
Professor Femi Oyebode’s work on psychopathology and the medical humanities is well established, and I eagerly anticipated his new book. I was not disappointed. Doppelgänger is a wide-ranging examination of the double across different eras and cultures, spanning Greek tragedies to clinical neuroscience.
The author quotes Paul Meehan on the self: ‘It’s you but it’s not you’. We are constantly reminded throughout the book about the ominous condition of human nature, a shadow contrasting with an awakened other. Walt Whitman rightly emphasises, in the opening poem of the antiquity chapter, that we contain multitudes. Playwrights, who were perhaps some of our earliest psychologists, drew on these multitudes to mirror the issues of their times: war, gender roles, entertainment and relationships. While the outer world is reflected within and vice versa, it was inevitable that writers tried to explore the complexity of the human soul by using the double as a tool.
The classic literary examples, ranging from Poe to Dostoyevsky and Saramago, portray the experience of meeting our double. This experience can involve the feeling of uncanny resemblance or otherness, but the encounter is nonetheless imbued with frantic unease. Conflicting emotions, paradoxical thoughts and disturbed mental states are projected onto the double to render them more bearable. In this context, I would like to mention two other books that embody the double motif: The Notebook Trilogy by Ágota Kristóf and Narcissus and Goldmund by Herman Hesse.
Cinematography-wise, we are introduced into the Hitchcockian world of double motifs. Cinema becomes a realm where the portrayal of forbidden fantasies is a way of experiencing impossible, real-life desires. Mention should be made of Woody Allen’s satirical mockumentary Zelig – a masterpiece of the cinematic doppelgänger.
Oyebode refers to Melzack’s concept of a ‘neuromatrix’, which is defined as being integrated, dynamic and fluid. It reminded me of the ‘dynamic matrix’ in group analytic theory. The unconscious web of communications and relationships within a group can be incorporated into the self, as an infinite network of multiples, permanently relating to one another, entangled in a light-and-shadows game.
The book matches clinical cases with fictional ones, but it goes beyond this and resists oversimplification. It configures and deconstructs the self and, despite Oyebode’s warning that it is not a ‘philosophical treatise’, I would contend it is an existential exercise in imagination, culture and the complexity of the human nature.

eLetters
No eLetters have been published for this article.