In this recent monograph, Harald Jørgensen addresses two questions:
What does research tell us about institutions of higher music education?
How can research be utilised in the quality improvement process? (p. 11)
Jørgensen has been a teacher and researcher at the Norwegian Academy of Music for nearly 40 years, and was its Rector from 1983 to 1989, and again from 2002 to 2006. He knows his readership well: leaders, quality managers, administrators; teachers of performance, composition and pedagogy, etc.; researchers; students. The term ‘institutions of higher music education’ is perhaps used more widely in Europe than the UK; here it refers to conservatoires and university music schools and departments, but not institutions catering for general education or non-music majors, nor those specialising only in musicology.
The purpose of the book is to provide an overview of research that Jørgensen describes as in and about, and outside and for institutions. This excludes topics – such as musicology – that are relevant to the experience of higher music education but not directly related to its delivery. In the introductory chapter, Jørgensen proposes a pyramid-shaped model in which the four cornerstones of the base are represented by Chapter 2 (the core characteristics of institutions), Chapter 3 (resources), Chapter 4 (processes) and Chapter 5 (relationships with external sectors). The apex of the pyramid is represented by Chapter 6, on outcomes, and in the concluding chapter Jørgensen reflects on the nature of quality and the role of research in effecting change.
While Jørgensen argues that higher music education is a relatively under-researched topic, expressing astonishment that so few researchers in higher music institutions have investigated research questions arising from their own work, the great strength of this book is in fact the wide range of literature surveyed. It is a goldmine of a resource for students and others who wish to read further; indeed the list of references constitutes nearly a quarter of the book. The same plan is used for each chapter. Jørgensen provides a rationale for the choice of topics covered, then summarises the research relating to each topic (including doctoral dissertations as well as peer-reviewed publications), and comments on its implications for practice, questions arising and – providing another valuable resource for students and investigators – potential avenues for future exploration.
During the course of Chapter 2, for example, Jørgensen argues that institutional histories are worth comparing, so as to illuminate issues that are important for individual institutions. One such is the educational philosophy that underlies the institution's mission statement and therefore has implications for change. Another is the difficulty of reconciling institutional goals and those of individuals. In his view, however, the most serious omissions in research to date are the investigation of institutional organisation and culture, without which it is impossible to formulate informed institutional policies for improvement.
Chapter 3 surveys research on educational, human, musical and material resources. Educational resources include programmes, subjects and disciplines. Human resources include students and staff, teaching and administrative. Issues include threats to student health and wellbeing, the recruitment and working conditions of staff, and the concerns of administrators and leaders. Jørgensen concludes that there is no research on finances, almost none on material resources such as housing standards and facilities, and very little on the kind of music that is taught and studied within higher music institutions.
Jørgensen is best known by his colleagues in music education and performance research for his highly influential work on teaching, learning and practising. It is not surprising, therefore, that Chapter 4, the book's central – and by far the longest – chapter, should be devoted to processes within the institution. Its three main themes relate to students and student learning, staff teaching and research, and leadership and management. First, recruitment and the extent to which entrance examinations predict subsequent success are considered, and the research on student learning including motivation, learning style and development, and practising strategies is summarised. Second, Jørgensen outlines research on the teaching of different subjects in different contexts, and highlights the dearth of research on the multiple roles that are often fulfilled by those who teach, perform, compose and undertake research. There have been many investigations, however, of student assessment, and these are listed and described. Finally, Jørgensen addresses issues relating to leadership: the need to monitor institutional quality and change, the nature of social interaction in institutions, and the ways in which staff and students participate in decision making.
In Chapter 5 Jørgensen moves from the overview of research carried out in and about institutions to research outside and for them. Here he asks:
To what degree are our institutions reactive and to what degree are they proactive towards external relations? Is there a willingness and ability to change in relation to external developments? (p. 158)
There is a body of research on relationships with pre-college music institutions and other higher education institutions, and with the music professions and the job market, former students and cultural life more generally. On the other hand, Jørgensen has identified only two European studies looking at the relationship between higher music institutions and the political and economic sector. At the time of writing, it must be acknowledged that this relationship is hugely salient to music researchers and research leaders in England and Wales, as we consult with the Higher Education Funding Council of England in preparation for the next Research Excellence Framework (REF); I wonder if one or more of us have time to design an appropriate study that could perhaps have a useful impact on this relationship?
Research on outcomes, hidden and intended, is the topic of Chapter 6. This is the briefest of the seven chapters, since while we have evidence of graduates' views on their educational experiences there is little or no in-depth research on either broader outcomes for the individual, or ‘the contributions of our institutions [author's italics] to society’ (p. 180). The model that has been used in the past – particularly as a way of allocating funding – is reminiscent of the behaviourist ‘black box’ model in which the inputs are educational, including financial and material resources, student background etc., the black box (in which the inputs are processed invisibly) is the institution, with its curriculum and teaching quality, and the outputs are measurable student achievements (e.g. Ballantine, Reference BALLANTINE1997). Jørgensen is critical of this model, arguing instead for the pyramid model introduced in Chapter 1, which illustrates dynamic inter-relationships between the four cornerstones and apex.
Jørgensen opens his concluding chapter with a discussion of the meaning of ‘quality’, with reference first to Robert Pirsig (Reference PIRSIG1974) and then Harvey and Green's (Reference HARVEY and GREEN1993) definitions in terms of exceptionality, perfection/consistency, fitness for purpose, value for money and transformation. He ends with a rallying call: we in higher music education are those who should be carrying out this research, not relying on others to do so, although we should be collaborating with them. We should be setting up our own departments for institutional research, and research should inform our agenda for change.
To reiterate, this book has the potential to be a wonderful resource for leaders, staff and students in higher music institutions. It needs, however, to reach its audience, and its readers need to be active in reading the research that Jørgensen has identified, and following it up. They will then discover what Jørgensen himself acknowledges as the major weakness I perceive: many of the studies he mentions – though by no means all – are ‘micro-’ studies often involving only very small numbers of participants at a single institution, addressing a particular issue typical only of that institution. They provide starting points, nevertheless, for more ambitious studies, and for researchers to gather converging evidence as the basis for new, testable theories.
I have to admit that I am not entirely convinced by Jørgensen's pyramid model. He claims at the outset that it is not only a ‘metaphor [pointing] to the interactive nature of institutional life’ (p. 16) but also a
framework for research. It allows researchers to address questions from different theoretical perspectives, on both the macro and micro levels, and to use all relevant research designs and method. (ibid.)
Interaction is dynamic, while pyramids seem to me to be rather solid structures; also, I think there are good reasons for individual researchers and groups of researchers to take one theoretical perspective at a time, and let their questions determine their methods. He goes on to say, however, that the ‘primary function’ of the model is ‘to help me organise the basic question of the book: What does research tell us about institutions of higher music education?’ (pp. 16–17), and I agree that the structure of his argument is admirably clear.
All in all, then, this is a book to recommend. I hope it will be read by leaders and senior managers, so that institutional changes and improvements may be informed by evidence from research. I hope it will be read by staff – teachers in all disciplines, performers and composers – not only to inform them about themselves and their students, but also to inspire their own research. I hope it will be read by researchers, as a basis for future studies, and above all I hope it will be read by students who will themselves one day be teachers and leaders in higher music education.
