The topic of Islam and the new Islamic movements in Turkey has been studied quite extensively in the last decade, and the complexity and the diversity of these Islamic movements are very interesting and revealing. The concept of a “Turkish Islam” has recently been articulated as ideology to emphasize the exceptional experience of secular Turkey or to promote the Turkish experience as a model for the Middle East. The lack of comparative framework in the field has unfortunately contributed immensely to the trap of assuming the existence of an absolute Turkish exceptionalism.
Yavuz and Esposito's book contributes to the growing literature on Islamic movements in modern Turkey. The main thesis is that nationalism and secularism did not bring peace and stability to Turkey. The book claims that laicism “has very little moral power to guide political action” (p. xxii). Therefore, it is necessary to balance Islamic values with the Kemalist political system, and the Gülen movement offers a solution (p. 47). Gülen represents a modern, middle way of Turkish Islam (pp. 115–30), which is moderate, tolerant toward other faiths, and affirms science (p. 21). John Voll claims that at the end of the 20th century, the great conflict was between “different visions of [a] globalized future, viewed in terms of more traditional modern secularism, in terms of globalized rigid fundamentalisms, or in terms of multicultural, pluralist, interconnected societies” (p. 247). Viewed in this way, Gülen represents “a force in the development of the Islamic discourse of globalized multicultural pluralism” (p. Although).
247 the book's structure is somewhat awkward, it can be examined in three layers. The first layer, which consists of four articles (Yavuz, Yavuz, Aktay, and Kosebalaban), concentrates on Fetullah Gülen and the importance of his movement in the Turkish sociopolitical context. In the second layer, the Gülen interpretation of Islam is discussed from a religious perspective (Kuru, Sarıtoprak, and Yılmaz). In the third layer, educational institutions in Central Asia, the Balkans, and Turkey are examined (Agai, Michel, Ozdalga, and Turam).
It is clear that Gülen followed the path of Said Nursi as a religious scholar and took his organizational skills as an example for his movement (p. 19). From a religious point of view, as Yılmaz indicates, his discourse is not unique, but his ability to put these ideas into practice is (p. 237). Following the footsteps of Said Nursi, Gülen's main aim has been to raise a new generation educated in both Islamic morals and science. Islam is interpreted as a tolerant religion, and the group has made efforts to create channels to meet with secular intellectuals in Turkey and religious leaders inside and outside Turkey. On the other hand, Gülen interprets Islam in a very nationalistic way, leading to an interest in Central Asia and close cooperation with right-wing political parties, along with the 1980s military government.
Gülen sees education as a medium to create a “modern Muslim” and a capable community able to change society (pp. 52–53). With highly idealistic ideas (pp. 67–84), the aim of the Gülen institutions is to “create scientifically competitive future generations who also will be faithful believers” (p. 188). The two articles concerning the schools of the movement offer a strong understanding of these institutions' role outside Turkey (Agai on Albania and Turam on Kazakhstan). Both articles emphasize the importance of teachers and business people who operate these institutions in different countries. Based on rich ethnographic data, Turam discusses the strong association of Islam with the Turkish nation and reveals how this loyalty strengthens the Gülen movement's organizational capacity to cooperate with the Turkish and the Kazakh state. Agai and Turam also discuss the duty-oriented, self-sacrificing values among followers. Ozdalga's article provides the gender dimension of Gülen schools in Turkey. Based on three female teachers' life stories, she discusses individual self-reflexivity, autonomy, and initiative.
Gülen is often described as a man of practice. It is certainly clear that the Gülen movement has a wide network of followers even though not all of them are equal at the organizational level. These networks are important because they form social capital for the followers, and at the same time they materially operate educational institutions in Turkey, the Balkans, and Central Asia. Although the book clearly shows the importance of the movement inside and outside Turkey and its capacity to form networks with its distinctive “Islamic values,” it lacks an analysis of the movement's organizational structure and the substance of these networks. One can argue that the Gülen movement is based on “loose networks.” These networks cannot solely be glorified if the “dark side” of these networks in the Bourdieuan sense is considered.
There is also a definite hierarchical organizational structure in the movement. Close associates of Gülen stand at the top and are greatly respected for their positions. Although Ozdalga mentions that she witnessed strong hierarchical relations among male members and gender hierarchy in the movement, unfortunately this book will not provide readers with a clear grasp of the movement's inner organizational structure. Gülen's interpretation of Islam couples support for global religious dialogue and free markets with expressions of Turkish nationalism and an ideology of duty to the state. It is important to evaluate how these ideas are materialized not only within his discourse and activities, but also within the inner structure of the movement.
As there are a very limited number of studies on the Gülen movement, this book, despite some shortcomings, would be very useful to researchers, especially those performing in-depth analyses on Turkish Islam.
