Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T11:21:59.472Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Uniform momentum zones for the logarithmic layer in turbulent pipe flow

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 July 2026

Dongmin Kim
Affiliation:
School of Mechanical Engineering, Pusan National University, 2 Busandaehak-ro 63beon-gil, Geumjeong-gu, Busan 46241, Republic of Korea
Jinyul Hwang*
Affiliation:
School of Mechanical Engineering, Pusan National University, 2 Busandaehak-ro 63beon-gil, Geumjeong-gu, Busan 46241, Republic of Korea
*
Corresponding author: Jinyul Hwang, jhwang@pusan.ac.kr

Abstract

Content of image described in text.

Wall-bounded turbulent flows consist of multiple zones of relatively uniform streamwise velocity, known as uniform momentum zones (UMZs), separated by thin shear layers across which sharp velocity jumps occur. These zonal-like arrangements form a hierarchy consistent with the self-similar eddies postulated in Townsend’s attached-eddy hypothesis (AEH). However, whether the velocity fields carried by UMZs exhibit the asymptotic behaviours predicted by the AEH remains unclear because UMZs coexist over a wide range of scales. Here, we extract wall-scaled UMZs characterised by the wall-normal distance ($y$) and the friction velocity ($u_\tau$), and examine the velocity fields within them in the context of the AEH. We analyse direct numerical simulation data of turbulent pipe flow at friction Reynolds numbers $\textit{Re}_\tau = 550$–$6000$. The number of UMZs increases logarithmically with $\textit{Re}_\tau$, while their interface velocities span a wide range, reflecting their hierarchical organisation. We identify wall-scaled UMZs exhibiting linear growth of thickness with $y$ and velocity jumps scaled by $u_\tau$. The turbulence statistics associated with these UMZs reveal a common wall-normal range, $5\textit{Re}_\tau ^{-1/2} \lt y/R \lt 0.2$ (where $R$ is the pipe radius), over which the mean velocity follows the logarithmic law and the wall-parallel turbulence intensities exhibit logarithmic variation. Within this range, constant regions emerge in the wall-normal turbulence intensity and the Reynolds shear stress wherever the number of UMZs exceeds its mean. The probability density functions (PDFs) of the velocity fluctuations within the wall-scaled UMZs exhibit $\textit{Re}_\tau$-independent self-similarity, characterised by near-zero skewness across the logarithmic region. Consistently, the Kullback–Leibler divergence remains approximately constant, confirming invariant PDF shapes in $y$. These findings demonstrate that the wall-scaled UMZs are directly related to the logarithmic layer and provide a structural basis for the statistical behaviour of wall-bounded turbulence.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Simulation parameters. Here, Reb$\textit{Re}_b$ and Reτ$\textit{Re}_{\tau }$ are the bulk Reynolds number and the friction Reynolds number, respectively, Lx$L_x$ is the domain size in the streamwise direction and R$R$ indicates the pipe radius. Also, Nx$N_x$, Nr$N_r$ and Nθ$N_\theta$ indicate the number of grid points in the streamwise, radial and azimuthal directions, respectively. The streamwise and spanwise grid sizes are denoted by Δx+$\Delta x^+$ and Δ(Rθ)+$\Delta (R\theta )^+$, respectively. The minimum and maximum radial grid spacings are represented by Δrmin+$\Delta r_{{min}}^+$ and Δrmax+$\Delta r_{{max}}^+$, respectively, and Δt+$\Delta t^+$ is the time step.

Figure 1

Figure 1.The wall-normal profiles of (a$a$) the mean streamwise velocity, and (b$b$–d$d$) the streamwise, wall-normal and spanwise (i.e. azimuthal) turbulence intensities. The black, green, blue and red lines represent the present data at Reτ=550$\textit{Re}_{\tau } = 550$, 1000$1000$, 3000$3000$ and 6000$6000$, respectively. The open circle symbols (∘)$(\circ )$ denote the pipe flow data from Pirozzoli et al. (2021).

Figure 2

Figure 2.An example of UMZ detection in a turbulent pipe flow at Reτ=6000$\textit{Re}_{\tau } = 6000$ using a histogram-based method. (a$a$) The contour plot of the instantaneous streamwise velocity (U/UCL$U/U_{\textit{CL}}$) in the r$r$–θ$\theta$ plane. The colour contours highlight a subdomain (lz+=2000$l_z^+ = 2000$) used for UMZ detection. (b$b$) The corresponding contour plot in the y$y$–z$z$ plane. (c$c$) The PDF of U/UCL$U/U_{\textit{CL}}$ within the highlighted subdomain. Here, the local peaks, denoted by red circles, represent the modal velocities Um$U_m$, each corresponding to a distinct UMZ, including the core region. The vertical dashed lines mark the midpoints between adjacent peaks, representing the velocity at the UMZ interfaces (Ui$U_i$). The different UMZs are labelled as Ri$R_i$, where increasing i$i$ indicates proximity to the wall. The core region is excluded from this indexing. (d$d$) The wall-normal profile of U/UCL$U/U_{\textit{CL}}$ at z+=3000$z^+ = 3000$, corresponding to the vertical dashed line in (b$b$). The grey line indicates the mean velocity profile ⟨U⟩/UCL$\langle U \rangle /U_{\textit{CL}}$.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Figure 3 long description.The instantaneous visualisation of UMZs at Reτ=550$\textit{Re}_{\tau } = 550$–6000$6000$. (a$a$) The instantaneous flow field with the UMZ edges (U=Ui$U = U_i$) denoted by black line contour. The core boundary (U/UCL=0.95$U / U_{\textit{CL}} = 0.95$) is indicated by the blue line contour. (b$b$) The PDFs of U$U$ computed from the subdomains in (a$a$). The local peaks, marked by red circles, correspond to Um$U_m$ of individual UMZs. The vertical dashed line denotes the interface velocity Ui$U_i$. (c$c$) The three-dimensional U$U$ contours over Δz/R=0.2$\Delta z/R = 0.2$. Here, the thick black line represents the wall-normal profile of U$U$ at the spanwise location denoted by the vertical dashed lines in (a$a$).

Figure 4

Figure 4.Figure 4 long description.The number of UMZs (NUMZ$N_{\textit{UMZ}}$) at varying Reynolds numbers. (a$a$) The PDFs of NUMZ$N_{\textit{UMZ}}$ at Reτ=550$\textit{Re}_\tau = 550$–6000$6000$. (b$b$) The mean number of UMZs, ⟨NUMZ⟩$\langle N_{\textit{UMZ}} \rangle$, plotted as a function of Reτ$\textit{Re}_{\tau }$. The data from TBLs by de Silva et al. (2016) (◊$\lozenge$) and Chen et al. (2025) (△$\triangle$) are also shown for comparison. The blue dashed line denotes the prediction of Bautista et al. (2019).

Figure 5

Figure 5.The PDFs of (a$a$) the modal velocities (Um$U_m$) and (b$b$) the interface velocity (Ui$U_i$) at Reτ≈550$\textit{Re}_\tau \approx 550$–6000$6000$. The dashed line indicates the core-boundary velocity at U/UCL=0.95$U/U_{\textit{CL}}=0.95$ and the shaded region denotes the core region.

Figure 6

Figure 6.The joint probability density functions (JPDFs) of the central position (ym/R$y_m/R$) and the thickness (Hm/R$H_m/R$) of all UMZs; (a$a$) Reτ=550$\textit{Re}_{\tau } = 550$, (b$b$) 1000$1000$, (c$c$) 3000$3000$ and (d$d$) 6000$6000$. The red dashed line indicates Hm=2ym$H_m = 2 y_m$. The insets show the JPDFs of ym+$y_m^+$ and Hm+$H_m^+$. The contour levels correspond to 40%,60%,70%$40\,\%, 60\,\%, 70\,\%$ and 80%$80\,\%$ of the total probability.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Figure 7 long description.(a$a$) The JPDF of the central position (ym/R$y_m/R$) and thickness (Hm/R$H_m/R$) of the detected UMZs at Reτ=550$\textit{Re}_{\tau }=550$. The colour contours correspond to all UMZs (R1$R_1$ to Rmax$R_{\textit{max}}$), with contour levels at 40 %, 60 %, 70 % and 80 % of the total probability. The line contours indicate the JPDFs for the R1$R_1$ and Rmax$R_{\textit{max}}$, corresponding to 30 % and 95 % of the total probability, respectively. The red dashed line indicates Hm=2ym$H_m = 2y_m$. (b$b$) The JPDFs of ym/R$y_m/R$ and Hm/R$H_m/R$ for R1$R_1$ and Rmax$R_{\textit{max}}$ at Reτ=550$\textit{Re}_{\tau }=550$–6000. The line contours for R1$R_1$ and Rmax$R_{\textit{max}}$ enclose 30 % and 95 % of the total probability, respectively. The dashed line indicates Hm=2ym$H_m=2y_m$. (c$c$) The JPDFs for R2$R_2$ to Rmax−1$R_{{max} - 1}$, plotted with contour levels enclosing 70 % of the total probability. The open circles indicate ⟨Hm(ym)⟩$\langle H_{m}(y_m) \rangle$. The dashed line denotes Hm=0.75ym$H_m = 0.75y_m$, and the dashed–dot line denotes Hm/R=0.75ym/R−0.15$H_m/R = 0.75y_m/R - 0.15$. (d$d$) The variation of the mean thickness ⟨Hm⟩$\langle H_m \rangle$ of the self-similar UMZs (filled circles), in comparison with that of R2$R_2$ to Rmax−1$R_{{max} - 1}$ in (c$c$). The open circles correspond to all UMZs in (c$c$). The inset shows the same result in viscous wall units.

Figure 8

Figure 8.(a$a$) The schematic of the conditional averaging procedure at UMZ edges. The coloured contours and black line contours denote U/UCL$U/U_{\textit{CL}}$ and the UMZ edges, respectively. The red solid line corresponds to the outer envelope of the edges. The red ⋄$\diamond$ symbols indicate the interface coordinates yi$y_i$, while the black ⋄$\diamond$ symbols mark the grid points sampled in the near vicinity of each interface. (b$b$) The conditionally averaged streamwise velocity profile ⟨U|i⟩$\langle U|_i \rangle$ at yi/R=0.1$y_i/R = 0.1$. The profiles are plotted relative to the local frame of reference at each interface yi$y_i$. Here, ΔU$\Delta U$, δω$\delta _\omega$ and ∂⟨U⟩/∂y|max$\partial \langle U\rangle /\partial y|_{\textit{max}}$ denote the average velocity jump, the shear-layer thickness and the maximum local velocity gradient, respectively. (c,d) The variations of ΔU+$\Delta U^{+}$ with wall-normal distance for all UMZs (c$c$) and for the self-similar UMZs (d$d$). The insets show the same results in viscous wall units. Note that ΔU+$\Delta U^{+}$ in (d$d$) corresponds only to the UMZs satisfying the self-similarity criteria defined in § 5.1.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Figure 9 long description.The variations of the shear-layer thickness δω/λT$\delta _\omega /\lambda _T$ as a function of yi/R$y_i/R$. (a$a$) All UMZs; (b$b$) wall-scaled UMZs, where λT$\lambda _T$ denotes the local Taylor microscale. For the wall-scaled UMZs, δω$\delta _\omega$ is further normalised by different characteristic length scales: (c$c$) the pipe radius R$R$; (d$d$) Reτ1/2$\textit{Re}_\tau ^{1/2}$ (associated with the vortical fissure scaling); (e$e$) the viscous length scale δν$\delta _\nu$; (f$f$) the local Kolmogorov length scale η$\eta$.

Figure 10

Figure 10.(a$a$) The relationship between the lower edge yL$y_{L}$ and the upper edge yU$y_{U}$. The dashed line indicates yU=1.62yL$y_{U}=1.62y_L$. (b$b$) The ratio yL/yU$y_{L}/y_{U}$ as a function of yL$y_{L}$. In (a,b), the grey lines indicate all UMZs, and the coloured symbols indicate the wall-scaled UMZs at each Reτ$\textit{Re}_\tau$. The inset in (b$b$) shows the fraction of the wall-scaled UMZs relative to all UMZs, Ns/Nall$N_s/N_{{all}}$, as a function of Reτ$\textit{Re}_{\tau }$.

Figure 11

Figure 11.(a$a$) The conditionally averaged streamwise velocity of the wall-scaled UMZs, ⟨Us⟩+$\langle U_s \rangle ^+$, at Reτ=550$\textit{Re}_{\tau } = 550$, 1000$1000$, 3000$3000$ and 6000$6000$. The dashed line indicates the logarithmic law, ⟨U⟩+=1/κln⁡(y+)+B$\langle U \rangle ^+ = 1/\kappa \ln (y^+) + B$, where κ=0.39$\kappa = 0.39$ and B=4.3$B = 4.3$. (b$b$) The logarithmic-law indicator function of ⟨Us⟩+$\langle U_s \rangle ^+$, Ξ1=y+d⟨Us⟩+/dy+$\varXi _1 = y^+ \mathrm{d}\langle U_s \rangle ^+ / \mathrm{d}y^+$. The inset shows Ξ1$\varXi _1$ plotted against y/R$y/R$. (c$c$–f$f$) The indicator function at each Reynolds number. Here, the vertical lines denote y+=3Reτ1/2$y^+ = 3\textit{Re}_\tau ^{1/2}$ and 0.2R+$0.2R^+$. In (a$a$–f$f$), the grey lines indicate the unconditioned mean streamwise velocity, ⟨U⟩+$\langle U \rangle ^+$, for comparison.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Figure 12 long description.(a$a$) The conditionally averaged streamwise turbulence intensity of the wall-scaled UMZs, ⟨us2⟩+$\langle u_s^2 \rangle ^+$, at Reτ=550$\textit{Re}_\tau = 550$, 1000$1000$, 3000$3000$ and 6000$6000$. (b$b$) The logarithmic-law indicator function Ξ2=yd⟨us2⟩+/dy$\varXi _2 = y{\rm d}\langle u_s^2 \rangle ^+ / {\rm d}y$. (c$c$–f$f$) The indicator function for each Reynolds number. Here, the vertical lines represent the range where a plateau (Ξ2=−0.95=−A1$\varXi _2 = -0.95 = -A_1$) occurs. In (a$a$–f$f$), the grey lines indicate the unconditioned streamwise turbulence intensity, ⟨u2⟩+$\langle u^2 \rangle ^+$, for comparison.

Figure 13

Figure 13.(a$a$) The conditionally averaged spanwise turbulence intensity of the wall-scaled UMZs, ⟨ws2⟩+$\langle w_s^2 \rangle ^+$, at Reτ=550$\textit{Re}_\tau = 550$, 1000$1000$, 3000$3000$ and 6000$6000$. (b$b$) The logarithmic-law indicator function, Ξ3=yd⟨ws2⟩+/dy$\varXi _3 = y{\rm d}\langle w_s^2 \rangle ^+ / {\rm d}y$. (c$c$–f$f$) The indicator function for each Reynolds number. Here, the vertical lines represent the range where a plateau (Ξ3=−0.38=−A2$\varXi _3 = -0.38 = -A_2$) occurs. In (a$a$–f$f$), the grey lines indicate the unconditioned spanwise turbulence intensity, ⟨w2⟩+$\langle w^2 \rangle ^+$, for comparison.

Figure 14

Figure 14.The conditionally averaged wall-normal turbulence intensity and Reynolds shear stress of the wall-scaled UMZs, ⟨vs2⟩+$\langle v_s^2 \rangle ^+$ and −⟨usvs⟩+$-\langle u_{s}v_{s} \rangle ^+$, respectively. The closed circles represent the conditional averages over all wall-scaled UMZs, while the open circles denote the corresponding quantities, ⟨vs2⟩>+$\langle v_s^2 \rangle ^+_\gt$ and −⟨usvs⟩>+$-\langle u_s v_s \rangle ^+_\gt$, obtained for cases with NUMZ≥⟨NUMZ⟩=5$N_{\textit{UMZ}} \ge \langle N_{\textit{UMZ}} \rangle = 5$ (which corresponds to ⟨NUMZ⟩$\langle N_{\textit{UMZ}} \rangle$ at Reτ=6000$\textit{Re}_\tau = 6000$). The grey lines indicate the unconditioned statistics, ⟨v2⟩+$\langle v^2 \rangle ^+$ and −⟨uv⟩+$-\langle uv \rangle ^+$, for comparison. The vertical dashed lines inserted in each panel denote the peak location of −⟨uv⟩$-\langle uv \rangle$ (yp$y_p$) and the position of y/R=0.1$y/R = 0.1$, respectively.

Figure 15

Figure 15.(a) The PDFs of the streamwise velocity fluctuations, u′(y)=u(y)/urms(y)$u'(y) = u(y)/u_{\textit{rms}}(y)$, at y/R=0.1$y/R = 0.1$ (dashed), 0.15$0.15$ (dashed–dot) and 0.2$0.2$ (solid) for Reτ=1000$\textit{Re}_\tau = 1000$, 3000$3000$ and 6000$6000$. (b$b$) The PDFs of the streamwise velocity fluctuations within the wall-scaled UMZs, us′(y)=us(y)/us,rms(y)$u_s'(y) = u_s(y)/u_{s,{rms}}(y)$, at the same wall-normal positions and Reynolds numbers. (c$c$) The wall-normal variation of the skewness S(u′)=⟨u3⟩/⟨u2⟩3/2$S(u') = \langle u^3 \rangle /\langle u^2 \rangle ^{3/2}$ (grey line) and S(us′)=⟨us3⟩/⟨us2⟩3/2$S(u_s') = \langle u_s^3 \rangle /\langle u_s^2 \rangle ^{3/2}$ (coloured line). The profiles corresponding to each Reτ$\textit{Re}_\tau$ are shifted upward by ΔS$\Delta S$ = 1. (d$d$) The Kullback–Leibler (KL) divergence between the PDFs of the streamwise velocity fluctuations and the Gaussian distribution. The coloured and grey lines indicate the KL divergence for us′$u_s'$ and u′$u'$, respectively. The KL divergence corresponding to each Reτ$\textit{Re}_\tau$ is shifted upward by ΔDu′=0.01$\Delta D_{u'} = 0.01$.

Figure 16

Figure 16.Figure 16 long description.The contours of the two-point KL divergence between the PDFs of the streamwise velocity fluctuations at two wall-normal locations (y1$y_1$ and y2$y_2$) for Reτ=3000$\textit{Re}_\tau = 3000$ and 6000$6000$. The panels (a,b) show Du′(Py1‖Py2)$D_{u'}(P_{y_1}\Vert P_{y_2})$ for the unconditioned field at Reτ=3000$\textit{Re}_\tau = 3000$ and 6000$6000$, respectively. The panels (c,d) show Dus′(Py1‖Py2)$D_{u_s'}(P_{y_1}\Vert P_{y_2})$ for the wall-scaled UMZ samples at the same Reynolds numbers. In (a$a$–d$d$), the lighter colours indicate smaller values of KL divergence and the solid line indicates the value of 0.001. (e, f) The difference ΔD=Dus′−Du′$\Delta D = D_{u_s'} - D_{u'}$ at Reτ=3000$\textit{Re}_\tau = 3000$ and 6000$6000$. Here, the blue contours indicate negative values of ΔD$\Delta D$, indicating that Dus′$D_{u_s'} \lt D_{u'}$. The inserted dashed lines mark the lower and upper bounds of the logarithmic region.

Figure 17

Figure 17.The variation of the mean number of UMZs, ⟨NUMZ⟩$\langle N_{\textit{UMZ}} \rangle$, according to the subdomain size lz+$l_z^+$.

Figure 18

Figure 18.The conditionally averaged (a) mean velocity ⟨Us⟩+$\langle U_s \rangle ^+$ and (b) streamwise turbulence intensity ⟨us′2⟩+$\langle u_s'^2 \rangle ^+$ from wall-scaled UMZs, extracted using different domain lengths lz+=1000,2000$l_z^+ = 1000, 2000$ and 3000$3000$ at Reτ=550$\textit{Re}_{\tau } = 550$ (black) and 1000$1000$ (green).

Figure 19

Figure 19.Figure 19 long description.(a,b) Influence of the detection criteria on ⟨Hm⟩$\langle H_m \rangle$ corresponding to R2$R_2$ to Rmax−1$R_{max -1}$, obtained by varying (a$a$) the slope and (b$b$) the offset. The dashed line denotes ⟨Hm⟩=0.75ym$\langle H_m \rangle = 0.75\,y_m$. (c,d) Influence of the detection criteria on ⟨us2⟩+$\langle u_s^2 \rangle ^{+}$ of the wall-scaled UMZs, obtained using the same criteria as in (a,b), respectively. The inset in each panel shows the corresponding logarithmic-law indicator function, Ξ2$\varXi _2$. The grey line indicates the corresponding unconditioned result.

Figure 20

Figure 20.Examples of instantaneous streamwise velocity fields in the y$y$–z$z$ plane dominated by wall-scaled UMZs (a$a$) and non-wall-scaled UMZs (b$b$). In (a$a$, b$b$), the horizontal dashed line denotes y/R=0.35$y/R=0.35$, and each colour represents a different UMZ. (c$c$, d$d$) The PDFs of U/UCL$U/U_{\textit{CL}}$ computed from the instantaneous fields shown in (a$a$) and (b$b$), respectively. The colours in (c$c$) and (d$d$) correspond to the UMZs identified in (a$a$) and (b$b$), respectively. (e$e$) The conditionally averaged streamwise turbulence intensity for the wall-scaled UMZs (closed circles) and the non-wall-scaled UMZs (open circles). (f$f$) The corresponding indicator function, Ξ2=yd⟨us2⟩+/dy$\varXi _2=y\,\mathrm{d}\langle u_s^2 \rangle ^{+}/\mathrm{d}y$. In (e$e$, f$f$), the blue and red symbols represent Reτ=3000$\textit{Re}_{\tau }=3000$ and 6000$6000$, respectively, and the grey lines indicate the corresponding unconditioned quantities for comparison.

Figure 21

Figure 21.The wall-normal variation of the KL divergence between the PDFs of the cross-stream velocity fluctuations and the Gaussian distribution under both unconditioned (grey line) and wall-scaled UMZ conditions (coloured line): (a$a$) wall-normal velocity fluctuations and (b$b$) spanwise velocity fluctuations. The KL divergence corresponding to each Reτ$\textit{Re}_\tau$ is shifted upward by 0.01$0.01$.