In Work, Worklessness and the Political Economy of Health, Clare Bambra argues that the socioeconomic inequalities generated by paid work, as well as the lack of it, are the most important determinants of population health in advanced market democracies. She documents the range of mechanisms that lead to work and worklessness mediating life chances and the social determinants of health, and she highlights how those determinants of health must be analysed in terms of broader political and economic structures of society. While she is concerned to demonstrate that different types of public policy initiatives can mitigate health inequalities, ultimately the take home message is that macro-level policy interventions are the most important in mediating health inequalities, and that social democratic welfare state regimes fare better in this regard than neo-liberal welfare regimes.
A number of cross-national studies over the past thirty years have shown the importance of political and economic systems for population health and health inequalities, and a variety of reports and articles (exemplified, for example by Marmot, Reference Marmot2010; Navarro et al., Reference Navarro, Muntaner and Borrell2006; Mackenbach et al., Reference Mackenbach, Stirbu and Roskam2008) have effectively presented evidence that ill health is worse for those in lower socioeconomic classes. This book is a valuable contribution to that body of literature in that it summarises the material crisply and thoroughly and then attempts to crystallise a political economy analysis that is implicit in the common material of prior studies, showing how politics influences health and health inequalities.
Of the eight chapters in this book, the central chapters (chapters 3–6) cover, in turn, the health hazards of: the physical work environment, the psychosocial work environment, recession and unemployment and health-related worklessness. These chapters reflect their origins in a series of university lecture courses, in that they each adopt a standard literature review format to canvass a wide range of evidence to support the emphasis on work-related factors in the social determinants of health. While they do contribute to the overall theme of the book, these chapters have a relatively discrete feel, although they will doubtless constitute valuable resources for anyone interested in crisp and effective summaries of relevant material on each of these elements and, as such, are likely to be all the more useful for the conventional format. Notwithstanding that the material in each of the central chapters is relatively discrete, however, a distinctive overlay on the standard format is the development of a thread arguing that the welfare state mediates the impact of the social determinants of health and also of socioeconomic class on health. In particular, welfare state capitalism sets the parameters for the social determinants of health, and the way in which the state distributes financial resources and welfare services has consequences for social and economic hierarchies. In each of the four central chapters, countries in which more redistributive political parties held power for longer time periods are shown to have better health outcomes than those with more neo-liberal governments.
The chapters that bookend these central chapters are the ones that carry the weight of the model developed in book. It is that the health effects of work and worklessness vary by welfare state regime, and how society is economically and socially organised is critical in influencing the social determinants of health and health inequalities. In the model, the (welfare) state is seen to have a quasi-independent role in mediating the effects of the economic system, in particular the organisation of work and the labour market, the extent of socioeconomic class inequality and associated exposure to the social determinants of health.
More specifically, the political economy analysis in the penultimate chapter (chapter 7) also shows that, even within the constraints of unequal capitalist societies, things can be done to improve health and reduce health inequalities. Policy interventions can be made at the macro, meso or individual level requiring primary prevention, secondary prevention and treatment interventions respectively. Macro- and meso-level interventions are expected to be the most beneficial in terms of reducing health inequalities and individual interventions the least, because macro- and meso-level interventions treat the causes, whereas individual interventions treat the symptoms.
The most underdeveloped aspect of the book, however, is the connection between the context setting chapter (chapter 2) and the concluding chapters (chapters 7 and 8). In its own right, chapter 2 is a very effective overview of the ‘welfare regime’ debates that dominated comparative social policy literature throughout the1990s in response to Esping Andersen's Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Unfortunately, after a thorough cataloguing of a host of positions in the ‘beyond Three Worlds’ debates, the analysis reverts to a binary narrative, contrasting Social Democratic welfare states and Liberal welfare states. Finally, the proclaimed model that classifies levels of political interventions, finally appears in a cryptic and hurried form in the last three pages of the book, which suggests that a future edition would benefit from a more explicit exposition of the model earlier in the book, allowing for more effective integration of the model and examples. As it stands, though, this is a persuasive catalogue of material for anyone interested in the relationship between the labour market and population health
