Clare Haru Crowston presents a wide-ranging study of credit in seventeenth- and eighteenth-century France based on both literary and archival sources. Her topic includes, but also extends far beyond, the narrowly economic functions of credit and debt as she seeks to recapture the many different meanings that the word crédit held for contemporaries, including significations of influence, political power, reputation, esteem, and celebrity. She rejects the view that these “nonmaterial” meanings of credit were metaphorical or derivative. Rather, all the complex meanings of the word were somehow literal, coexistent, and interrelated. Her work thus offers a sweeping vision of a French credit market that, while it certainly fulfilled a vital economic function, was also fully integrated into the political culture, social structure, and gender relations of the old regime.
Crowston draws much of her theoretical model from Avner Offer who analyzed non-market exchange, especially gift giving, as an “economy of regard” (“Between the Gift and the Market: The Economy of Regard,” The Economic History Review 50, no. 3 [1997]: 450–76). Offer in turn was inspired by eighteenth-century economist Adam Smith who, in his Theory of Moral Sentiments, argued that the desire to gain the esteem of others is actually a much greater incentive than that to “supply the necessities of nature.” Crowston views old regime society as an economy of regard in which men and women sought, offered and exchanged esteem, and used the word “credit” to designate that esteem. One of the most important tools for enhancing one's esteem was fashion, especially fashionable clothing. Much of Crowston's research thus focuses on the fashion merchants, many of them great businesswomen, who made liberal use of financial credit to supply clients with a form of cultural credit that could enhance their social and political credit.
Crowston's research on this topic is made possible in part by searchable full-text databases, including the ARTFL database developed by the University of Chicago, that enable her to search large swathes of French literature for passages that use the word “credit,” and even to offer some statistical analyses of its usage. Her print sources are thus heterogeneous and broadly representative. Through them her first three chapters show how the concept of credit was both deployed and criticized in France between roughly the mid-seventeenth and mid-eighteenth centuries. The language of credit in both its material and nonmaterial forms characterized not only writings on the royal court, where those in the King's favor were often said to possess credit, but also discussions of power and influence within the law courts, the intelligentsia, the Church, the home, and even among the “ordinary people,” as when the cardinal de Retz wrote of local leaders who had credit among the people of Paris. Women were often perceived to possess as much or more of the nonmaterial forms of credit as men, a situation that elicited much comment and more than a little criticism, as when the abbé de Saint-Pierre argued that a proposed system of royal government by committees would have the advantage of limiting the harm caused by the “credit of women.” In the mid-eighteenth century the famous royal mistress and patron of the Enlightenment Jeanne-Antoinette Poisson, Marquise de Pompadour, the issue of a family of very successful financiers, became the pinnacle of credit in both its material and nonmaterial forms.
Roughly the second half of the book focuses on the Parisian fashion trades and draws heavily on archival as well as literary sources, especially the papers of Parisian notaries and commissaires de police at France's Archives nationales, and bankruptcy depositions at the Archives de Paris. Crowston shows that fashion merchants (marchandes de modes) were a female offshoot of the Mercers’ Guild whose operations expanded enormously with the rise of consumer spending among both elite and popular classes over the course of the eighteenth century. The most celebrated of fashion merchants was Rose Bertin who, as supplier of clothing to Queen Marie-Antoinette, came to dominate French fashion in the 1780s. Independent businesswomen like Bertin (marchandes publiques) bought and sold largely on credit, and were thus heavily imbedded in financial markets on their own account. With their rising influence on fashion among court nobles and other elites, and their consequent ability to provide their clients with cultural and political esteem, they also came to wield considerable credit in the nonmaterial senses of the word. For the Queen's circle at Versailles such attention to fashion ultimately backfired as the luxury spending of the Marie-Antoinette, nicknamed “Madame Deficit,” came wrongly to be blamed for the fiscal insolvency of the crown. While wisely declining to argue that this was the “cause” of the French Revolution, Crowston suggests that the monarchy was not so much desacralized as it was discredited.
On the more strictly economic side of this picture, Crowston's final chapter examines access to credit among ordinary married women. Historians of early modern France have long supposed that a married woman, unless she was legally separated, could not contract credit or debt without her husband's signature. Crowston, however, shows that this is much too simplistic. In reality the commercial courts recognized the legal authority of married women to provision their households through the purchase of consumer goods on credit, as well as to conduct business operations on credit when their husbands were absent. As consumer spending grew rapidly over the course of the eighteenth century, married women's access to credit grew as well. Indeed, a spendthrift wife could lead her household to bankruptcy, just as the Queen was presumed to have done, so they needed to be trained in basic accounting and the judicious use of credit instruments.
Crowston thus expands our understanding of the role of women in old regime credit markets, even as she transforms our understanding of the credit markets themselves.
