Charlie Parker and Bud Powell walk into a bar. No, no, wait a minute: Charlie Parker and Bud Powell are playing in a bar. It's Birdland, on Broadway near 52nd Street, early 1955. Parker is not in great shape. In fact, in a few weeks, his drug-exhausted body will be found in the apartment of the Baroness Pannonica de Koenigswarter. But it's Powell, the pianist, who's misbehaving. He stubbornly insists on his own tempo. He ignores suggestions for repertory, or refuses to play the bridge of a tune. At one point, he turns his bench away from the piano and, with a mirthless grin, stares at the audience. The band takes a break. Backstage, the manager yells at Parker for letting things to get so out of hand. When they return to the stage, Parker suggests that they play “Out of Nowhere.” “What key do you want it in?” asks Powell. “S, mother,” Parker snaps back.Footnote 1
Ah, yes. Charlie Parker and Bud Powell. The bad boys of bebop. Their lives are an incorrigible challenge for biographers. Parker—better known as Bird—was a revolutionary creative artist, but also a scoundrel. For much of his life he was invisible, as he spent hours securing the heroin that fed his habit. His personality was, to put it mildly, mercurial. As Chuck Haddix puts it, the eighty-two people interviewed for Robert Reisner's Bird: The Legend of Charlie Parker (published in 1962, and for years the only biographical source) seem to have seen eighty-two different Charlie Parkers (3). Nor was Powell, the legend of bebop piano, any less intractable. Aggressive, headstrong, incapable of holding a drink, he had barely started his career before he began disappearing behind the walls of mental institutions. Not surprisingly, both have inspired major films: Clint Eastwood's Bird (1988), and Bertrand Tavernier's Round Midnight (1986), based on the reminiscences of Francis Paudras, Powell's French champion.
Of the recent biographies on these two men, Haddix's new book, Bird: The Life and Music of Charlie Parker, takes the most straightforward approach by attempting to capture his life through documented facts. In Parker's youth, these are relatively few: his birth in 1920; his marriage to Rebecca Ruffin in 1936, and the birth of his son, Francis Leon, in 1938; a dramatic automobile accident on Thanksgiving Day 1936, that threatened Parker's life (and may have led to his addiction to narcotics). Of course, his story is far richer than that, but it rests primarily in oral history. However evocative musicians’ reminiscences might be, they are not the most reliable resource. But Haddix, a native of Kansas City and currently head of the Marr Sound Archives at the University of Missouri–KC Library, adds a few more through new interviews and thorough digging in archives. No one before has mentioned, for example, the young seven-year-old Parker's attendance at the Penn School, the first educational institution for black students west of the Mississippi. A careful reading of newspaper ads helps pin down such minutiae as his first professional gig, at age fourteen, with Lawrence Keyes's Ten Chords of Rhythm in 1935; several crucial months with alto saxophonist Buster Smith at the Antler's Club in the summer of 1938; his first stint with the Jay McShann band in a November 1938 gig, as well as the beginning of the second in March 1940.
Moving beyond these scattered printed resources is tricky. Haddix cites oral history, but with caution. One of the chief witnesses on early Parker is the pianist Jay McShann, who lived in Kansas City until his death in 2006. In a 1997 interview with Haddix, McShann said he first heard Parker while walking by a nightclub, as the alto saxophonist's playing was piped out to the sidewalk (33). The same memory is recounted by Brian Priestley.Footnote 2 However, Priestley also reports—as does Haddix—that McShann said on another occasion that he first heard Parker on the radio, mistaking his playing for Buster Smith's. In a third interview, McShann claimed he first glimpsed Parker as a “cocky kid” who pushed his way onto the bandstand. Obviously, there's no way to reconcile these memories, or to judge which is authentic. Much the same can be said of other witnesses relied on by biographers. According to Carl Woideck, Parker's first trip to New York in 1939 is a puzzle. To sort it out, he offers numerous possibilities. One involves a second trip to New York, which no one has mentioned but that resolves some inconsistencies in the testimony of “the generally reliable” bassist Gene Ramey, one of the main eyewitnesses.Footnote 3 Haddix does his best to describe Parker's New York experience, but cannot specify when the saxophonist arrived in New York, or when he was forced to return to Kansas City after his father's murder—which, depending on who you believe, could be the fall of 1939 or the spring of 1940. (No one as yet has ended the speculation by uncovering his father's death certificate.) Haddix's book is brief (under two hundred pages), reliable, and unsentimental. It provides a few surprises, including a solo by Parker from a previously undiscovered test recording from 1942. But for most readers, it gives yet another take on a familiar story.
One might expect more novelty from Stanley Crouch's Kansas City Lightning: The Rise and Times of Charlie Parker. This, after all, is only the first volume of what promises to be a mammoth biography of Parker by the well-established journalist and novelist. Kansas City Lightning covers only the first twenty-two years of Parker's life, leading up to his stunning debut at the Savoy Ballroom in Harlem with Jay McShann in 1942. Crouch has been working on this biography for a long time, so many of his interviews with McShann, Gene Ramey, and Buster Smith date back to the early 1980s.
Yet, any hopes for clarifying the chronology of these early years are dashed. Crouch takes his ample resources in oral history too literally, often leading him astray. He writes that Parker's time with Buster Smith at the Antler's Club happened in “early 1937,” not 1938, as Haddix insists. He even claims that Parker's playing there benefited from “the time [he had] spent in the Ozarks.” That Ozarks gig, where three solid months of practicing transformed the indifferent improviser into a master, happened after this date, in the summer of 1937 (206). He also confuses Parker's stints with two major Kansas City big bands. As Haddix explains—and this is documented by newspaper citations—Parker played with Jay McShann for a month in 1938 before being hired away by Harlan Leonard's Rockets in November. Crouch instead has him playing with Leonard first before being hired away by McShann (241–42). On his return from New York in 1940, he has Parker rejoining Leonard's band before being hired again by McShann. As Leif Bo Peterson, who has kept a Parker chronology online puts it, “this seems improbable.”Footnote 4 That Crouch is aware of the problems of relying on oral history is evident later in the book. Parker's first wife, Rebecca, claims their final breakup happened “in East Saint Louis in 1939, when he was with Billy Eckstine's big band and a young, enthralled Miles Davis was there listening” (322), but Crouch has to admit that this was impossible, since Parker didn't play with Eckstine until five years later.
What, then, does Crouch derive from his interviewees? Mostly a vivid sense of what it was like to be a black musician in the 1930s and 1940s. He quotes generously from them, sometimes for pages at a time. This material is wonderfully evocative. It adds an element of the glorious idiosyncrasy of black speech that is often missing from jazz literature. To choose one example, here is Gene Ramey, recalling the McShann band's attitude on finally arriving in the Savoy Ballroom:
Our outlook was you were never supposed to be one of those walking into a place looking hankty or dicty [black slang for stuck-up, white behavior]. You go to go in there wild-like. Think wild, play wild. You see a guy so wrapped up intellect and you wonder, “Why don't this guy let himself go? Loosen that collar. Drop that shoulder a little bit. Relax.” That was our attitude: don't go in there and try to appear like Imperial Potentates of the Domestic Orders of the Shrine. Although music is serious, we don't want to make it so serious that we appear stiff-necked. . . . A stiff band will never shake the pillars of a dance hall. And we intended to tear the Savoy down. (22)
Of course, anyone who has dealt with oral history is well aware that a certain amount of editing is necessary. Any sensible researcher must edit idiomatic spoken prose into something that can be published. As one example, one need only compare Gene Ramey's spoken interviews, on file for years at the Institute for Jazz Studies, with a printed version of the same material in Stanley Dance's The World of Earl Hines to see how Ramey's sentiments have been tidied up and organized.Footnote 5 But there, at least, the original tape is available for study. Knowing Crouch's powerful rhetoric, one has to be suspicious about what, exactly, was on his tapes. Quotations like the above seem too polished, too Crouch-like, to pass as historical documents. The endnotes don't help much. Taking up only nine pages (by contrast, Haddix's are fourteen pages, Woideck's twenty, and Priestley's thirty-one), they are often imprecise. The above quotation, for example, receives the following endnote, which covers pp. 22–27: “Ramey, McShann, Ralph Ellison, and John Tumoni in interviews and in conversations.” To be sure, no one is accusing him of making things up. I'm certain he talked to these people and recorded, as best as he could, their observations. But it might be more precise to amend this endnote as “remembered”—or “edited”—by Stanley Crouch.
Unfortunately, what makes this book so readable is also what makes it so untrustworthy. To be sure, the book's opening chapter, describing the McShann band's debut at the Savoy Ballroom (7–36), is beautifully written. But when Crouch shifts to Parker's humiliation at a Kansas City jam session (the scene that became the central image of the film Bird, where Parker's inept solo is rudely interrupted by a cymbal thrown across the room by Jo Jones), we see not only exactly how Parker stands:
When his nerve was up, young Charlie would cadge a cigarette and stand off to the side with his hand in his pocket, one leg forward and bent a little, trying to give off the look of an older player swimming deeply but easefully in the nightlife (150).
but also how things felt to him:
The instrument seemed heavier, the reed almost the size of a tongue depressor, the buttons on the keys slippery. He could feel his every breath, almost the flow of his blood, the indifferent presence of his nervous system (153).
Is this a biography or historical fiction? It's frustrating. Crouch had access to crucial eyewitnesses—“estimable men who knew all of the Kansas City fact and lore, understanding many of the varied meanings of that era and how far that brief time actually was from what is believed, or even documented, all these years later” (338)—yet he cannot help but take his biography far beyond the boundaries of the knowable.
Still, there are moments when Crouch puts his resources to good use. Most Parker fans remember an interview published in 1949, when Parker “came alive” while jamming with guitarist Biddy Fleet during his first visit to New York in 1939. Crouch tracked down Fleet, “a stocky, dark-brown-skinned man with conked hair . . . and shoes shining like a costly showroom car” (297). Fleet was a “natural handyman,” fond of taking things apart to find out how they worked. He and Parker worked together to explore harmonies. Countering the critique that Parker was an “idiot savant, unaware of the ingredients of his art,” Crouch writes:
Biddy and Charlie were following their ears but in a very systematic fashion. They moved through their music note by note, increasing their technical command in much the same way that apprentice mechanics learn the workings of automobiles by lying under them for hours and learning part by part how the engines and transmissions are put together and what makes them function (303).
But much of the book, regrettably, is filler—unless one knows nothing about jazz history, and prefers to get a short course by thumbing through pages and pages of this book. There are brief (and not-so-brief) digressions on the filmmaker D. W. Griffith, the gangster John Dillinger, the boxer Jack Johnson, each supported by a handful of books in his bibliography, (which only has fifty-seven entries). One only hopes that in taking on the remainder of Parker's life, Crouch sticks more to the subject at hand.
* * * * * *
Bud Powell was born four years after Parker, in Harlem in 1924. His musical gifts were evident early. His father hoped to prepare him for a career as a concert pianist, and something of the intricacy of Bach's passagework could be found in Powell's playing throughout his life. Yet he was drawn into contemporary African-American music, quickly bypassing the stride pianists for the aesthetics of the modernists. “Forget [Art] Tatum, we're talkin’ about something new,” he told Billy Taylor. “I want to make the piano sound just like Charlie Parker” (39–40).
Powell was an aggressive virtuoso. In his eagerness to be heard, he literally pushed pianists off their benches in jam sessions. He attracted the attention of Thelonious Monk, who championed his playing at Minton's Playhouse. Others were eager to capture his fire, too. When Dizzy Gillespie formed what has been known as the first bop combo on 52nd Street in late 1943, he tried reaching Powell, only to be told by his mother that the pianist had just taken a job with bandleader Cootie Williams. The timing was unfortunate—both for Gillespie and for Powell. “Bud was the pianist of choice,” Billy Taylor recalled. “That piano seat was left open for him. Don't think that Bud didn't think about that” (43).
Worse things happened a year later. On January 19, 1945, after playing with a sextet led by Williams in Philadelphia, he wandered over to the train station, only to be confronted by the railroad security force. Claiming he was drunk and disorderly, they beat him over the head before turning him over to the police. After his mother picked him up and returned him to Harlem, Powell suffered severe headaches. He made outrageous claims, such as that he owned the Chrysler building. She took him to a local hospital, which transferred him to Bellevue, which in turn recommended treatment at Pilgrim State Hospital. There he stayed for six weeks, tagged with the diagnosis of “Manic Depressive Psychosis.” Thus began Powell's status as a mental patient.
All this can be found in Peter Pullman's book Wail: The Life of Bud Powell. Pullman started working on the book over two decades ago, conducting hundreds of interviews with family members, friends, fellow jazz musicians . . . indeed, anyone who might have witnessed some aspect of Powell's life. Faced with the legal wall that protected Powell's institutional records, he sued the state of New York—a case resolved in his favor by the New York Supreme Court. He sorted through over a thousand pages of documents in the files of Powell's lawyer, Maxwell Cohen, as well as materials held by Francis Paudras, the French jazzophile and Powell fanatic who befriended Powell in the early 1960s. It is an impressive and densely documented book.
Pullman's Bud Powell is difficult to characterize. In the era of Black Lives Matter, it would seem easy to lay the blame for Powell's difficulties on that 1945 incident of police brutality. Yet from the beginning, Powell's personality clearly had its flaws. He was never very sociable—“one of those people who never follow[s] a conversation,” according to a childhood friend (13). His aggressive, “tigerish” qualities (looking as if “he were going to bite the piano” [78]) was one side of his public personality. But so, too, was his childlike dependence on the audience, borne from a “desperate need to get recognition commensurate with his talent” (104). Then, there was the disastrous effect of alcohol on his system. One drink could leave him both totally incapacitated and crudely belligerent. Even Charlie Parker learned to keep his distance. “Bird didn't want Bud in the band,” remembered Miles Davis, “because he ‘got too high.’ Now can you imagine Bird saying that somebody ‘got too high’? As high as he got?’” (83).
In a shrewd analysis, Pullman contrasts Powell's career with those of his fellow bop artists. Gillespie (and later, Davis) were the most “publicity-savvy” (97) of the bunch, always working hard to further their careers through recordings, interviews, and public appearances. But even the drug-saddled Parker had a charming, charismatic personality. And the taciturn Monk, who like Powell refused to accommodate outsiders, had a professional mentor in Alfred Lion, owner of Blue Note records. Lion recorded him in 1947 and promoted him heavily as the “High Priest of Bebop.” The reclusive Monk remained stubborn in his musical tastes, but amused audiences by wearing ridiculous hats and dancing on stage.
Powell had none of this. Every attempt he made to pursue his career was undercut by misbehavior. He lasted only a few months with Dizzy Gillespie's big band before he was fired for being “supererratic” (64). In 1947, when bebop was rising in publicity, he made several recordings as a sideman, including sessions with Parker and Dexter Gordon, but none on his own. His first recording as leader didn't occur until February 23, 1949—and even then, the date was a supervised day's leave from the Creedmoor Institute, where he was incarcerated. (Hospital records show that they thought he was being “allowed to apply for a position in a record company” [107].) Indeed, he might not have been kept so long had the folks at Creedmoor not wanted him to play in their annual Minstrel Show two weeks later (105–7). Powell's best recordings were made from 1949 to 1951. By the time people had begun to discover his genius, he had already begun to disintegrate under the stress.
Granted, Powell's behavior was often well beyond the pale, regardless of what he had gone through. Unlike most jazz musicians, he seemed stunned and hurt when not met with thunderous applause, even on casual gigs. “Why don't you clap?” he said to a group of fried-chicken eaters on a Sunday afternoon. “Are you afraid your Kotex are going to fall out?” (100). He could be equally rude to fellow musicians. With pianist George Shearing, who was notorious for quickly copping Powell's licks, that contempt might have been justified. But even then, it seems childish to light a match in Shearing's face to see if he was “really blind” or to put a thumbtack on his piano bench (103). But even Charlie Parker was a target. One night in Birdland, when Parker and Lennie Tristano sat at a table, Powell told him, “You know, Bird, you ain't shit. You don't kill me. You ain't playing shit now.” Parker politely kept his distance: “Lennie, don't pay any attention. I dig the way he plays” (188). On his 1951 recording of “Un Poco Loco,” the drummer Max Roach matched the pianist's intensity with a blistering polyrhythmic accompaniment, making this one of Powell's finest recordings. This earned from Powell the epithet: “You fucked up my record!” (161).
When he got drunk, he was far worse. He would often refuse to pay for his drinks, earning him a conk on the head with a baseball bat (82). He was fond of stealing people's drinks off of tables, a sleazy barroom trick that got him fired from the Blue Note in Paris (309). In short, he had an adolescent's pairing of high ego and exceptionally low inhibitions. Even when praised to the skies, he could react strangely. One night, when sitting in with Miles Davis's Birth of the Cool band, he played a solo so amazing that the audience erupted in approval. Powell, according to Sy Johnson, was terrified, “recoiling like a cornered animal.” Gerry Mulligan solved the problem by coming up to Powell and kissing him hard on the mouth—making his affection clear while “snapp[ing] Bud out of it” (139).
Some of this may have been playacting. But their totality suggests something worse. Undoubtedly Powell had problems that could have benefitted from close attention by intelligent therapists. Yet Pullman's perusal of his records (patient/doctor reports still remain confidential, but thanks to Pullman, the rest of Powell's record is now public) show how little an overworked New York mental health department cared about an individual patient, especially one who was black. All psychiatric diagnoses come from interviews, where the possibility of misunderstanding a black musical “genius” is evident. I, too, have written on the effect of ill-conceived psychiatric treatment on jazz musicians.Footnote 6 It's not hard to read in these interviews the inability of doctors to connect with their patient, or to understand why Powell seemed “preoccupied with the animosity that exist between the colored and the white races” (93). Pullman reports these observations straight, but wonders on the side whether his “silly, inappropriate smile” (172) or “giggling in response to the psychiatrists’ questions” (171) might have been better understood had we seen the situation or heard the questions. And there is no doubt who was in control. In a law court, innocence is assumed; but psychiatry lived by the rubric, “when in doubt . . . suspect illness” (91). Once considered a mental patient, Powell was in danger of being thrown back into an institution any time he was detained.
This happened in 1951, when both Powell and Monk were arrested on drug charges. It's not clear what happened (indeed, it may have been a setup), but someone, possibly Powell, threw a packet of heroin that landed near Monk's feet. Monk pled not guilty but was convicted anyway, losing his cabaret license for the next five years (which meant he couldn't play anywhere in New York for more than two consecutive nights). But as a former mental patient, Powell was put back into psychiatric care for another eighteen months. A new dose of ECT began: in just one eight-week period, he received thirty-three shocks, sometimes just days before he was released for a weekend appearance at Birdland (174). Just as important, he severed his connections with Monk, his “only true mentor” (168), as well as his growing audience. When Marian McPartland came to visit him, he asked, “Do people still remember me?” (173).
The decade before Powell's death in 1964 was a long, slow decline. Pullman tracks it in detail, even as Powell became even less communicative and clearly dependent on alcohol and prescription drugs. Powell suffered from “non-performance anxiety”: when placed in front of a keyboard, he often did well, but he was lost during the long hours between gigs. The obvious thing, from his perspective, was to drink; but fearing his alcohol-fueled behavior, his caretakers insisted on sobriety, or made him wait until the end of the day to have a cognac. One of those caretakers was Altevia “Buttercup” Edwards, who entered his life in 1954. She claimed to be his wife and had Powell convicted in court as father of her new child, John Edwards, whom she took to referring to as Earl Powell, Jr. None of these things appeared to be true, but Edwards retained control for many years, throughout his long stay in Paris, keeping Powell in line with the vague threat of institutionalization.
Was “Buttercup” Edwards a positive or negative presence in Powell's life? Pullman doesn't force the issue, but the accumulation of evidence from his numerous informants suggests a relationship that was at its best sadly co-dependent, and at its worst crudely exploitative. A countering perspective comes from The Amazing Bud Powell: Black Genius, Jazz History, and the Challenges of Bebop by Guthrie Ramsey, who bases his opinion less on eyewitnesses and more on his interpretation of the secondary literature. He first cites a biography (The Glass Enclosure: The Life of Bud Powell by Alan Groves and Alyn Shipton) that casts Buttercup as “overbearing, parsimonious, pill-pushing, mercenary, and domineering.”Footnote 7 Yet Ramsey is more concerned with how this image of the “brazen, ‘emasculating’ black female” (familiar from “literature and film”) plays into what he calls the “heroic genius narrative,” which itself depends on “a conception of masculinity in which one is pitted in battle against various societal structures to make great art” (80).
Ramsey, the Edmund J. and Louise W. Kahn Term Professor of Music at the University of Pennsylvania, is perhaps best known for Race Music, a book that delves into his own family's complex history during the Great Migration to embed modern jazz in a much broader continuum of black music.Footnote 8 Indeed, his term “Afro-Modernism,” which describes a distinctly African American approach to modernist aesthetics, has been adopted by a wide range of contemporary scholars. In writing about Powell, Ramsey is returning to the subject of his 1994 dissertation, “The Art of Bebop: Earl ‘Bud’ Powell and the Emergence of Modern Jazz.”
The Amazing Bud Powell is not a biography per se, but a form of criticism on the pianist, self-proclaimed as “the first extended scholarly study of its kind” (6). In place of a straightforward chronological narrative, Ramsey positions Powell within the turmoil of contemporary scholarship. This covers a vast amount of territory—not just research from the “new jazz studies,” but the latest articles in musicology, cultural studies, anthropology, and feminism. “This study of Powell,” he writes, “illuminates his life's work, but also takes this opportunity to address larger issues in African American music” (42)—issues such as historiography, gender studies, concepts of “genius,” and black experimental art. It's difficult to keep one's eye on the subject in the midst of this fast-spinning collage. Ramsey sees Powell in multiple roles: “as a genius, as a black man, as a musician of Afrological and Eurological traditions, as a lawbreaker, as an experimental modernist, as a laborer in the modern jazz industry, as a subject in jazz criticism and history, and as a mental health patient” (109).
How can one organize such a book? Ramsey does his best with five broad chapters with evocative titles (the fourth is “Making the Changes: Jazz Manhood, Bebop Virtuosity, and a New Social Contract”), but the vast array of themes resist categorization. The argument wanders among many, many topics—race, commerce, jazz criticism, the visual arts, music analysis—with periodic links back to bebop and Powell.
Consider, for a moment, his discussion of “the gendered musical language of bebop genius” (7). Ramsey sees bebop as “masculine”: it was the music of the “primarily male black youth culture” (25). It was “revolutionary” and “heroic” (26), its discourse “masculinist, aggressive, and transformative” (31) and “shot through with the politics of gendered language: commercial conquest, cultural territorialism, violence, and musical ‘cutting contests’” (25–26). Yet the broader culture saw it, as a form of jazz, in the realm of pop music, which was “coded as feminine” (133). When early critics tried to put bebop in its place, they “emasculated” it through language he describes as feminine (32) (even though the specific examples he cites—“weird,” “neurotic,” and “foreign”—seem less feminine than psychological or xenophobic). When bebop finally entered the academy, musicologists “butched up” its discourse (134) by associating it with the dominant art music, classical music—even though that itself is often seen as feminine (e.g., “long-hair music”). In other words, “gender is about power” (38), and the fluctuations in power lead him to describe bebop rather imprecisely as “a slippery, transgendered discourse” (38–39).
This welter of academic voices inevitably yields many, many conclusions, some contradictory. Ramsey has the unenviable job of choosing his own position, which he does reluctantly. His discussion of “jazz manhood,” for example, leads him through scholarly work on Jelly Roll Morton, Fletcher Henderson, Max Roach, Billie Holiday, and Mary Lou Williams, with an odd detour through black women composers and Charles Ives. Summing up, he concludes “how complex, diffuse and contradictory gendered ideologies can be. They cannot be interpreted in the same way across time, genre, and geography” (134). Later in the book, he issues the following call to action, which reads something like a prompt for an undergraduate exam:
The disruptive appearance of bebop, then, provides an excellent opportunity to examine jazz and gender. . .. To what degree, we must ask, are these present in jazz history? How have they differed? And how have musical theories revealed the practice and politics of “jazzmanhood” in instrumental jazz? Jazz, like many American art forms, is grounded in multiple cultural heritages. How do we account for this multiplicity in the analytical framework? (141)
But these questions, falling as they do at the end, rather than the beginning, of a chapter, remain rhetorical.
There are, of course, places where Ramsey makes incisive observations, especially about race. Citing the common misconception that blacks “shunned jazz in favor of rhythm and blues,” he argues: “Such sentiments fail to acknowledge the diversity and complexity of African American audiences, especially in the postwar period” (35). He mocks a claim by jazz critic Martin Williams (admittedly, from 1964), that white critics took “jazz seriously, [wrote] its history, catalogued its records, criticized its players, and called it an ‘art.’” Williams cites as evidence Ellington's self-discovery at the segregated Cotton Club, causing Ramsey to counter: “Could the fact that white audiences at the Cotton Club were able to provide the financial support necessary for Ellington's music growth. . .? If so, then Williams's concerns are more economically based than they are racial” (36).
I have problems with his claim, though, that bebop could be described as “the avant-garde music of 1940s black youth culture” (24). In this, he aligns himself with Eric Lott, who in “Double V, Double-time: Bebop's Politics of Style” argued that bebop was “intimately if indirectly related to the militancy” of black protest during World War II.Footnote 9 Bebop certainly was political, and its music has an “unmistakable edge of resistance”; but it goes too far to map bebop musicians directly onto to the “zoot-suit” culture of the Harlem ghetto. Bop musicians shared some qualities with the black masses, including the threat of violence from police (a threat that has hardly gone away since), but their all-consuming professional careers kept them separate from the “zoot-suited, long-haired, and reefer-smoking” hipsters who, according to Ramsey, plagued 52nd Street (29). Powell provides the perfect example: far from being a zoot-suiter, his dress was sober and conservative. “With his reliance on solid, dark suits and white shirts with starched collars, and sometimes carrying a rolled umbrella,” Pullman notes, “he could have passed for a banker or a lawyer” (97).
Ramsey makes much of the “violent clashes” that pitted black musicians against white tormenters in midtown, but he cites only two. One was Miles Davis's infamous confrontation outside Birdland in 1959, much too late to be relevant to the 1940s. The other involved Dizzy Gillespie, who retells the story in his autobiography. But Gillespie's sense of the social implications of this clash were far less alarmist. He concludes: “There were few problems of racial discrimination on 52nd Street because most of the bands there were black. Even among the clientele on 52nd Street there was very little racist feeling.”Footnote 10
Ramsey's discussions of Powell himself are on firmer ground, informed by his dissertation research on Powell's early years. His sense of Powell's apprenticeships with the Cootie Williams band, a gig that placed him within the populist blues-based black mainstream, contradicts the frequent claim that bebop was non-commercial. It's unfortunate that Pullman's biography came out only as Ramsey's book was near conclusion, however, since it might have prevented Ramsey from repeating now-discredited material. For example, Ramsey praises the unexpected maturity of Powell's session for Roost Records, routinely dated as January 10, 1947 and therefore frequently cited as his debut as leader. Pullman clearly shows that this recording session could not have happened before the summer of 1949, resituating it in the midst of Powell's other trio recordings. Similarly, Ramsey repeats the claim that Powell was absent from the “Ko-Ko” recording of 1945 because he accompanied his mother as she bought a new home in Pennsylvania. Examining the records, Pullman finds that the house was bought the preceding year. And in a general sense, the brooding, complex character that haunts Pullman's Wail has no place in The Amazing Bud Powell, which prefers to show him as a “heroic genius,” struggling against adversity.
The last chapter of the book is devoted to music analysis—indeed, Ramsey is the only author of the four who uses musical notation. (His transcriptions of Powell's solos and compositions are largely accurate, with only occasional errors.) Early in the book, Ramsey complains few jazz musicians show interest in one of the main goals of analysis, “to expose organic unity” (19), but later claims that Powell's improvisations are “logical, shapely, and ordered” (145). He approvingly cites jazz pianist Vijay Iyer (now the Franklin D. and Florence Rosenblatt Professor of the Arts at Harvard), who argues that “logical motivic coherence” is only one dimension of a more complex experience: the narrative story of jazz improvisation “dwells not just in one solo at a time, but also in a single note, and equally in an entire lifetime of compositions” (146). This is an intriguing idea, but difficult to put into practice. Ramsey's method does seem to be “one solo at a time.” In Powell's performance of “Nice Work if You Can Get It,” Ramsey notes a spot where the pianist “appears to stumble.” This might indeed be one of the “puzzling shards” (in Iyer's words) that opens up a new way of focusing on Powell's idiosyncrasies. Similar passages pepper Powell's solos, suggesting his aggressive, “tigerish” intensity (biting off more than he can chew), as well as foreshadowing his later psychic decline. Ramsey instead notes it as a “mistake”; this rare glitch simply gives Powell “a burst of creative energy,” leading to “one of the more beautifully crafted sections of the solo” (169).
Analysis depends upon context. Should we look at Powell's improvisation in isolation, or compare it to the bebop style? Or should we place this generic style against its predecessor, swing? Surprisingly, this latter method dominates much of the chapter: Ramsey dutifully walks us through the basic bebop song structures and introduces us to his many colleagues, fellow soloists (like Dexter Gordon) and members of the rhythm section. This feels like stalling. He clearly would like to support the claim, made throughout the book, that Powell is not simply an ordinary bebop musician, but rises above it to the level of genius. At one point, he states that Powell's playing “possesses the refreshing melodic coherence and expressiveness found in the best of Charlie Parker's solos” (169). But this is circular reasoning: Parker's style is similarly ineffable. Failing to articulate a critique at this level, he instead boils down the complexity of Powell's style to bland observations:
In general, when Powell plays descending melodic lines, they move by stepwise motion. . . . Ascending lines often arpeggiate, although descending arpeggios are also present. Powell uses a high degree of chromaticism throughout, but nonharmonic tones usually resolve to a pitch consonant with the underlying harmony (167–69; references to specific measure numbers removed).
Of course, transcriptions are often less help than hindrance. There are always qualities of jazz performance that escape notation. In discussing “Nice Work” (where the transcription is borrowed from John Mehegan), Ramsey complains about the absence of the subtle accents and changes in dynamics that enliven Powell's solos. Of course, if he wanted to move in that direction, he could have adjusted the transcription, either with accent marks to show the shifting points of emphasis or parentheses to show “ghosted” notes. He could also have added left-hand chords, an extra rhythmic dimension rarely included in transcriptions of piano playing. To go further, he could have explored the idea of Powell's “embodied” performance. Ira Gitler described him this way in 1947: “right leg digging into the floor at an odd angle, pants leg up to almost the top of the shin, shoulders hunched, upper lip tight against his teeth, mouth emitting an accompanying guttural song.”Footnote 11 Ramsey's chapter is a noble first attempt, but fails to live up to Iyer's lofty vision.
By contrast, Pullman's description of music is less technical, avoiding music notation altogether. But Pullman has the clear advantage of scope. He describes virtually every Powell recorded performance, from the near perfection of recordings from 1949–1951 to a 1955 session that marked “the worst music that Powell had made on record” (222). These observations are blended in with Pullman's biographical narrative, making his book a real “life and works” study. Some aspects of his prose are a bit quirky, such as his use of onomatopoeia to describe music (the opening of “Un Poco Loco” comes out as “De-DAH, de-DAH, de-DAH, DOH-DOH-DOH!”) (160). Readers may also be confused by Pullman's decision to replace “black” and “white” with “afram” and “euram”—a useful, if initially puzzling, condensation of “African American” and “European American.” Pullman's book is also problematic in its documentation, possibly because it was first available as an e-book, where endnotes were easily accessible by a mouse-click. The published version has no separate bibliography, which makes it hard to keep track of his hundreds of interviews. Once an interviewee has been cited, the footnotes refer to “[Last name], op. cit,” causing the reader to thumb back through pages of notes to try to find the original reference. Despite these inconveniences, Pullman's Wail is the place to go for information on Bud Powell's life.
* * * * *
That gig at Birdland? It didn't end well. Frustrated, Parker walked offstage and retreated to the bar for some serious drinking. For the last set, the band limped along without a pianist. At one point, Parker took to the microphone, calling out “Bud Powell! Bud Powell! Bud Powell!” But Powell refused to return, hiding backstage for the rest of the night. (He was one of the last to leave.) The final word went to the bassist, Charles Mingus, who apologized for posterity: “This is not jazz.”Footnote 12
