In Defectives in the Land: Disability and Immigration in the Age of Eugenics, historian Douglas C. Baynton lays clear the profound ways in which disability (or, what today we call disability) permeated immigration laws, policy, debates, and practices during the Progressive Era, which have remained largely missing from historical scholarship regarding immigration. Put bluntly, immigration laws were a vital part of eugenic efforts to rid the body politic of those considered defective. Disability rendered one a defective citizen with whom the nation had to deal, but defective potential citizens could be turned away at the doors. Baynton argues that Progressive Era immigration policies reflected citizenship ideals; and due to their immense impact and public visibility, they offer “an especially legible guide to that era's cultural assumptions about disability” (6) and who constituted the disabled.
This brief book is about ideology and consequence. Embedded in eugenic thought, the fear of the defective immigrant was not simply due to the supposed defectiveness of the individual, but due to belief in the degenerative, multigenerational, and mushrooming peril created by incorporating a defective into the U.S. body politic. Defectives, unhealthily dependent by nature, impeded the nation's embrace of industrial-based speed, efficiency, and betterment. They also multiplied exponentially. Immigration policies thus sought to exclude defectives; and immigration officials developed practices by which they believed they could easily and quickly identify defectiveness on the bodies that passed before them. The strength of Defectives in the Land is its persuasive argument that defectiveness, while believed at the time to be biologically inherent and apparent, was instead ideological and thus needs rigorous historicization.
Baynton is a historian of ideas whose goal is to bare and trace the intellectual threads underlying and protruding from immigration policy. He does so with elegant prose, analyzing eugenic and anti-immigrant sentiment from a wide variety of medical, legal, literary, and political sources. He organizes Defectives in the Land conceptually, using the chapters of “Defective,” “Handicapped,” “Dependent,” and “Ugly” to build his argument. For me, most revealing were his analyses of “handicapped” and “dependent.” In these chapters, Baynton links the nation's disgust for disability to its capitalistic fervor. The ableist assumption that disability always and inevitably entailed dependency, that disability always and inevitably resulted in economic sluggishness, resulted in excluding people with disabilities. Even when faced with direct evidence to the contrary—in this case, written job offers—immigration officials defined those with disabilities as economically invalid and likely to become a public charge. This work suggests that both immigration law and economic thought are vital to understanding the history of ableism; and that ableism is vital to understanding both immigration and economic thought. Too often immigration officials presumed all things disability to be based in dependency and charity, particularly labor and education.
As noted, Defectives in the Land is a piece of intellectual history—and it is in this field that Baynton has given so much to the history of the Progressive Era, the history of eugenics, and the history of disability. This is a book about the concept of disability and the uses of that concept to build legal and ideological walls restricting immigration. It is not about people with disabilities, immigration inspectors, or the material consequences of immigration law, but nor does Baynton ever claim it to be. Defectives in the Land opens the door for future scholarship on the people and families whose lives were shaped, sometimes ended by being turned away at Ellis Island or spurned by ticket sellers or ship captains on European shores (who could be fined if a passenger was rejected by immigration inspectors).
Throughout Defectives in the Land, Baynton wrestles with the question of how disability relates analytically and in immigration policies to gender, race, and class. For historians and other scholars, wrestlings such as these are about method as much as they are about analyses, intersectionality, and life complexities. Baynton focuses only on Ellis Island arrivals, demarcating his primary sources and choosing to render race less obviously visible in immigration practices and in his analyses. He posits disability as the dominant and all-encompassing framework of turn-of-the-century eugenic immigration ideologies. As a result, Baynton has unwittingly rendered both immigration and disability white. Race, however, was as elemental to the practices and ideologies of Ellis Island as it was to Angel Island's Immigration Station—and both locales determined which immigrants would become future citizens and which would be rejected. Defectives in the Land could be strengthened, and fruitfully complicated, by deeper analysis of the relationship between race and defectiveness, continued unpacking of the confusing (at least to me) racial categories and subcategories of Europeans at the turn of the century, and consideration of the huge swaths of the global population (such as most Africans) barred from even attempting legal immigration.
