La tentación populista contains much information and analysis of interest to students of populism in modern Latin America, yet it is a flawed contribution to the huge literature on the subject. It is, as the publisher promises, a synthesis that covers most of the sweep of the twentieth century and brings the story up to the present. It aspires to be encyclopaedic, incorporating dozens of populists identified in the literature (and some who were not). Flavia Freidenberg utilises a political definition of populism very similar to one proposed years ago in two volumes edited by this reviewer, Latin American Populism in Comparative Perspective (1982) and Populism in Latin America (1999), neither of which is cited. In general, the approach taken is near the mainstream of populist writings throughout the Americas.
The book's uneven quality is due to several characteristics. Firstly, although the working definition of populism wisely emphasises the way in which populists gain power rather than what they do while in office, much of the analysis of the many cases relapses into standard descriptions of the subjects' careers, even including such information as how they left office, which nobody has argued is a defining characteristic of populism. Secondly, the definition, I believe, correctly de-emphasises ideologies and economic programmes, yet the actual narratives here spend a great deal of time on economic policies and performance. This disjuncture between theory and marshalling of facts not only makes the text much longer than necessary, by including information of little theoretical relevance, but also undermines the reader's confidence in the theory.
Just as troubling is the superficiality of the historical sections dealing with the classical populists, which often lack a clear grasp of the subjects. Lázaro Cárdenas is described, for example, without covering his historic 1934 campaign in which he earned the nickname ‘Tata Lázaro’. Juan Domingo Perón is discussed with barely a mention of Evita and with no attention given to the descamisados. A Peruvian populist is mistakenly named ‘Víctor Hugo’ Haya de la Torre. The section on Arnulfo Arias is especially weak, overlooking the enormous appeal of his Panameñismo. The reader is left to doubt theoretical superstructures that are based on sandy foundations. The same is true of the dozens of tables offered throughout the text, which attempt to give an empirical gloss to data that are often questionable. Finally, Getúlio Vargas is the only Brazilian populist included, leaving out an impressive group of leaders associated with the Populist Republic (1946–64). In contrast, the book includes a full chapter on Evo Morales, even though it concludes that he is not a populist, and another on local Bolivian politicians.
Some sections stand out, especially where the author has first-hand research experience, as she does in Ecuador. Thus the analyses of Jaime Roldós, Abdalá Bucarám, Rafael Correa and Álvaro Noboa are particularly rich. Also, sidebar excerpts from speeches provide scintillating glimpses of populist rhetoric in action.
Readers looking for reliable information on the most recent populists, from Hugo Chávez to Correa, will focus on the later chapters of the book. These offer straightforward accounts of the rise of this new generation, with attempts to compare these populists with their earlier counterparts. The author uses a standard format in approaching these subjects, with sections on the style of leadership, the social base of support and the type of mobilisation, discursive strategies, the content of economic and social policies, and, when appropriate, exit from the presidency.
The book would have benefited from good copy editing. Some usages and neologisms (for example, discrecionalismo, cholocracia, partidos carismáticos) are at best inelegant. An index would have been a welcome tool to enable the reader to navigate the scores of people and many eras covered, and the bibliography reveals an overwhelming reliance on Spanish sources, containing few works in English and none in Portuguese.
Throughout the book the author takes a neutral, non-judgmental stance with regard to populism, arguing for example that it helped spread and strengthen democracy while perhaps failing to achieve true representative government. The final chapter, however, reveals a fairly negative interpretation, referring to the phenomenon as a syndrome, suggesting a medical or mental disorder. Populists act as ‘antidepresivos sociales’. They succumb to the ‘tentación de movilizar a los ciudadanos y traficar con sus esperanzas’ (p. 277). Indeed, it is only on this last page that we get an inkling of what the author means by the term tentación in the title, and it is hardly neutral.
