Whilst the gulf between internationalist theory and praxis has long bedevilled organized labour and the left, a comparable problematic has only lately emerged in American historical writing. With the exception of several important and notable works, in the last decade rather more effort has gone into theorizing the “transnational turn” in US historiography than into actually practising its methodologies. The product of a 2008 conference at the Newberry Library in Chicago, Workers across the Americas presents the efforts of a group of labour historians seeking to redress this imbalance. The book opens with a series of short methodological reflections from established scholars on the importance of transnational labour history, several of which attempt to explain why historians have recently come to adopt approaches that deemphasize or complicate the centrality of the nation-state. Essays by John D. French and Vic Satzewich, for example, highlight how waves of migration during the 1980s and 1990s, as well as the rapidly developing sense of the importance of globalization, drew US labour historians to the realization that, in Benedict Anderson's phrase, the nation-state is no more than an “imagined community” whose boundaries are constantly brought into question by the experiences of workers and migrants. At the same time, however, the essays in this section demonstrate that whilst its intellectual underpinnings may be attractive precisely because they speak to contemporary political and social concerns, there is “nothing historically unprecedented about present-day transnationalism” (44), and that its insights are consequently applicable across a broad sweep of pan-American history.
This observation is borne out by the main bulk of Workers across the Americas. Six thematic sections contain extended versions of fourteen of the papers given in Chicago, which range widely in scope, both geographically, from Guatemala and Canada to the United Kingdom and Australasia, and temporally, from the Seven Years War (1756–63) to the United Nations International Women's Year Conference (1975). Outstanding contributions include a chapter by Eileen Boris on maternity leave and US exceptionalism, and Steven J. Bachelor's analysis of the effects on Mexican workers of developmental conceptions of what constituted an “American way of life.” However, the collection's most significant essays are contained in its final two sections, which deal with transnational labour politics and internationalism. For example, Shelton Stromquist's bravura chapter on workers' engagement with the politics of urban space and municipal socialism in regions as diverse as Christchurch, New South Wales, Manchester and the American Mid-west is methodologically and conceptually akin to (but by no means derivative of) Daniel Rodgers's pioneering Atlantic Crossings (1998), whilst Jeffrey R. Kerr-Ritchie's excellent cross-national analysis of attempts by fugitive slaves to find “pathways to freedom” provides a much-expanded context for discussions of labour internationalism in the nineteenth century (364). Ultimately, then, Workers across the Americas presents its reader with a set of clear, theoretically aware and perceptive essays that succeed in placing the “labour question” front and centre in contemporary debates in US historiography. In doing so, the book approaches both the theory and the practice of transnational history with great aplomb.
