Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T19:11:01.672Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

A numerical study of a weakly stratified turbulent wake

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 July 2015

J. A. Redford
Affiliation:
Aerodynamics and Flight Mechanics, University of Southampton, Highfield, Southampton SO17 1BJ, UK
T. S. Lund
Affiliation:
NorthWest Research Associates – CORA Division, Colorado Research Associates, 3380 Mitchell Lane, Boulder, CO 80301, USA
G. N. Coleman*
Affiliation:
Computational AeroSciences, NASA Langley Research Center, Hampton, VA 23681, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: g.n.coleman@nasa.gov

Abstract

Direct numerical simulation (DNS) of a time-developing turbulent wake evolving in a stably stratified background is presented. A large initial Froude number is chosen to allow the wake to become fully turbulent and axisymmetric before stratification affects the spreading rate of the mean defect. Turbulence statistics are formed by averaging over the homogeneous streamwise direction of a domain that is larger than earlier stratified-wake simulations in order to reduce the statistical uncertainty. The DNS results are used to cast light on the mechanisms that lead to the various states of this flow – namely the three-dimensional (essentially unstratified), non-equilibrium (or ‘wake-collapse’) and quasi-two-dimensional (or ‘two-component’) regimes, previously observed for wakes embedded in both weakly and strongly stratified backgrounds. For this relatively high-initial-Reynolds- and Froude-number simulation, we find that the signature reduction in the rate of decay of the maximum mean defect velocity during the wake-collapse regime is due to buoyancy-induced alterations of the turbulence structure, which weaken and redistribute the Reynolds shear stresses whose gradients appear in the streamwise mean momentum equation. The change in the rate of decay of the turbulence kinetic energy (TKE) observed during the wake-collapse regime (which occurs well after the mean velocity decay reduction begins) is not caused by transfer of turbulent gravitational potential energy to TKE, as has been previously suggested. The results instead reveal that the reduction in TKE decay – which for this flow, with its relatively weak internal waves, eventually leads to TKE growth, heralding the arrival of the two-component regime – is caused by an increase in the rate of TKE production associated with the wake structure becoming increasingly two-dimensional, such that the lateral Reynolds shear stress, $-\overline{u^{\prime }v^{\prime }}$ , becomes dominant. The present results are also compared with those of previous simulations at different Froude and Reynolds numbers, and whose initial conditions contain different turbulence structures. This comparison confirms a strong degree  of commonality in the late-wake behaviour, which lends support to the hypothesis that all wakes in stably stratified environments achieve a universal state in the final stages of decay.

Information

Type
Papers
Copyright
© 2015 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Figure 1.Histories of the maximum mean velocity defect $U_{d}$, buoyancy Reynolds number $Re_{b}$ and root-mean-square streamwise $u^{\prime }$, lateral $v^{\prime }$ and vertical $w^{\prime }$ velocity fluctuations at the wake centreline. The curve fit in (a) is given by $(U_{d}/U_{do})^{-3/2}=3.1(Nt-0.645)$, while in (b) $U_{d}/U_{do}=0.47(Nt-0.645)^{-2/3}$ shown for $Nt<10$, $U_{d}/U_{do}=0.25(Nt+1.0)^{-1/4}$ for $3 and $U_{d}/U_{do}=2.05(Nt-10)^{-0.85}$ for $Nt>30$. The $U_{d}(t)$ interpolants in (b) intersect at $Nt\approx 6$ and $45$. The buoyancy Reynolds number in the inset to (b) is defined as $Re_{b}=\{{\it\epsilon}_{tke}\}/4{\rm\pi}h_{y}h_{z}{\it\nu}N^{2}\approx \langle {\it\epsilon}_{tke}\rangle /{\it\nu}N^{2}$.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Histories of mean wake length scales $\ell$ and growth rates ${\it\beta}$ in (a) the vertical and (b) the lateral direction. The curve fit for $\ell$ is given by $r_{z}^{\ast }/h_{o}=r_{y}^{\ast }/h_{o}=1.23(N{\it\tau})^{1/3}$ for $Nt<10$, where $N{\it\tau}=Nt-Nt_{vo}$ and $Nt_{vo}=0.645$ (figure 13b). At $Nt=0$, $r_{z}^{\ast }=r_{y}^{\ast }=r_{o}^{\ast }=0.865h_{o}$. The vertical and lateral growth rates are respectively ${\it\beta}_{z}=(1/U_{d})\,\text{d}r_{z}^{\ast }/\text{d}t$ and ${\it\beta}_{y}=(1/U_{d})\,\text{d}r_{y}^{\ast }/\text{d}t$.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Profile of the mean streamwise velocity in (a) the vertical and (b) the lateral plane through the wake centreline. The Gaussian idealization is $\overline{u}/U_{d}=\exp (-\!\ln (2)s^{2})$, where $s$ is either $(y-y_{c})/h_{y}$ or $(z-z_{c})/h_{z}$. The coordinates $(y_{0},z_{0})$ and $(y_{c},z_{c})$ respectively define the initial and current location of the wake centreline, given by the centroid of the mean velocity defect.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Transfer terms in the budgets of the mean kinetic energy $\text{MKE}=\overline{u}_{i}\overline{u}_{i}/2$ (3.1), turbulence kinetic energy $\text{TKE}=\overline{u_{i}^{\prime }u_{i}^{\prime }}/2$ (3.6), and turbulence potential energy $\text{TPE}=(g\overline{{\it\rho}^{\prime }{\it\rho}^{\prime }}/2)/{\it\rho}_{\infty }|{\it\Gamma}|$:1, TKE production $\mathscr{P}_{tke}$ (from MKE); 2, MKE dissipation $D_{iijj}$ (transfer to internal/thermal energy IE); 3, Mean buoyancy transfer $\mathscr{B}_{mke}=-g\overline{{\it\rho}}\,\overline{w}/{\it\rho}_{\infty }$ (exchange with mean potential energy $\text{MPE}=(g\overline{{\it\rho}}\,\overline{{\it\rho}}/2)/{\it\rho}_{\infty }|{\it\Gamma}|$);4, Turbulent buoyancy transfer $\mathscr{B}_{tke}$ (exchange with TPE); 5, TKE dissipation ${\it\epsilon}_{tke}$ (transfer to IE); 6, internal-wave radiation $\mathscr{W}_{tke}$ (lost to far field FF); 7, TPE production $-g(\overline{{\it\rho}^{\prime }u_{i}^{\prime }}/{\it\rho}_{\infty }|{\it\Gamma}|)(\partial \overline{{\it\rho}}/\partial x_{i})$ (from MPE); 8, TPE dissipation $({\it\alpha}_{T}g/{\it\rho}_{\infty }|{\it\Gamma}|)\overline{(\partial {\it\rho}^{\prime }/\partial x_{i})(\partial {\it\rho}^{\prime }/\partial x_{i})}$ (entropy production ${\mathcal{P}}_{s}$ due to heat conduction). See (3.1) and (3.6) for definitions relating to MKE and TKE budgets, and, e.g., Kundu (1990) regarding MPE and TPE budgets. Single solid-line arrows indicate ‘production’ terms, with direction defined such that term acts as source. Dashed-line arrows denote irreversible sinks.

Figure 4

Figure 5.(a) Components of the integrated mean kinetic energy $\{K_{{\it\alpha}{\it\alpha}}\}=\{\overline{u}_{{\it\alpha}}\overline{u}_{{\it\alpha}}/2\}$ (no sum on ${\it\alpha}$). Values are normalized by the MKE at $Nt=0$, $\{K_{ii}\}_{o}=\{K_{11}\}_{o}+\{K_{22}\}_{o}+\{K_{33}\}_{o}$. (b) Dominant terms in the budget of the MKE components, in units of $U_{r}^{3}L_{r}$, where $U_{r}=2.09U_{do}$ and $L_{r}=h_{o}$. (These arbitrary scales are implicitly defined by the non-dimensionalization used to prescribe the radius, spacing and circulation of the vortex rings in the initial condition field.) One should note the signs of $\{P_{2222}\}$ and $\{\mathscr{B}_{mke}\}=\{B_{33}\}$ (open symbols), which (unlike all the other terms) both act as sources in their respective $+\text{d}\{K_{{\it\alpha}{\it\alpha}}\}/\text{d}t$ balances.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Terms in the mean streamwise momentum budget at $N{\it\tau}=2.5$: (a) rate of change $\partial \overline{u}/\partial t$; (b) advection $-\overline{v}\partial \overline{u}/\partial y-\overline{w}\partial \overline{u}/\partial z$; (c) Reynolds-stress divergence $-\partial \overline{u^{\prime }v^{\prime }}/\partial y-\partial \overline{u^{\prime }w^{\prime }}/\partial z$; (d) viscous-stress divergence ${\it\nu}(\partial ^{2}\overline{u}/\partial y^{2}+\partial ^{2}\overline{u}/\partial z^{2})$. The size and shape of the mean defect are indicated by closed solid-line curves, which denote $\overline{u}=0.05U_{d}$ and $0.5U_{d}$. Budget terms are given in units of $U_{r}^{2}/L_{r}$, where $U_{r}=2.09U_{do}$ and $L_{r}=h_{o}$.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Terms in the mean streamwise momentum budget at $N{\it\tau}=18$ (NEQ regime): (a) rate of change $\partial \overline{u}/\partial t$; (b) $-\partial \overline{u}\,\overline{w}/\partial z$; (c) vertical advection $-\overline{w}\partial \overline{u}/\partial z$; (d) lateral advection $-\overline{v}\partial \overline{u}/\partial y$; (e) vertical Reynolds-stress divergence $-\partial \overline{u^{\prime }w^{\prime }}/\partial z$; (f) lateral Reynolds-stress divergence $-\partial \overline{u^{\prime }v^{\prime }}/\partial y$; (g) vertical viscous-stress divergence ${\it\nu}\partial ^{2}\overline{u}/\partial z^{2}$. The size and shape of the mean defect are indicated by closed solid-line curves, which denote $\overline{u}=0.05U_{d}$ and $0.5U_{d}$. Budget terms are given in units of $U_{r}^{2}/L_{r}$.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Terms in the mean streamwise momentum budget at $N{\it\tau}=82$ (Q2D regime): (a) rate of change $\partial \overline{u}/\partial t$; (b) $-\partial \overline{u}\,\overline{w}/\partial z$; (c) vertical advection $-\overline{w}\partial \overline{u}/\partial z$; (d) lateral advection $-\overline{v}\partial \overline{u}/\partial y$; (e) lateral Reynolds-stress divergence $-\partial \overline{u^{\prime }v^{\prime }}/\partial y$; (f) vertical viscous-stress divergence ${\it\nu}\partial ^{2}\overline{u}/\partial z^{2}$. The size and shape of the mean defect are indicated by closed solid-line curves, which denote $\overline{u}=0.05U_{d}$ and $0.5U_{d}$. Budget terms are given in units of $U_{r}^{2}/L_{r}$. The vertical Reynolds-stress divergence $-\partial \overline{u^{\prime }w^{\prime }}/\partial z$ and lateral viscous-stress divergence ${\it\nu}\partial ^{2}\overline{u}/\partial y^{2}$ are negligible compared with the terms shown.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Terms in the mean streamwise momentum budget at $N{\it\tau}=586$ (late Q2D regime): (a) rate of change $\partial \overline{u}/\partial t$; (b) lateral Reynolds-stress divergence $-\partial \overline{u^{\prime }v^{\prime }}/\partial y$; (c) vertical viscous-stress divergence ${\it\nu}\partial ^{2}\overline{u}/\partial z^{2}$. The size and shape of the mean defect are indicated by closed solid-line curves, which denote $\overline{u}=0.05U_{d}$ and $0.5U_{d}$. Budget terms are given in units of $U_{r}^{2}/L_{r}$. The mean vertical momentum divergence $-\partial \overline{u}\,\overline{w}/\partial z$, advection $-\overline{v}\partial \overline{u}/\partial y-\overline{w}\partial \overline{u}/\partial z$, vertical Reynolds-stress divergence $-\partial \overline{u^{\prime }w^{\prime }}/\partial z$ and lateral viscous-stress divergence ${\it\nu}\partial ^{2}\overline{u}/\partial y^{2}$ are negligible compared with the terms shown.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Histories of (a) the cross-wake-averaged turbulence potential and kinetic energy and (b) the Reynolds-stress anisotropy $\unicode[STIX]{x1D623}_{ij}=\langle |\overline{u_{i}^{\prime }u_{j}^{\prime }}|\rangle /2\langle k\rangle -{\it\delta}_{ij}/3$. The inset plot in (a) shows components scaled by local $U_{d}$.

Figure 10

Figure 11.History of terms in the budget of the integrated TKE $\{k\}$. Terms in (a) are given in units of $U_{r}^{3}L_{r}$, those in (b) as a fraction of the local $\{{\it\epsilon}_{tke}\}$. The interpolant in (a) (chain-double-dot curve) is given by $A_{{\it\epsilon}}(N{\it\tau})^{-5/3}=A_{{\it\epsilon}}(Nt-Nt_{vo})^{-5/3}$, with $(A_{{\it\epsilon}},Nt_{vo})=(0.00138,0.645)$. Production terms not shown are either zero because of homogeneity ($\{P_{1111}\}=\{P_{2211}\}=\{P_{3311}\}\equiv 0$) or negligible ($\{P_{2233}\}\approx \{P_{3322}\}\approx 0$). Components of dissipation rate $\tilde{{\it\epsilon}}_{{\it\alpha}{\it\alpha}}={\it\nu}\overline{(\partial u_{{\it\alpha}}^{\prime }/\partial x_{j})(\partial u_{{\it\alpha}}^{\prime }/\partial x_{j})}$ (no sum on ${\it\alpha}$), where $\tilde{{\it\epsilon}}_{ii}={\it\epsilon}_{tke}-{\it\nu}\partial ^{2}\overline{u_{i}^{\prime }u_{j}^{\prime }}/\partial x_{i}\partial x_{j}$, and ${\it\epsilon}_{tke}=2{\it\nu}\overline{s_{ij}^{\prime }s_{ij}^{\prime }}$.

Figure 11

Table 1.Summary of comparison cases.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Histories of mean (a,b) Froude number $Fr_{d}=U_{d}/Nh$ and (c,d) Reynolds number $Re_{d}=U_{d}h/{\it\nu}$ for the present and previous simulations (see table 1).

Figure 13

Figure 13.Histories of (a) the maximum velocity $U_{d}$, (b) the height-to-width ratio $\ell _{z}/\ell _{y}$, (c) the height $\ell _{z}$ and (d) the width $\ell _{y}$ of the mean defect for the present and previous simulations (see table 1). The maximum defect velocity $U_{d}$ in (a) for Brucker & Sarkar’s (2010) case TR50F$_{\infty }$08 (but not TR10F$_{\infty }$40) is replaced by their $U_{1}^{mke}$. Integral measures are used for the height and width for the present DNS, with $\ell _{z}=r_{z}^{\ast }$, $\ell _{y}=r_{y}^{\ast }$, and $\ell _{o}$ the value of $r_{z}^{\ast }=r_{y}^{\ast }$ at $Nt=0$. For Brucker & Sarkar’s (2010) case TR50F$_{\infty }$08, $\ell _{z}$ and $\ell _{y}$ are respectively represented by integral scales (in their notation) $R_{3}$ and $R_{2}$, with $\ell _{o}$ the half-radius of the initial Gaussian mean velocity profile, while for Diamessis et al. (2011), and effectively for Gourlay et al. (2001), $\ell _{z}=h_{z}$, $\ell _{y}=h_{y}$ and $\ell _{o}=h_{o}$, where $h_{z}$ and $h_{y}$ are determined from fitting an assumed Gaussian profile. The inset plots show unstratified similarity diagnostics for (a) the velocity ${\it\chi}=(U_{d}/U_{do})^{-3/2}$ and (b) the height ${\it\xi}_{z}=(\ell _{z}/\ell _{o})^{3}$ (lower curve/symbols) and width ${\it\xi}_{y}=(\ell _{y}/\ell _{o})^{3}$ (upper curve/symbols); these are used to define the virtual time origin $t_{vo}$ for each case: $Nt_{vo}=0.645$ for the present DNS, $Nt_{vo}=0.2$ for Brucker & Sarkar’s TR50F$_{\infty }$08, $Nt_{vo}=-0.5$ for Diamessis et al. and $Nt_{vo}=0$ for Gourlay et al. and Brucker & Sarkar’s TR10F$_{\infty }$40. For the present DNS, the linear curve fits for ${\it\chi}$ and ${\it\xi}$ (thin solid lines) are ${\it\chi}=(U_{d}/U_{do})^{-3/2}=BN{\it\tau}$ and ${\it\xi}=(r^{\ast }/r_{o}^{\ast })^{3}=CN{\it\tau}$, where $N{\it\tau}=Nt-Nt_{vo}$ and $(B,C,Nt_{vo})=(3.1,2.9,0.645)$.

Figure 14

Figure 14.Histories of the rescaled mean defect (a,c) as a Q2D power-law/similarity diagnostic and (b,d) with respect to the Q2D time shift $Nt_{0}$, assuming (a,b) $n=3/4$ and (c,d) $n=0.85$, for the present and previous simulations (see table 1). The thin solid curves in (a,c) are linear curve fits of the Q2D diagnostic (which for Gourlay et al. (2001) and case TR10F$_{\infty }$40 of Brucker & Sarkar (2010) are nearly coincident), used to define the time shift $Nt_{0}$ in (b,d), such that for (b) ($n=3/4$) $Nt_{0}=:19$ (present DNS), $-55$ (Gourlay et al.2001), $-63.5$ (Brucker & Sarkar’s (2010) case TR50F$_{\infty }$08), $-57$ (Brucker & Sarkar’s (2010) case TR10F$_{\infty }$40) and $11$ (Diamessis et al.’s (2011) case R100F$_{\infty }$64), and for (d) ($n=0.85$) $Nt_{0}=:7$ (present DNS), $-70$ (Gourlay et al.2001), $-66.5$ (Brucker & Sarkar’s (2010) case TR50F$_{\infty }$08), $-71$ (Brucker & Sarkar’s (2010) case TR10F$_{\infty }$40) and $-3$ (Diamessis et al.’s (2011) case R100F$_{\infty }$64).

Figure 15

Figure 16.Radial profiles of terms in the TKE budget at $N{\it\tau}=1.2$, normalized by $U_{r}^{3}/L_{r}$, where the reference velocity $U_{r}=2.09U_{do}$ and $L_{r}=h_{o}$. The advection $-\overline{v}\partial k/\partial y-\overline{w}\partial k/\partial z$ is negligible compared with the terms shown.

Figure 16

Figure 17.Contours of terms in the TKE budget at (a) $N{\it\tau}=2.5$, (b) $N{\it\tau}=18$, (c) $N{\it\tau}=82$ and (d) $N{\it\tau}=586$. Streamwise-averaged quantities have been further averaged (‘double folded’) across the lateral $y$ and vertical $z$ axes through the wake centreline $(y_{c},z_{c})$, and plotted in separate quadrants, such that the upper left (‘northwest’), upper right (‘northeast’), lower left (‘southwest’) and lower right (‘southeast’) region of each plot respectively corresponds to the net rate of change $\partial k/\partial t=\mathscr{A}_{tke}+\mathscr{P}_{tke}+\mathscr{F}_{tke}+\mathscr{B}_{tke}-{\it\epsilon}_{tke}$, production $\mathscr{P}_{tke}$, (minus) dissipation $-{\it\epsilon}_{tke}$ and flux gradient transport $\mathscr{F}_{tke}$. (The corresponding buoyancy term $\mathscr{B}_{tke}$ variation is shown in figure 17 of Redford et al. (2014).) The advection $\mathscr{A}_{tke}=-\overline{v}\partial k/\partial y-\overline{w}\partial k/\partial z$ is negligible compared with the other terms. Budget terms are normalized by $U_{r}^{3}/L_{r}$, where the reference velocity $U_{r}=2.09U_{do}$ and the length $L_{r}=h_{o}$. White solid line contours indicate $\pm 0.67$ of the larger of the minimum and maximum magnitude at each time. Black solid line contours correspond to $\overline{u}=0.05U_{d}$ and $0.5U_{d}$. The (maximum, minimum) values at $N{\it\tau}=2.5$, $18$, $82$ and $586$ are respectively $(+1.49\times 10^{-5},-2.25\times 10^{-5})$, $(+1.77\times 10^{-7},-1.1\times 10^{-7})$, $(+5.3\times 10^{-8},-3.2\times 10^{-8})$ and $(+8.15\times 10^{-11},-2.6\times 10^{-10})$.