. From angels and demons, Bartlett moves on to discuss some of the weird animals Pliny described in his Natural History. Medieval writers continued to discuss cyno-cephali (basically humans with the heads of dogs), humanlike creatures that had faces on their chests and creatures with one large foot that they could use as a built-in umbrella. Bartlett discusses the dog-heads at length, demonstrating how they functioned in medieval discourse as a way of determining the boundaries between humans and animals.
The other two chapters have their interest too. In the second, Bartlett considers several ideas about the physical universe, comparing the views of various theologians and philosophers with those of the common people. In one especially intriguing passage, he discusses the theologians' reactions to the popular response to a lunar eclipse. As men having university training, theologians were acquainted with the physical causes of eclipses, and reacted very negatively to the behaviour of some villagers who shouted at the moon to help prevent its being consumed during an eclipse. The theologians dismissed the villagers' beliefs as magical, based on the belief in the efficacy of incantations. In the fourth chapter, Bartlett turns to consider Roger Bacon's philosophy and experimental approach to knowledge of the world. Briefly describing Bacon's natural philosophy, Bartlett emphasizes the Franciscan's naturalism, at the same time describing his belief that knowledge of the sciences would provide a powerful weapon to fight the Antichrist, whose arrival seemed imminent.
Despite Bartlett's engaging style and his use of interesting examples, the book suffers from some serious flaws. Lack of adequate analysis of the basic concepts presents the most serious problem. Although he sets out criteria for distinguishing between the natural and the supernatural, he fails to clarify further concepts such as magic, miracle and wonder. Consequently, the point of many of the examples he uses is not entirely clear. For example, by the late Middle Ages, the Church regarded the practice of witchcraft per se as a form of heresy, not magic. The Devil or demons were thought to give witches the ability to use magic to carry out their evil deeds. This point does not emerge from Bartlett's discussion. In other examples, he fails to place the figures he discusses in their historical contexts. He never mentions the Augustinian and Neoplatonic assumptions that guided Roger Bacon's natural philosophy – assumptions that lay at the basis of the Franciscan tradition and distinguished it from the Aristotelian Dominicans. Many of the items cited in the bibliography are very old, and many important more recent studies are absent, such as Lorraine Daston and Katharine Park's Wonders and the Order of Nature (1998), Edward Grant's books on medieval science, and David Lindberg's important work on Roger Bacon.
For its sheer interest, The Natural and the Supernatural in the Middle Ages seems ready-made for recommendation to students. But unless they can be engaged in extended discussions of some of the fundamental contextual and analytical issues missing from the book, the temptation should be resisted.
