In Observing Theatre Daniel Meyer-Dinkgräfe and co-authors investigate the subjective and spiritual dimensions of theatre as it is practised, studied and experienced. Having offered a broad introduction to the field of consciousness studies, the book moves through chapters on nostalgia, intercultural theatre and theatre criticism, before using the work of German geobiologist Hans Binder as a lens through which to view the relationship between theatre and consciousness. The chapter on nostalgia draws together original trains of thought, examining the notion as both a critical and a theatrical tool which exerts a powerful force on subjectivity, but concludes with a baffling list of plays which serve as examples (of which there are forty-three). Chapter 2 introduces the term ‘intuitive collaboration’ (p. 61) as a model for intercultural theatre practice, and aims to outline a framework within which future research might take place. Through a discussion of a collaborative dance project between Meyer-Dinkgräfe, PhD student Gayathri Ganapathy and dancer Shrikant Subramaniam, a mode of performance creation is carefully outlined which eschews the rational and the objective in favour of the intuitive and the subjective. Chapter 3 discusses theatre criticism and its relation to acting, noting that critics often fail when it comes to praising acting and are more comfortable with negative criticism. This is situated in a historical context, via philosophy and religion, to argue that blame is deeply rooted in Western culture, and is followed by two sample reviews that outline an alternative, more sensitive form of criticism. Chapters 4 and 5 present Binder's principles of consciousness, which are thought through in relation to a wide variety of theatrical contexts, including practice as research, the canon, applied theatre and how actors cope with demanding roles. Whilst the individual sections seem disparate, the focus provided by Binder allows for a sense of overall coherence, with his thoughts on resonance, natural law and intuition finding surprising homes in the context of theatre studies.
The conclusion takes the form of a discussion between the contributors on the contents of the previous chapters. Benjamin Poore expresses his doubt as to whether the examples he mentioned in chapter 1 ‘are fully representative of what prevails in theatre more broadly’ (p. 183). This then opens up a conversation between Binder and Meyer-Dinkgräfe on whether or not this was the case. Such self-reflexive critique is compelling, and allows the concern with subjectivity to effect the form of the book. Thus critiquing Meyer-Dinkgräfe's methodology for lacking a more formal rigour would appear to be missing the point. Rather than constructing a logical argument, Binder's thinking is taken for granted ‘in order to tease out the implications of that approach’ (p. 217). The study resonates with the growing interest in the relationship between performance and philosophy, complementing but also departing from work by scholars such as Laura Cull and James Hamilton. Readers with an interest in the relationship between spirituality, consciousness and theatre will find the book both insightful and engaging.
