The idea of a state-ruled brothel is not new in Western societies. As Rossiaud has demonstrated for fifteenth-century France, where fornication was practiced in the protected spaces of Renaissance prostibula publica, municipal authorities and feudal lords had practically the monopoly of prostitution. In terms of a long-time history, prostitution – or more accurately, the action of having sexual intercourse in exchange for money or goods – has had different meanings and social values.
Since modernity has arisen, however, prostitution has become a main issue on the social and political agenda. The eruption of what Foucault called ‘disciplinary society’ was possible thanks to a cluster of professionals in charge of the administration of life, cleansing bodies and condemning practices in order to look after ‘social wellbeing’. Women's bodies and sexuality became a focus of biopower and transited from a locus of temptation and death-for-men mediaeval and Renaissance conceptions to a weak, biologically dominated entity created by modern medical scholars. The bourgeois anxiety for the improvement of ‘dangerous’ social classes has been summed up as ‘ameliorism’. This doctrine assumes that social problems are the result of individual deviance, mainly due to poverty, and not to social exclusion or power relations between classes, groups and gender-differentiated individuals. Prostitution is then a resource used by poor, marginal, uneducated women in order to survive. But this does not mean that prostitution should grow according to market laws and economic equilibrium; on the contrary, it must be the object of close surveillance or maybe complete eradication on behalf of the social interest.
The cyclical and intense debate about reglamentarism, abolitionism or legalisation of prostitution is not only a matter that concerns public health, ethics and the law, but a political reaction anchored in deep, elemental, controversial conceptions about class, gender, power and the body. Patty Kelly's book on a brothel in Chiapas, Mexico, shows that these nineteenth-century ideas are still troublesome in most parts of the world at the beginning of the twenty-first century, from a Mexican city to the Swedish state (p. 211). Does prostitution degrade women? Must it be prohibited or permitted under certain circumstances? Is prostitution only performed by poor, deviant women? Are women's bodies usable and expendable?
During her broad and in-depth ethnographic research, Kelly answers these and other questions about how prostitution is understood and experienced by a group of women who work in a state-regulated brothel located in Tuxtla Gutiérrez, capital city of the south-eastern state of Chiapas. Its location is crucial to keep this dishonourable but ‘socially necessary’ practice away from public eyes. In a modernising project aimed at containing and regulating sexual commerce by criminalising street prostitutes, Tuxtla's authorities tried to circumscribe the legal exercise of prostitution to a tolerance zone. But while the Zona Galáctica is supposed to be a safe, risk-controlled place where women are periodically checked out for sexually transmitted diseases, work from nine to nine – ‘respectable’ hours – and practice safe sex thanks to the condom stock they regularly receive, the truth is that prostitutes there must pay high rates for the rooms they rent, have scarce health benefits and live a sort of ‘double life’: as prostitution at the state-ruled brothel must be a stable, full-time activity, the women don't enjoy the advantages of working shorter time or quitting when they want as the street prostitutes do. Because of the visible stigma involved, women have to conceal, by any means, to their family and friends that they work in the Galactic Zone. On the other hand, working at a state-ruled brothel does not protect women from the exploitation of pimps. Many of them are obligadas (forced), mainly because they came from Central America, running away from terrifying living conditions of poverty and violence, and thus have undocumented immigrant status.
Organised in eight chapters and an epilogue, Patty Kelly's book shows all the complexities and contradictions of sex work in a small provincial city that has been shot into the twenty-first century by its local authorities. The author analyses profoundly the cultural beliefs that moved state authorities to create a sanitised and invisible place to which to confine prostitution, and the daily organisation and daily life of the brothel, as well as the inner lives and thoughts of the working women, their relationship with clients, the way they experience stigmatisation, their immediate fears and hopes, and their expectations for the future. All these elements provide an inside vision of what being a prostitute in Tuxtla nowadays is like. It is very interesting to note that there is no place for male prostitutes at the Galactic Zone. In a way, the Chiapas government does not recognise the existence of male sex workers or of clients seeking these services. Again, prostitution is a gendered matter.
I do not completely agree with Kelly's opinion of prostitution as an activity that challenges cultural norms and the gender order by allowing women to make a living without masculine support. On the contrary, the way it is viewed in the Galactic Zone reinforces the idea that the realm of sexuality still divides women into ‘good’ and ‘bad’. As Vance has pointed out, ‘[in] spite of the breakup of the ancient pact that opposed sexual safety to sexual freedom, women's fear of reprisals and punishment due to their sexual activity has not decreased’ (1989: 11–12). In spite of this discrepancy, Lydia's Open Door is a captivating, well-written book that makes use of the author's ethnographic skills and theoretical baggage. Undoubtedly, this book is a key reference for those interested in the way in which neoliberalism transforms the exercise of prostitution into something ‘modern’, by exhibiting hidden nineteenth-century moral values, in a society ‘trapped’ between tradition and modernity.
