There is a growing appreciation of the impact of the built environment on the quality of life. This recognition plays a role in practical politics, too. We can see this in issues of urban sprawl, environmental justice, property rights, and eminent domain. These are all facets of place making and its relationship to the quality and character of communities. Phenomena that might at first glance be thought to minimize local politics, such as globalization and the growth of virtual political communities, instead contribute to a renewed interest in the quality of where we live and how we can act collectively to inscribe political values on our shared locales. Cities in particular are being recognized as important both as polities and economic powerhouses apart from the nations in which they reside. These three books provide excellent and diverse explorations of politics and power and how they shape the places where we live. Despite their differences in method and theory, the authors of all three use rich compilations of evidence and analysis, critical theoretical perspective, and an interest in political action that allows them to contemplate the practical implications of their findings. Although in different ways, all three books explore how discourse and ideas generate power in the shaping of urban environments. None is or pretends to be adequate for and understanding of the relationship of politics to place making, but together they provide insight and raise challenges for both research and political action.
Margaret Farrar's Building the Body Politics is a probing and carefully argued exploration of the ways in which disciplinary discourses generate power that has literally shaped the urban landscape of Washington, DC. Alert to the significance of the nation's capital as an eminently political city, she explains how various efforts at development, redevelopment, and reform revealed and realized visions of a nation. At the same time, these discourses generated power to define and control bodies as subjects. She provides close readings of several important episodes in the history of Washington and shows how a series of discourses resulted in the building and rebuilding of spaces and places, in some cases relocating populations and disrupting lives as if the people affected were mere set pieces for the creation of grand civic tableaus. The diversity of the episodes discussed in this taught, short book strengthens the narrative. For example, Farrar examines the construction of the Washington Mall under the influence of Chicago's White City and the political legacy that resulted: a long-term monument and a museum glut that requires careful management of the city's remaining monumental spaces. By way of contrast, she shows how a variety of discourses were deployed in the management of Washington's elaborate alleys and their inhabitants, who, despite confinement to spaces hidden from public view, were seen as inharmonious with the grand vision of a monumental national center, and thus needed to be displaced.
Most dramatic and insightful is Farrar's discussion of the project to reshape Southwest Washington. From one vantage point, this was a blighted slum located within the line of sight of the Capitol, a special embarrassment thus subject to the high modernist project known as urban renewal. From another vantage point, it was home, a neighborhood and a community. The erasure and rebuilding of the neighborhood redeemed the ideal of polity and citizenship, with Southwest Washington's subjects unceremoniously removed and strewn around the city. In this instance and throughout the book, Farrar could have given us just another instance of discourse analysis. Her text is distinguished, however, by its clarity, its carefully and powerfully crafted argument, and its delivery of real insight into the way that power shapes the built environment and expresses visions of polity and citizenship.
Robert Gottlieb's Reinventing Los Angeles is as different from Farrar's book as Los Angeles is from Washington. Where we often think of Washington as having a surplus of self-consciously meaningful places, the stereotype of Los Angeles is that of a sprawling landscape of mass-produced, overcommercialized, privatized places. Washington has the ideal of a national character inscribed on the landscape, whereas Los Angeles is generally regarded as composed of anonymous and interchangeable, anomic places with a lack of sense of community, linked by freeways but disconnected from nature. Gottlieb challenges these stereotypes by showing how citizens in the region are mobilizing to create communities of action. He studies community efforts to change water management, reenvision the Los Angeles River, reshape the relationship of places to cars and freeways, and more. The book is as sprawling as the city it studies, but the richness of detail and the combination of theoretical reflection and personal experience make it easy to read and rewarding.
Gottlieb's book does not conform to the research norms of contemporary political science or most social science generally. It is neither a straightforward empirical study based on models and data nor a discourse analysis like Farrar's that applies ideas inspired by the likes of Michel Foucault or Julia Kristeva. Gottlieb uses theory to be sure—his discussion of the “keywords” nature and community are crucial to his argument. Instead of a more conventional piece of research, this book consists of broad discussions of themes and theoretical issues interspersed with narrative presentations of social actions, as well as personal reflections based on the author's civic engagement. He was both a participant in and student of the episodes he discusses. His academic and participatory role consisted partly of community action research. Such research allows academics and their students to use their skills to join forces with community members in projects less defined by abstract theory or hypothesis testing than by applied collaboration driven by citizens' practical concerns. Presenting the results of such research to a broader academic audience presents a challenge, and Gottlieb's approach is informal but professional and provocative. This book sets a high and welcome standard concerning an important, emerging, alternative approach to academic research.
This Could Be the Start of Something Big also looks at recent changes in citizen mobilization in metropolitan Los Angeles (among other urban regions). Like Gottlieb, Manuel Pastor, Jr., Chris Benner, and Martha Matsuoka are academics and activists long involved in community mobilization. At first glance, it might be assumed that these two books would have a lot of in common. Yet they are very different in style, organization, and methods and in their approaches to political action. Pastor, Benner, and Matsuoka present a more conventionally academic book, despite its overtly political agenda. They are contributing to the literature on urban social movements, arguing that a new way of defining urban mobilization for equity, focused on regionalism, is changing the strategies and likelihood of success for social and political change. The authors make clear that they intend this book to provide a new analytical perspective for understanding urban and suburban problems and dilemmas, providing new strategies for a reinvigorated progressive politics.
The context for the shift to a “regional equity” perspective from the more traditional community organizing is as follows: First, many of the practical issues faced today are rooted not just in the inequality of income and resource distribution but in the way that cities and suburbs have been spatially arranged. Economic segregation by class, inadequate affordable housing stock, declining urban and suburban commercial centers, environmental degradation of former industrial areas, sprawl, and inadequate public transportation for those with the greatest need all affect the way entire regions work. Spatial arrangements of American cities not only concentrate poverty but also exacerbate the impact of having a low income. These are local issues in the sense that federal and state programs are unlikely to fix them, but they go beyond specific neighborhoods, communities, or even existing urban and suburban jurisdictions. Externalities of these localized issues drag down entire regions. The authors' concerns come from the traditional Left, which is to say that they object to the inequality and deprivation involved in these problems. Yet they also argue that the failure to address them hurts entire regions as well, rendering them uncompetitive in national and international economic competition. Neither community organizing focused on very local matters nor the fading hope for some sort of resurgent class-based politics is likely to transform American politics in the near future. It is the authors' contention that a politics of regional equity is opening a new path to progress. If social movements address regional equity concerns, they can forge coalitions within regions, coalitions that include business and political elites who share an interest in improving the competitiveness of an entire region, such as Los Angeles.
The authors provide an overview of a regional equity perspective that is emerging across the United States, including the San Francisco Bay area, Detroit, Milwaukee, greater Chicago, and Los Angeles. They document how a regional focus has allowed elements of the Left—community activists, environmentalists, and labor—to collaborate, and also how these elements have reached out to political and economic elites to join in coalitions to improve the overall prospects of the region. The authors focus extensively on various case studies of regional equity movements in Los Angeles, including some in which they played an active role. The strength of this book lies in the detailed discussion of specific efforts. The chapter devoted to Los Angeles, for example, analyzes variation in actual instances of what the authors categorize as regional equity movements, showing that organizational and strategic features result in different outcomes. Their coverage of a potentially important emerging change not only in urban politics but in American politics as a whole is important evidence for a wide audience to consider. So is their discussion of how to evaluate the significance of strategy and structure for the likelihood of successful urban equity movements.
The following chapters of the book do acknowledge that the regional equity movement is now in an initial stage, and that it faces many obstacles before it can become a major, transformative force in contemporary American politics. It is here that the analysis is less than convincing. The compiled evidence documents that the phenomenon the authors describe is real and important. It is also clear that they underrate the impediments to its becoming a transformative force in American life. Since the authors gave us a lyrical title, “there is something happening here” might have been more in line with the evidence than “this could be the start of something big.” Such criticism notwithstanding, everyone concerned with the politics of the built environment will want to read this text, in addition to the other two.
The diversity of these books is striking, but from very different analytical positions each shows that spatial configuration is a persistently contested political issue. Each also shows that language and discourse, whether in disciplinary discourses or advocates' strategic framing, play a crucial role in making and reshaping our political geography. Discourses enable and constrain self-understandings and the distribution of life's chances as they are mapped out in our cities and suburbs. All of these books are important for getting us to think more about language, strategy, and the built environment. Yet it might be worth considering the dogs that do not bark in any of these texts. The spatial configurations of urban and suburban geography are also products of economic and political resources that are not purely discursive. As obvious as it may seem, for instance, spatial configuration takes its form partly because of political institutions and jurisdictional boundaries. Arguably these are rooted in political discourses from the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, but they are relegated to our shared cognitive background and operate as brute facts. Furthermore, the geography of economic decline may be shaped by disciplinary discourse and progressive strategic responses would surely be improved by the recognition of regionalism, but right now, the relative cost of action for urban and suburban revitalization may be prohibitive. Furthermore, widespread contempt for politics and the delegitimation of politics at every level will not be easily overcome by rethinking what we mean by nature, or by mobilizing for equity on a regional scale. For the sake of both adequate analysis of urban and suburban politics and political action, we still need to remember the importance of the political economy.
