Razmik Panossian's first book, The Armenians: From Kings and Priests to Merchants and Commissars, is the most sophisticated and comprehensive analysis of the development of Armenian (national) identity from prehistory to 1988. In addition to a deconstruction of Armenian identity, Panossian engages a broader discussion on the nature of national identity and its formation. Using the Armenians as his case study, he challenges the modernist notions that nations are formed through the organizing instruments of the state and that nationalism is culturally homogenizing.
In seeing identity itself as something transcendent, Panossian minimizes the role a state must play in the formation of a nation. Thus, he looks to the diaspora for the initiators of nation building. Given the general poverty of the Anatolian or Caucasian peasant in history, it comes as little surprise that the sparks of Armenian nationalism came from abroad. Panossian deals with these issues and events in the first half of Chapter 3, “Preparing the Groundwork, I: Merchant Communities and Diaspora Centres.” Here Panossian outlines various significant communities and their historical importance, including those of India, Europe, Tbilisi, Istanbul, and New Julfa.
This really begins the more contentious part of the book. Giving the diaspora a central place to anything Armenian, be it in history or contemporary affairs, assumes a marginalization of those inhabiting the territory called Armenia. Thus, the overemphasis in this book on the diaspora inhibits more developed discussion on more mundane elements of the nascent Armenian “nation” being created or reinvented at various times. In particular it hinders a discussion of the relationship between the ideas and goals of nationalism and nationalists and the rising polity being shaped ostensibly by those political forces. This falls into one of the traps laid by the theoretical work on nationalism, particularly the centrality given to political and intellectual actors. In the Armenian case one must look almost exclusively to the diaspora to find such characters, leading to the logical conclusion that the diaspora does in fact replace the state as the main organizing institution. Still, this does not account for the fact that the subjective feeling necessary for the application of the designation “nation” is being created at a popular level, yet in lieu of a state apparatus; how that process is negotiated is absent in the book. The discussion of individual communities fails to show any connection, however minor, between isolated intellectual or cultural endeavors abroad and the development of national sentiment, let alone any continuity.
The focus on the diaspora also leads to the argument that Armenian nationalism is not culturally homogenizing, as informed by Panossian's convincing multilocal argument (the idea that Armenian nationalism emerges from many different centers, generally diaspora communities and not one metropole as is typically the case). When reflected on to the whole of the Armenian “nation” throughout history, there is little place to argue the contrary; given the differences in geography and jurisdiction dividing Armenians, nothing else could be true. When taken on the basis of individual cases, though, nationalism is conforming in the Armenian case(s).
The chronological organization Panossian utilizes provides the most coherent method of tracing the emergence and evolution of Armenian national identity. This is especially true when considering the long literary and religious history Armenians have had and the need to differentiate among the various types of identity present at different times—sometimes in competition with one another. In addition, Panossian does succeed in tracing the development of Armenian national identity, arguing that national identity, to the chagrin of many nationalist scholars, is in fact a modern phenomenon. He also correctly argues for the need to utilize many different theories on nationalism to understand and properly analyze one case study. Occasional “theoretical interludes” interrupt the text to show how Armenians either fit or evade the dominant theories on nationalism, placing his work into a broader theoretical discourse.
However, the chronological approach inadvertently structures and dictates what the author uses to describe and analyze as national or prenational in the case of the Armenians. The use of a linear narrative places most everything analyzed in a more active role. Ancient history and merchants become building blocks as opposed to that which is “rescued” in the modern period. This is not to say that Panossian ignores the importance of the use of history in constructing a nation in the modern sense, but the characterization and importance of events is not always made clear.
Part of the problem, from a methodological standpoint, is the almost universal lack of primary sources. The author has staked his argument to the veracity and prejudices of the existing historiography on Armenia and the Armenians. Despite the efforts of many talented individuals, the work to date has simply not provided sufficient material to offer the source base necessary for a work like The Armenians. Thus the trappings of the field, dominated by diaspora Armenians in the North American and European academies, are reproduced in the book: an overemphasis on the diaspora throughout history, the centrality of the 19th-century revolutionary parties, and the central role of certain political actors in the contemporary diaspora.
In this way, as in others, Panossian is ahead of his time when it comes to the subject of his study. Still, he has masterfully handled his topic, displaying a very solid grasp of both the field of nationalism and Armenian political history. Any book with a scope such as that of The Armenians is bound to have at least some organizational and structural flaws. Despite this, Panossian has provided us with a stimulating work rife with new conceptualizations of a very difficult and controversial issue. This work will remain the standard on Armenian identity for some time. One hopes that the author will continue his work.
