The first two decades of the twenty-first century witnessed a surge of scholarship reevaluating the normative implications of honor for modern politics and morality. This scholarship includes Sharon Krause's Liberalism with Honor (Harvard University Press, 2003), Robert Faulkner's The Case for Greatness (Yale University Press, 2007), Alexander Welsh's What Is Honor? (Yale University Press, 2008), Kwame Anthony Appiah's The Honor Code (W.W. Norton, 2010), Stephen Darwall's Honor, History, and Relationship (Oxford University Press, 2013), Peter Olsthoorn's Honor in Political and Moral Philosophy (SUNY Press, 2015), and Tammler Sommers's Why Honor Matters (Basic Books, 2019)—just to name the most notable few.
This growing interest in honor among political theorists and moral philosophers is both surprising and expected: surprising, as the quest for honor may seem to be unavoidably quixotic, if not entirely toxic, in the modern Western world; expected, as the Western world has yet to transcend its own tradition of honor, which may be traced to ancient Greece. According to Haig Patapan, the modern uneasiness with honor can be attributed to honor's “two faces” (ix): while the desire for honor often instigates the pursuit of immoral ambitions and tyranny, good leadership can hardly do without this desire, which has motivated generations of political leaders to sacrifice their narrow self-interest for the common good. The conflict intrinsic to honor has led to constant attempts to reinterpret the meaning of honor in hope of attaining a reconciliation between its two faces. But how have changing interpretations of this “dangerous passion” shaped our changing perception of political leadership? This is “the question of honor” explored in Patapan's intriguing book A Dangerous Passion: Leadership and the Question of Honor—a question to which existing studies of either honor or leadership have failed to provide an answer.
The central argument of this book is that “leadership and honor are mutually constitutive and that this leadership-honor dynamic influentially defines major aspects of contemporary politics” (165). To illustrate this, Papatan divides the body of this book into two major parts. In the first part, he examines the leadership-honor dynamic from the perspective of the history of political thought. The focus of this examination is the political thought of Plato (chapter 2), Niccolò Machiavelli (chapter 3), and Thomas Hobbes (chapter 4). According to Patapan, while Plato takes seriously the tension between the two faces of honor and points to the philosophic life as a form of life potentially superior to the life of honor, Machiavelli and Hobbes offer their respective accounts of honor that challenge Plato's and significantly affect the modern perception of the leadership-honor dynamic. Specifically, despite his agreement with Plato regarding the normative ambiguity of honor, Machiavelli's account of gloria is distinctive in that it is “on a wholly new, modern plane with the longing for glory now recognized as the only self-concerned yet mediating passion that can approximate the common advantage or common good” (56). Such elevation of the importance of glory/honor to life gives rise to the modern idea of charismatic leaders of republics as well as modern elitism. In contrast to Plato and Machiavelli, Hobbes unreservedly rejects honor in view of the danger that it poses to the peace and order of a civil society. Thus, “the depreciation of honor is needful, he would claim, because it is the only remedy for destroying the seeds of pride or vaine-glory” (66). This depreciation of honor ultimately results in the dominant modern idea of democratic, dispersed leadership, an idea that ruthlessly negates the leadership-honor dynamic because it is essentially “the forgetting of honor and the forgetting of leadership” (70). More could be said in this part of the book on the rationale behind its selection of thinkers. With all its tension between secular and religious leadership as well as between honor and faith, the medieval tradition of chivalry remains underexplored by political theorists and moral philosophers. Bernard Mandeville is another important source of the modern understanding of honor and thus warrants our attention.
Having reconstructed the three accounts of honor and its relations to leadership, in the second part of the book, Patapan turns to discuss the implications of the leadership-honor dynamic for a wide range of topics on contemporary political leadership. These topics include the scholarly attempt to define leadership (chapter 5), the case study of Lee Kuan Yew's perception of ideal leadership and its close connection with honor (chapter 6), the issue of flattery that political leaders must tackle (chapter 7), the challenge that the modern (mis)perception of honor as either fame or identity politics poses to contemporary politics (chapter 8), and the problem of nationalism and patriotic leadership that stems from (mis)perceiving honor as national pride (chapter 9). What these chapters jointly illustrate is that, although Hobbes's idea of democratic, dispersed leadership as the outcome of his depreciation of honor has indeed obscured the necessity of taking seriously the leadership-honor dynamic, the attempt to negate this dynamic fails to eradicate it from politics. The ensuing disjuncture between the unavoidable relevance of the leadership-honor dynamic to politics, on the one hand, and the inadequate attention to this dynamic, on the other hand, gives rise to several urgent political-theoretical issues that can be resolved only if we reemphasize the value of honor to leadership and politics.
In chapter 8, for instance, Patapan discusses how the attempt to reject honor has resulted only in the emergence of fame and identity politics as two inferior substitutes for honor. Whereas fame is “a form of honor uncoupled from excellence or virtue” (126) and depends entirely on the judgment of social opinion, contemporary identity politics is understood as the Kantian attempt to restore individual dignity and autonomy, “a core commitment” of which is “the primacy of the individual” (139) detached from the phenomenal world. Despite the obvious incompatibility between fame and identity politics, Patapan claims that they both contribute to the depoliticization of politics intrinsic to the Hobbesian project. On the one hand, Patapan argues in an Arendtian fashion that the replacement of honor by fame denies “politics and political life any specific honor, dignity, or grandeur” (128). On the other hand, he argues in a communitarian fashion that the emphasis of identity politics on the expression of individuality renders authenticity, the aim of this expression, “impervious to reason, justice, and morality” (141) and hence marginalizes the distinctively political activity of persuasion. As a result, while the rise of fame and identity politics testifies to the constant need for a form of honor in political life, the modern misperception of honor only “gravely challenge[s] the legitimacy and therefore authority of political leaders” (142). This argument could be further strengthened if Patapan engaged contemporary critical political theorists such as Iris Marion Young, Chantal Mouffe, and Bonnie Honig, who understand identity politics in an agonistic fashion and who aim precisely at the repoliticization of politics.
Overall, A Dangerous Passion is a shrewd combination of the history of political thought and the analysis of contemporary political issues. Leading the way into the scholarly discussion of the relations between honor and political leadership, this book is an honorable attempt of Patapan's to deepen our understanding of honor, leadership, and politics in general.
