In Hot Time in the Old Town: The Great Heat Wave of 1896 and the Making of Theodore Roosevelt, Edward P. Kohn contends that the August 1896 heat wave shaped the political careers of both Theodore Roosevelt and William Jennings Bryan because it was “a unique convergence of quintessentially American politics and personalities, with a great, urban natural disaster as a backdrop” (242). For ten days, a combination of high temperatures and high humidity laid siege to New York, causing widespread suffering and the deaths of nearly 1,500 people. Only after a week did city officials, including police commissioner Theodore Roosevelt, offer any relief measures. Kohn believes that the heat wave educated Roosevelt about urban social conditions and demonstrated how government action could improve the public welfare. Kohn suggests that Roosevelt's provision of free ice to the poor saved lives, boosted his reputation at a time when his political career in New York City was at a standstill, and foreshadowed the progressive agenda Roosevelt later championed as president. Kohn views the heat wave as having the opposite effect on the political fortunes of William Jennings Bryan, the newly minted Democratic presidential candidate. Bryan was in New York during the heat wave to launch his campaign against William McKinley with a major speech at Madison Square Garden. Kohn suggests that the heat wave figured into the failure of the speech to establish Bryan as a viable national candidate and effectively ended his presidential campaign almost before it could begin. More broadly, Kohn views the heat wave as a turning point in how city governments handled urban crises and conditions.
This is a lively and often engaging account of politics and social life in late-nineteenth century America. Kohn moves between accounts of the heat wave, Roosevelt, and Bryan, holding them together with some skill. Kohn is at his best when describing urban conditions. He paints a vivid, detailed portrait of life in 1890s New York City, especially in the tenements of the lower East Side, and provides a gripping narrative of the heat wave as a natural disaster that unfolds slowly and horrifyingly. Above all, Kohn creates a nuanced, compelling portrait of a young, ambitious Roosevelt struggling in a stalled career, subjected to scorn and criticism for enforcing unpopular laws.
However, it is unclear that the heat wave had a special impact on Roosevelt's career. Roosevelt, who rode out much of the heat wave at his Oyster Bay home on Long Island, was not the only city official to respond. His later post in the McKinley administration came not because of that response, but because of his political service and some well-placed friends. The heat wave was only one of many New York experiences shaping his perspective on political and social reform.
Nor is it clear that the heat wave was the only factor affecting Bryan's political campaign. Unfortunately, Kohn's fine portrait of Roosevelt is not matched by an equivalent one of Bryan. Kohn turns Bryan into a straw man against which Roosevelt can shine. Kohn's dislike for Bryan is evident early on, when he attacks Bryan for resigning as secretary of state in 1915 and “undermining his president's foreign policy in a time of war,” though the United States had not declared war (29). Kohn makes every action of Bryan's fraught with significance and subject to criticism. Kohn continually criticizes Bryan for referring to New York and the east coast as “enemy country” but ignores the way the East Coast press described Bryan and the Middle West. When Bryan and his wife arrive in New York, Kohn portrays them as two hicks overcome by the big city. A boat ride to Coney Island and back without disembarking at the amusement park is an “odd trip” that “seemed to underscore Bryan's small-town and western contempt for all things big, eastern and urban” (213). Kohn probes Roosevelt's feelings and beliefs but rarely gets inside Bryan's. Kohn presents Bryan as the young, naïve, demagogic midwestern candidate of a divided Democratic party with ill-advised economic policies who is doomed to die at the Scopes Trial. Roosevelt, by contrast, is the young, savvy, sophisticated easterner with progressive but sound Republican politics headed for the presidency.
Though Roosevelt later uses “Hot Time in the Old Town Tonight” as the Rough Rider's theme music and as his 1904 campaign song, Kohn's attempt to interpret the heat wave as a turning point is not convincing. He compares the heat wave at length to train wrecks and cholera epidemics, argues for its significance based on the death toll but then says that measuring heat-related deaths is difficult and uncertain. Kohn criticizes city government for not responding quickly and effectively yet acknowledges that the city was trying to play catch-up with a slowly unfolding crisis at a time when both the will and capacity of urban government was just beginning to develop. He argues that the heat wave changed how cities responded to crises, then states that “lessons from the 1896 heat wave seemed limited and short-lived” (242, 257). Kohn sets Roosevelt and Bryan against each other in a way that did not actually occur, because Bryan was the Democratic candidate whereas Roosevelt was a relatively unknown city official. Finally, Kohn writes continually that his actors “must have” or “should have” believed or thought or known something, which probably is intended to heighten the narrative drama but weakens the methodology. Because this book has no citations, it is impossible to know the source of these speculations, or the extent to which the author engages the literature. In the end, though the heat wave provides an interesting window into the time period, heat is just heat, not a political maker or breaker.
