Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T16:19:43.796Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

On Lunatics and Loving Sons: A textualstudy of the Mamlūk treatment of al-Ḥākim*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 March 2008

Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The Mamlūk historical tradition's depiction of al-Ḥākimbi-Amr Allah (386-411/996-1021), the fifth Caliph ofthe Fāṭimid dynasty of Egypt (296-556/909-1171), isa contradictory amalgamation of awe, confusion, andhorror. Al-Ḥākim assumes effective political powerby murdering Barjawān, his guardian and tutor, whowas pivotal to securing the young Caliph'ssuccession in the face of powerful militaryopposition. Then we are witness to al-Ḥākim's steadydecline into a kind of psychosis or madness. He sitsalone in the candlelight or darkness for years andorders the sūqs (markets) to remainopen throughout the night. His policies range fromthe patently absurd (e.g. banning cobblers frommaking women's shoes to keep them indoors or thekilling of all dogs) to the outright tyrannical(e.g. forcing Jews and Christian to wear ten poundweights around their necks). The sources expresshorror when recounting al-Ḥākim's sudden killingsprees, but even his greatest critics acknowledgehis selfless generosity. Most compilers assert thathe proclaimed his own divinity and authorisedmissionaries to spread this message, while othersdeny this allegation, pointing towards hispersecution of the early Druze. In the end, we areshown al-Ḥākim riding into the hills surroundingCairo in solitary contemplation only to vanish intothin air.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © The Royal Asiatic Society 2008
Figure 0

Chart 1.The portrayal of the main characters in the murder of Barjawān

Figure 1

Chart 2.The portrayal of the main characters in the looting of Fusṭāṭ

Figure 2

Chart 3.The portrayal of Sitt al-Mulk in the disappearance/murder accounts

Figure 3

Chart 4.The portrayal of al-Ḥākim in the disappearance/murder accounts

Figure 4

Chart 5.The portrayal of the main characters in the disappearance/murder accounts

Figure 5

Chart 6.The sources of the disappearance/murder accounts

Figure 6

Chart 7.The Portrayal of al-Ḥakim in the selected accounts

Figure 7

Table 1.The murder of Barjawān narratives

Figure 8

Table 2.The Base Narratives of the Looting of Miṣr

Figure 9

Table 3.The Looting Narratives of Later Historians

Figure 10

Table 4.The Base Narratives of the Disappearance/Murder of al-Ḥākim

Figure 11

Table 5.The Disappearance/Murder Narratives of Later Historians