You and I are becoming palm trees. These puzzling words appear on page 1 of Palma Africana, the latest book by Michael Taussig, the enigmatic and often controversial Class of 1933 Professor of Anthropology at Columbia University. Adjectives such as unconventional, visionary, not-your-average, spring to mind when following Taussig's narrative and meandering thoughts through literary theory and ethnographic description. The latter is set for the most part in the northern swamplands of the Momposina Depression in Colombia, where the arrival of oil palm monocultures has clashed with traditional peasant lifestyles. Paramilitary groups at the behest of oil palm conglomerates threaten campesinos and murder their community leaders to impose agribusiness law and order. They destroy farmers’ crops, flood their fields and block campesinos’ access to their common lands. Although paramilitary gangs were officially dissolved during the Álvaro Uribe administration in the early 2000s as part of a demobilisation process, they quickly resurfaced in the shape of criminal gangs, or BACRIM (short for bandas criminales). Throughout the book Taussig calls them ‘(X)paramilitaries’.
Oil palm (elaeis guineensis), in Taussig's view, is like ‘the new sugar’: ‘just as sugar … was to colonialism, so oil palm is the postcolonial equivalent in terms of economic, social, and ecological impact’ (p. 4). We don't get much statistical evidence for this claim. He notes, however, that by 2020 world production will have doubled from what it was in 2000 – a staggering figure if true – with palm oil being an essential ingredient not only in most processed foods, but also in make-up and nail polish. It is of course also used to produce biofuel. In sum, ‘palm oil is an elixir from which all manner of being emerges. The metamorphic sublime. An alchemist's dream; finally … you and I are becoming palm trees’ (p. 1). Aha, puzzle resolved.
With the expansion of oil palm monoculture, the local ecology of the Momposina Depression was radically re-shaped, as swamplands were drained and dykes built. Campesinos’ access to lands was severely restricted, their cooperatives terrorised by henchmen. Death threats and limpieza social (‘social cleansing’) entered the everyday vocabulary. Of course, this was not the first time that campesinos had come under pressure in the region. In the 1980s and 1990s it was mostly cattle ranchers that harassed the swamp-dwellers to gain access to their lands.
Taussig examines these conflicts from the village of Las Pavas, built on sandy soil on the charming-sounding Island of the Papaya Grove, located at the junction of the Cauca and Magdalena rivers. Here, Taussig the ethnographer shines, treating the reader to beautiful ethnographic observations of everyday life that really bring this place to life:
Far off under a fierce sun I could see Efraín's adolescent daughter washing clothes in the shade of a crude thatch ramada. I could feel the thump of the clothes being beaten against some solid object, then the sound of the heavy wet material whacked as if to death, on and on. Her shadow was a silhouette sliding on the horizon as she walked back and forth over the clothes spread on the ground while we talked. (p. 42)
I felt also strangely attracted to a detailed description of the slaughter and skinning of a cow (pp. 106–10). Ample photographs and sketches are spread throughout the book and always commented on.
Yet, if this all suggests a straightforward narrative in Palma Africana, it is anything but. There are no chapters or subheadings in the book. Instead it is made up of sections headed by Roman numerals. Taussig regards the book as a ‘serpentine text: detailed, anecdotal, montaged, and jumping through puddles of tedium’ (p. 28). For him, ‘I'm trying to figure out what I'm doing as I go along … Things arise in writing as in a dream’ (p. 29). Almost half of the book consists of ruminations on this ‘cut-up method’, which he borrows from William Burroughs, whom he quotes: ‘Words know where they belong better than you do … They don't like to be kept in pages. Cut the pages and let the words out’ (p. 2).
To the reader, this seemingly unconventional narrative strategy may appear humorous at some times and bewildering at others. Yet certain bibliophiles will no doubt be annoyed by its seeming haphazardness. Which, I dare suggest, is pretty much Taussig's intention, though. Follow him in his meandering trains of thought at your own peril and allow your mind to go all over the place. To then come back and make connections that go beyond the typical accusations found in NGO reports and academic papers on violence and terror in Colombia, which have ceased to shock us, as this violence has become terribly routinised. Taussig's question is always how to write about this – where ‘this’ is always more complex and entangled than our words seem to suggest.
On his serpentine journey, Taussig enlists the services of many an illustrious travel companion (mostly European writers, I should add). As always in Taussig's writings, Walter Benjamin's musings figure prominently, this time his reflections on the storyteller's role in bourgeois society. But we also encounter literary luminaries such as Jean Genet, Franz Kafka, Marcel Proust, Thomas Mann, Roland Barthes and Heinrich Heine. The latter two appear on a number of occasions, introduced early on as a duet of Orientalist dreamers enthralled by the magic of the seductively bending palm tree (pp. 19–20). Barthes in particular resonates with Taussig, as a brother in arms, it seems. He is enthralled by the hermeneutical writing in his autobiographical work Roland Barthes by Roland Barthes, ‘which, by the way, is also a serpentine book’ (p. 214). Just as Barthes, Taussig is ‘consumed with interest about writing [and] the pleasure of the text’ (ibid.), and the reader may be forgiven for thinking that Palma Africana could perhaps also have been titled Michael Taussig by Michael Taussig.
