The study of the Mongol empire has made enormous strides in the past two decades, but so far there has been no attempt at an overall scholarly synthesis. Timothy May's work aims to fill this void by presenting an updated summary of the “state of research” of the Mongol empire at the beginning of the second decade of the twenty-first century. The book's major strength is its perspective: it looks at the Mongol empire from a holistic perspective and makes a strong case for the early globalization that characterized “the Chinggis Exchange,” as May termed the web of connections that crisscrossed Eurasia in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, many of which were initiated or facilitated by the policies of Chinggis Khan and his heirs.
The book is divided into two main parts, preceded by an introduction, which reviews the book's raison d'etre, the main sources for the study of Mongol history (including an intriguing reference to an expected English translation of the Yuanshi), and the danger of exaggerating the importance of the Mongols. The first part, “The Mongol Conquests as Catalyst” succinctly reviews the formation of the empire and its united phase (chapter 1), the four khanates that emerged after the dissolution of the United Empire in 1260 (chapter 2), and the Mongol political legacy (chapter 3). The third chapter is by far the most illuminating. Its title, “The World of 1350: A Global World,” is somewhat misleading since the chapter begins in 1350 but goes all the way up to the twenty-first century, enumerating various dynasties, states, and empires that either saw themselves as successors of the Mongol empire or can be seen as such. While one can question certain interpretations in this chapter—the reference to the Ming dynasty's debt to the Mongols (pp. 94–95), for example, could have benefited from referring to Robinson's workFootnote 3—and parts of it read as a somewhat technical enumerating of polities, it puts to rest the cliché that the Mongols conquered quickly and disappeared quickly, leaving nothing but destruction behind them. Instead, May convincingly claims that the Mongols ushered in the early modern period, and highlights their lasting political legacy across Eurasia.
Mongol impact on fields other than politics is the subject of the second and larger part, entitled “The Chinggis Exchange.” Its various chapters deal with trade, warfare, administration, religion, migration and demographic trends, the Mongols and the plague, and cultural exchange. The informative chapters summarize the recent research in each field, giving the rightful central place to the works of Thomas T. Allsen, by far the most influential historian of the Mongols in the last decades. The chapter on “new forms of warfare” that covers May's specialty, the Mongol military, is especially worthwhile, and I will certainly use it for my Mongol empire classes. Other chapters could have benefited from a more analytical, rather than descriptive, approach. The chapter on the plague is the only one in which May might have fallen into the trap of ascribing too much to the Mongols, as all the effects of the plague are indirectly ascribed to them. Moreover, while the plague's significance for the history of Europe and the Middle East is unquestionable, its presence in and impact on China and Inner Asia have been recently queried by both Brook and Buell.Footnote 4 The migrations chapter could have given more emphasis to the ethnic and religious transformations that these migrations generated, such as the dispersion and subsequent disappearance of long-lived steppe people, including the Uyghurs, Tanguts, Kitans and Qipchaq, and the emergence (in the sixteenth century) of the contemporary Central Asian people, including the Uzbeks and Kazakhs. The huge expansion of Islam in the aftermath of Mongol rule also deserves more attention.
Careful copyediting could have eliminated a few redundant mistakes: the territory of the empire rises from 7.5 million square kilometers (p. 9) to 8.5 million square kilometers (p. 21), John K. Fairbank is curiously renamed as Jonathan Fairbank (p. 12), and so on. Such quibbles notwithstanding, this vividly written book that manifests the author's fascination with its subject will become a useful textbook for world history courses and for classes on the Mongol empire, side by side with David Morgan's classic, The Mongols (2nd ed., London: Blackwell, 2007). Moreover, the availability of such synthesis will hopefully facilitate the mission of world historians when they come to include the Mongol empire and its legacy in their surveys.
