Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T13:12:05.075Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Thrust, drag and wake structure in flapping compliant membrane wings

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  15 January 2019

Gali Alon Tzezana*
Affiliation:
Brown University, School of Engineering, Providence, RI 02912, USA
Kenneth S. Breuer
Affiliation:
Brown University, School of Engineering, Providence, RI 02912, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: gali_alon@brown.edu

Abstract

We present a theoretical framework to characterize the steady and unsteady aeroelastic behaviour of compliant membrane wings under different conditions. We develop an analytic model based on thin airfoil theory coupled with a membrane equation. Adopting a numerical solution to the model equations, we study the effects of wing compliance, inertia and flapping kinematics on aerodynamic performance. The effects of added mass and fluid damping on a flapping membrane are quantified using a simple damped oscillator model. As the flapping frequency is increased, membranes go through a transition from thrust to drag around the resonant frequency, and this transition is earlier for more compliant membranes. The wake also undergoes a transition from a reverse von Kármán wake to a traditional von Kármán wake. The wake transition frequency is predicted to be higher than the thrust–drag transition frequency for highly compliant wings.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© 2019 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic of the flapping membrane wing. The shading of the membrane indicate the different phases of the flapping cycle. A reverse von Kármán street is shed behind the membrane, illustrated by a dashed line. Although the theoretical model assumes that the wake lies along the $x$-axis, a wavy line is shown to represent the spatio-temporal fluctuations of vorticity.

Figure 1

Figure 2.(a) Variation of maximum camber with Weber number, for different prestretch values. Symbols: current model, solid lines: model by Waldman & Breuer (2017). There is good agreement between the two models, validating the assumption of a uniform-pressure distribution along the chord. (b) Difference in membrane shape between the model by Waldman & Breuer (2017), assuming uniform-pressure distribution, and the current model. Solution obtained for $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FC}=3^{\circ }$, $Ae=30$, $\unicode[STIX]{x1D706}_{0}=1.1$.

Figure 2

Table 1.Summary of parameter ranges used in previous and current studies.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Membrane in pure heave, deflections during downstroke for different values of the normalized frequency $k/k_{1}$. Dark: beginning of the downstroke, $t/T=0$; light: end of the downstroke, $t/T=0.5$. Case parameters: $A_{0}=1$, $Ae=120$, $\unicode[STIX]{x1D706}_{0}=1.05$, $R=4$, $k_{1}=1.3$. The different rows correspond to the first three resonant frequencies. For each row, the first plot is before resonant frequency, the middle plot is close to resonance (note the large deflections) and the third is after resonance. The different modes of vibrations become dominant at the different resonant frequencies. A phase shift in the membrane’s deflection occurs as the membrane passes through resonance.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Membrane in pure heave, maximum deflection for different values of the reduced frequency $k$. A clear resonant peak is observed for all membranes, and for some the second and third resonances also appear in the plotted range of flapping frequencies. The resonant frequency increases as the aeroelastic number is increased, and decreases when increasing the mass ratio.

Figure 5

Figure 5.(a) Comparison of first resonant frequency with the membrane’s natural frequency, for membranes with different values of the aeroelastic number and mass ratio. Symbols: current model, solid line: $k_{1}$. The added mass parameter is $R_{A}=0.5$. (b) The damping coefficient, obtained from the deflection response using the half-power bandwidth method, plotted against $1/k_{1}$ for membranes with different parameters.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Variation of (a) maximum lift coefficient, and (b) average thrust coefficient with the reduced frequency for a membrane in pure heave; $A=1$, $\unicode[STIX]{x1D706}_{0}=1.05$, $R=4$. The dashed line represents classical thin airfoil theory for a rigid plate (Garrick 1936), in agreement with the current model. Lift and thrust magnitude increase at the resonant frequency. A stiffer membrane (higher aeroelastic number, red) generates thrust at low frequencies, which increases at the resonant frequency and then drops and transitions to drag at a higher frequency. For a more compliant membrane (yellow), the transition from thrust to drag occurs earlier, below resonance.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Variation of the phase of the wake transfer function (a) and the average thrust coefficient (b) with normalized frequency, $k/k_{1}$, for three different membranes. At a low flapping frequency, all membranes produce thrust and the corresponding reverse von Kármán wake is observed (identified by $\angle H(k)>90^{\circ }$). At a high frequency, the opposite happens – membranes have a regular von Kármán wake, and generate drag accordingly. Intersection with the dashed lines marks the transition in the wake structure (a) or transition from thrust to drag (b). For a very compliant membrane (low $k_{1}$), the thrust/drag transition occurs before the transition in the wake structure, and vice versa.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Variation of the phase of the wake transfer function (a) and the average thrust coefficient (b) with the normalized frequency, $k/k_{1}$, for two different membranes with the same natural frequency. Varying the aeroelastic number and the mass ratio changes the effect of fluid damping, which becomes dominant as the parameters become small. This results in a change in the thrust/drag and wake transition frequencies.

Figure 9

Figure 9.(a) Wake transition and (b) thrust/drag transition frequencies normalized by the natural frequency, plotted as a function of the natural frequency. Transition in the wake structure occurs close to the natural (resonant) frequency. If inertia is dominant (low $k_{1}$, more compliant wing), transition from thrust to drag happens before resonance; however when stiffness dominates (high $k_{1}$), we can get thrust for higher frequencies, to the limit of a rigid plate that produces thrust at any flapping frequency (Garrick 1936).