No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 April 2005
The historian Richard Crockatt paints on a broad canvas to untangle the mutual incomprehension between mainstream America and the peoples of the world whose lives are more or less continuously and profoundly affected by the exercise of U.S. global power. This thoughtful and judicious book maps the complex and contradictory relationship of U.S. supremacy in the post–Cold War world; the self-referential political culture that has historically motivated the broad U.S. public to support the global projects undertaken by American state managers with little understanding of, or attention to, the actual consequences for the lives of non-Americans; the resentments and resistances that U.S.-centered and massively unequal globalization has engendered worldwide; and the ways in which militant ideologies of “political Islam” have drawn energy from these. Crockatt identifies a confluence of political, economic, and cultural processes that together have generated something like a global-political perfect storm of dominance and resistance, terror, and increasingly terrible “war on terror.” “The main claim of the book,” he writes, “is that September 11 must be understood in light of the interaction between America's dominant international position since the end of the Cold War, the rise of political Islam, and the complex set of phenomena that comes under the heading of globalization” (p. ix).
Crockatt's first order of business is to understand the idiosyncratic way Americans see the world and their place within it. He notes that most Americans reacted to the attacks of 11 September with “shock and bafflement,” seeing the attacks as coming “out of the blue” (p. 8), with little or no awareness of their contextual relationship to America's global role. Not for the first time Americans framed their narratives of world politics in terms of a threatening intrusion, a malevolent disruption of the “normalcy” of daily life in America that required a putatively extraordinary U.S. response. It was seen as yet another American “loss of innocence,” but how is it that Americans are capable of repeatedly losing their virginity?
In this Crockatt detects a culturally based historical pattern, “a central tension in American history: the coexistence of an ambition for power and growth with an aspiration to exemplary status as an ideal republic” (p. 23). Crockatt briefly summarizes America's historical expansionism and contrasts the increasingly pervasive exercise of U.S. power with what he calls the “official story” that has been widely accepted by generations of Americans: “the self-image of the United States as a peace-loving beacon of democracy and a benign distributor of goods to a grateful world” (p. 27). This comfortable (and resilient) self-image is made possible by key historical features of American political culture, which Crockatt clearly identifies. America's founding mythology is understood in terms of an emancipatory struggle to construct an exemplary democratic republic in the face of overwhelmingly superior colonial power. This American genesis story is then projected as a transhistorical identity, the unalterable essence of national character. Viewed in these terms, it is almost inconceivable that postcolonial America could be a colonial power in the same way that Britain or Belgium was. Americans are further armored against imperial self-awareness by the ideological separation of economics from politics:
The United States' core value system does not admit the possibility that the economic structure itself—the capitalist system—may exert a malign influence, that it may exploit what it appears to benefit. Indi- vidual malefactors may and do exist; evil is a fact of life…. However, to see the motor of the American productive system as inherently dangerous to the lives and liberties of other nations hardly enters into the consciousness of those who see its benefits in the form of high standards of living and consumption as self-evidently good and of benefit to all [p. 31].
This powerful mythology of essential republican innocence Crockatt dubs “Americanism.” He then places anti–Americanism in relation to it as the equally essentialized ideological mirror image, representing America as the very embodiment of the dark side of modernity. “If … the peculiar blindness of Americans is to regard themselves as acted upon by the world rather than acting, the peculiar blindness of non–Americans is to regard America as the source of all the things they dislike in the contemporary world” (p. 57). Briefly mapping the worldwide intensification of such sentiments, Crockatt argues that in the eyes of much of the world, “the empire has subsumed the democratic republic” (p. 70). He concludes that “anti–Americanism in the Muslim world is a special case of the general anti–Americanism in much of the Third World” (p. 69).
But, of course, Islamic militancy cannot be reduced to anti–Americanism. Crockatt sketches the rise of political Islam over the past generation and the ways in which it has drawn strength from a confluence of historical processes: the pressures of modernization, which is both too fast and too slow; the failures of Arab nationalism; the unresolved plight of the Palestinians and America's complicity in Israeli expansionism; imperial petro-politics, which have put America in bed with repressive forces throughout the region; and such formative events as the Islamist-led Iranian Revolution and the anti-Soviet Afghan jihad.
In the context of a post–Cold War world in which American power is unrivaled, in which American-led globalization has produced cultural change and historic levels of inequality, in which institutions and processes of global governance have emerged but are limited in capability and subject to U.S. power, and in which Americans and non–Americans understand in almost diametrically opposed terms the world they must live in together, the stage is set for mutual incomprehension and conflict, terror, and counter-terror.
In a grand synthesis, Crockatt ably weaves together the strands of this tragic tapestry. This is a rewarding read and a fine teaching text, rich in opportunities for reflection and discussion. Perhaps ironically, though, the very ideological disjunction that the text so ably identifies means that it is unlikely to be equally beneficial to American and non–American audiences. In particular, Crockatt bends over backward to avoid the reflexive and unreflective anti–Americanism that is so widespread in today's world and to help his readers approach “America” in a more judicious manner. But in doing so, he may underemphasize those aspects of his broad canvas that might be most instructive to American readers: the ugly history of U.S. imperialism and the justifiable reasons that so much of the world is suspicious of U.S. power.