Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T07:09:58.465Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Allies of the Weak: La Résistance and Jews in the Holocaust

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 March 2025

KASIA NALEWAJKO*
Affiliation:
Collegio Carlo Alberto, Italy
*
Kasia Nalewajko, Assistant Professor of Political Science, Department of Social Sciences, Collegio Carlo Alberto, Italy, kasia.nalewajko@carloalberto.org
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Do insurgents help or hinder survival of the targets of genocide? A common view in political science holds that insurgents’ presence attracts state violence against civilians. In contrast to this, I use multiple archival collections on WWI and WWII military personnel, Holocaust victims’ records, and testimonies of survivors and rescuers to show that insurgent presence in fact decreased local numbers of Holocaust victims. To ensure that the relationship is causal, I use an instrumental variable exploiting the exogenous number of WWI military deaths, which increased insurgent enlistment in WWII. Case studies of mechanisms reveal that individual insurgents helped the Jews mainly out of “moral” motivations, by using tactics they had developed to fight the incumbent. By zooming out of times of increased counterinsurgency and studying the specific needs of genocide targets, this article nuances existing literature and points to an overlooked source of variation in genocide survival.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2025. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of American Political Science Association
Figure 0

Table 1.Insurgents’ Motivations for or Against Helping

Figure 1

Figure 1.Emergence and Survival of La Résistance Groups with Chosen Deportation ConvoysNote: Timeline includes 279 La Résistance networks (“réseaux”) and 44 movements (“mouvements”) (Marcot 2006, 104–11; 114–43; 1082–8). The vertical lines refer to the dates of key deportations of Jews from France: Convoy 1 stands for the first train of Jewish deportees; Convoy 3 for the first train of Jewish deportees that included women and children; Convoy 79 was the last convoy to depart from France.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Holocaust Victims by Place of Arrest or MurderNote: Units are counties (“cantons”) by their 1940 boundaries.

Figure 3

Figure 3.La Résistance Group Membership by Group Type, Nationality, and EthnicityNote: Left-hand-side bars in each group type denote foreigners and right-hand bars French insurgents. The final explanatory variable includes only the insurgents of the second and fourth columns from the left, FFI and FFC French, gentile insurgents (in red). FFI were maquis guerrillas and irregular volunteer soldiers. FFC were networks gathering intelligence, organising sabotage actions and evasion routes. Forces Fraçaises Libres (FFL) were members of De Gaulle’s regular army. Résistance Intérieure Française (RIF) were not insurgents, but people who due to some services for the resistance obtained military pension.

Figure 4

Table 2.OLS Results

Figure 5

Table 3.Main Results. Dependent Variable: Proportion Holocaust Victims (Logged)

Figure 6

Table 4.Overview of Selected Cases

Figure 7

Table 5.Contexts in Which Insurgency Is Mentioned in Survivors’ (USC) and Rescuers’ (YV) Testimonies

Figure 8

Table 6.Rescuers and Rescuees in Righteous Households

Figure 9

Figure 4.Linear Probability Estimates of Likelihood of Performing Specific Rescue Activities, by Rescuer ProfileNote: Civilians without links to insurgents are baseline for comparison. The coefficient lines are 90% and 95% confidence intervals with robust standard errors. Units of analysis are individual YV Righteous rescuers from France (N = 2,466). See Tables A9–A12 in the Dataverse repository for results in table format.

Supplementary material: File

Nalewajko supplementary material

Nalewajko supplementary material
Download Nalewajko supplementary material(File)
File 3.6 MB
Submit a response

Comments

No Comments have been published for this article.