Introduction
Human beings must have discovered the beneficial effect of burning resins and aromatic herbs for their well-being in pre-historical times and subsequently used incense in rituals around the world in almost all cultures and religions. Incense is used not only as an offering to a deity, but also to mask bad odours or to drive away evil spirits. Eventually, the development of various easily handled and transportable varieties of incense products established its routine use not just in places of worship but also on a personal level. Today, incense is used not only in most world religions for ceremonial rituals, but also for therapeutic purposes or else for enjoyment. The development of various easily handled and transportable varieties of incense eventually established it as a routinely used product not just in places of worship but also in individual homes. Incense is available in many forms such as in powder or granules, cones or sticks and generally consists of resins, aromatic substances, essential oils, and also of synthetic chemicals (Jetter et al Reference Jetter, Guo and McBrian2002). Special mixtures and fragrances such as sandalwood, magnolia, rose, lemon, lavender or vanilla are used. The burning of incense sticks results in the release not only of the desired fragrance but also of smoke. Large-scale incense burning, as practiced in many places of worship, results in high exposure to incense fumes, creating health problems for both workers and visitors. Often, the smoke is so dense that visibility is low and measured air pollution is very high (Lin et al Reference Lin, Krishnaswamy and Chi2008, Navasmurti et al 2008). Exposure also occurs when incense in burned in poorly ventilated homes.
Incense smoke analysis
Incense burns at temperatures of around 200–360°C, the level required to release the fragrance. However, the incomplete combustion of the organic material also results in the formation of toxic compounds. Analysis of several types of incense has revealed the presence of carcinogenic and toxic constituents in smoke emissions. Incense smoke condensate is mutagenic and genotoxic (Chang et al. Reference Chang, Kuo and Lin1997, Navas murti et al). High levels of particulate matter, including fine particles are generated upon incense burning (Ji et al Reference Ji, Le and Ramalho2010, Fang et al Reference Fang, Lin and Lee2009). A number of studies have reported the levels of harmful substances emitted during the burning of incense. These include volatile organic compounds, aldehydes, acrolein, formaldehyde and benzene (Löfroth et al Reference Löfroth, Stensman and Brandhorst-Satzkorn1991, Eggert and Hansen 2004), and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (Guo et al Reference Guo, Jetter and McBrian2004, Lin et al Reference Lin, Chang, Hsieh, Chao and Chao2002) in amounts that were evaluated to pose potential health risks.
The amount of pollution and the substances that are emitted from burning of incense was examined in laboratory tests. A large variation of emissions between incense sticks was observed. The aerosols consisted of a mixture of organic and inorganic materials such as volatile organic compounds (VOC), resins, ashes, soot, etc. Some of these VOCs are classified as hazardous if inhaled (e.g. acrolein), possibly carcinogenic (e.g. formaldehyde) to carcinogenic (benzene). The study concluded that the burning of incense may cause a significant increase in indoor air pollution when the incense is burned indoors and health risks to the consumer from the use of incense cannot be excluded (Eggert and Hansen, 2004).
Health Effects of Incense Emissions
Consumers are not aware that incense can increase indoor pollution in poorly ventilated space. The main route of exposure is inhalation and exposure to skin. Exposure to incense smoke contributes to various acute and chronic health problems. Several studies have shown that incense smoke contains substances that are established irritants to the nose, throat, skin, eyes and harmful to health, more so in sensitive parts of the population like children. Cough symptoms in children have been reported (Yang et al, Reference Yang, Chiu, Cheng and Lin1997).
Complaints of immediate acute effects like irritation to the eyes, nose and throat or dizziness have been reported (Ho et al, Reference Ho, Tseng and Yang2005). Long-term exposure leading to contact dermatitis, itchy depigmentation (Hayakawa et al Reference Hayakawa, Matsunaga and Arima1987a and Reference Hayakawa, Matsunaga and Arima1987b), asthma or other more serious health risks such as leukaemia have also been reported (Löwengart et al. 1987). The inhalation of fine particles (<2.5 μm d) is of concern as they can penetrate deeply into the alveoli causing damage to the lungs. Inhalation can result in respiratory symptoms and lung dysfunction.
The Carbon Monoxide (CO) generated combines with haemoglobin more readily than with oxygen, reducing the blood's capacity to transport oxygen. Exposure to low concentrations of CO can cause dizziness, nausea, headaches, while high concentrations are fatal. Experiments have shown that burning as few as 2 joss sticks in a well-sealed room would breach the WHO-1-hour guideline levels for CO levels within an hour (Croxford and Kynigou, 2005). The volatile compounds emitted may reach uncovered skin and cause contact dermatitis (Roveri et al. Reference Roveri, Andrisano, Di Pietra and Cavrini1998). Allergens recognised and regulated by EU Directive 2003/15/EC (EU 2003) have been identified in some incenses. In the EU member states, incense products are rejected for import if they pose a chemical risk due to detection of values of benzene, toluene or similar substances after combustion, considered harmful to health on grounds that the product is intended for use in closed environments and not to be dispersed by ventilation.
Moreover, the depositing of a thin layer of soot can be expected in places where incense is burned, if airing or ventilation is not efficient and such a case has been reported in a church in Switzerland (Huynh et al. Reference Huynh, Savolainen, Vu-Duc, Guillemin and Iselin1991).
Fragrance of Incense
An ancient Indian fable about a king who wanted to choose the wisest of his three sons to be crowned as his successor, beautifully illustrates this point. The king challenged his sons to fill up their rooms by the following day, using three gold coins to purchase something for this purpose. The first worked diligently and filled his room with straw, the second with soil and stones, but the third relaxed. The next day the king was disappointed with the mess created by the two sons, but as he approached the room of the third son, a wonderful and delicate fragrance welcomed him. The son had burnt a single incense stick and not only was the room filled with aroma, so was the surrounding environment. The king was delighted with his son's thinking and was convinced he had found his wise successor.
Human beings have a sensitive organ for the sensory perception of aromas. Aroma or smell is a major contributor to this sensory perception. Most incense has a low sensory threshold, implying that it can impact the aroma in low concentrations. What most people do not realise however, is that a high concentration of aroma volatiles can blunt the senses to lead to an undesirable sensory impact and health effects in sensitive individuals.
Recommendation for Exposure Reduction:
During the burning of incense, a few simple precautionary measures can go a long way to protect the consumer. Proper ventilation is essential to reduce the exposure to incense smoke toxicants, without sacrificing the pleasure and beneficial effects of the fragrances as the risk is proportional to the level of exposure.
The importance of ventilation during and after the use of incense must be emphasised to the consumers so that the smoke can be removed and the incense can be used as safely as possible (Lin et al Reference Lin, Krishnaswamy and Chi2008; Danish report). This information should be mandatory on incense packages.
Burning of copious amounts of incense or joss sticks as currently practised should be discontinued, as small amounts can effectively aromatise large areas. This important precaution should also be taken in large places of worship where large-scale burning of incense occurs in comparatively poorly ventilated space. This is also a health risk for the workers in such places as they are exposed for longer periods.
Thus, continuous burning of incense especially in closed areas should be avoided. Especially direct inhalation of incense smoke can result in very high exposure to toxic components.
In conclusion, incense burning is a significant source of indoor air pollution and several constituents are toxic and can result in acute as well as in serious health risks. Therefore, exposure should be minimised by good ventilation and one should limit the number of units burned by using only one at a time. The desired fragrance will still be perceptible to the olfactory system. These simple precautions are an effective way to avoid ill effects, but still enjoy the offerings.
