Joseph Horowitz has been casting new light on America's so-called Gilded Age for years, a project that, simultaneously, has cast doubt on the term's implication that the United States was culturally empty in the closing decades of the nineteenth century and the beginning of the twentieth. In both Wagner Nights: An American History and Classical Music in America: A History of Its Rise and Fall, he suggested that the label “fin de siècle” aptly captures the complex cultural forces at work in the United States at the turn of the twentieth century.Footnote 1 As Horowitz wrote in Wagner Nights of that phase in New York's history, “The city's new cultural landmarks—museums, libraries, opera houses, orchestras”—were not “monuments to evasion and complacency, or a ploy to mesmerize and subdue the masses.”Footnote 2 Rather, he argued, they participated in a broader, morally charged activist project.
In Moral Fire, Horowitz intensifies his reevaluation of the “fin de siècle” label. He does so by reintroducing readers to four significant figures, all of whom flourished in distinct musical spheres but whose work, taken together, shaped U.S. culture in the Gilded Age: Henry Lee Higginson, the businessman and Civil War veteran who founded the Boston Symphony Orchestra and created Boston's Symphony Hall; Henry Krehbiel, the New York critic who elucidated the social potential of high art; Laura Langford, the writer and activist who brought the conductor Anton Seidl and his Wagner interpretations to Coney Island in Brooklyn; and Charles Ives, a defining voice in twentieth-century music.
Although these figures surface in Wagner Nights and Classical Music in America, books that supply some of the basic outlines of the narratives in Moral Fire, Horowitz's latest book allows these individuals to shine. As he argues convincingly in Moral Fire's Prologue and Summation, all of these figures shared both a belief that high culture could empower rather than shackle the masses and a sense of disaffection with new, twentieth-century trends. As Horowitz explains, the term fin de siècle “typically refers to a dynamic moment in Old World culture, a fulcrum moment, circa 1880 to 1914, dialectically charged, tugged backward and forward, a moment of closure and of anticipatory excitement. Evoking a vibrant coda, it is freighted with decadence: escapism, aestheticism, ennui; evoking a new beginning, it connotes revolt” (11). Horowitz acknowledges, however, that the U.S. fin de siècle was not equivalent to Europe’s. Although the U.S. fin de siècle did see “an intense high culture in vigorous transition,” he adds, “New World tensions… reflected the growing pains of a young culture. Far from evading the genteel tradition, a Krehbiel or Ives elasticized or challenged its sanguine precepts from within” (12).
Horowitz's protagonists justify his reframing of the Gilded Age as a fin de siècle. We learn that Higginson, exhibiting early in his career a sense of social consciousness, bought a plantation in Georgia after the Civil War and employed blacks in that region. Soon afterward, in 1881, as a successful businessman in Boston, he founded the Boston Symphony Orchestra—an endeavor that Horowitz argues was closely tied to Higginson's “democratic impulse” (37). Far from being an institution for the Boston elites, he suggests, the BSO was a civic exercise; cheap tickets were the norm, and the new Symphony Hall, which opened in 1900, was meant to sound sublime and to welcome the masses. But Higginson's undoing came at the end of World War I in 1918, this time in the aftermath of his own resistance, and that of his German conductor Karl Muck, to having the orchestra perform “The Star-Spangled Banner.” Through this episode, Horowitz shows Higginson emerging as a fin-de-siècle figure—one for whom old views about the autonomy of music, grounded in his worship of Beethoven, met the realities of twentieth-century politics head on.
Horowitz similarly reveals Henry Krehbiel to have believed in the power of German art music to buoy up a society. Krehbiel is shown to have treated his role at the New York Tribune as an opportunity to encourage Americans to engage seriously with serious music. It is in this role as critic where one of Krehbiel's most intriguing contradictions, as Horowitz defines it, resides. On the one hand, Horowitz notes that Krehbiel's “eagerness to educate new listeners is egalitarian, democratic, American.” On the other hand, as Horowitz demonstrates with extensive quotations from Krehbiel's writings, “what chiefly shades Krehbiel's teachings with an Old Worldly gravitas is his mistrust of the very vox populi he labors to edify” (104). In the end, what marked Krehbiel as a fin-de-siècle figure was that, despite his commitment to art as a vehicle for social improvement, he “retained a barnacled scholarly mien out of touch with the streamlined aesthetic fashions of a new century” (123).
Laura Langford emerges in Moral Fire as “one of the most astonishing operatives in the history of American classical music” (150), and her portrait in Horowitz's study underscores the crucial role women played in fin-de-siècle U.S. musical life. Langford's passion for charity work and her pathbreaking efforts to build a broad-based musical community upon a shared appreciation for Wagner's music—efforts that had included convincing the Brighton Beach Railroad to add cars for women and children to attend concerts of the Seidl Society—were cut short quite abruptly before the turn of the century, with the destruction of Brighton's Music Hall in 1896 and Seidl's own death in 1897 (“Two calamities doomed everything,” Horowitz writes [158]). Horowitz's account of Langford's tense and ultimately fruitless partnership with the Shakers to build a sanitarium in the first decade of the new century strongly suggests her own fin-de-siècle struggle to face changing times.
Turning to Ives, Horowitz reframes the controversial composer as a turn-of-the-century figure rather than a twentieth-century one. He characterizes Ives as generous and deeply committed to democratic ideals—qualities that he argues permeated Ives's life and music.Footnote 3 In this exploration, Ives's career in the life insurance business was not simply about making money; it was about serving humanity. Suggesting that his music and career went hand-in-hand, Horowitz argues in a lengthy and enlightening discussion of the Concord Sonata that the work reveals Ives as “an apotheosis of the life insurance salesman: meliorist, democratic, embracing the ‘average’ and quotidian even while striving toward philosophic climes” (192). Horowitz describes Ives’ fin-de-siècle stature best with his animated observation that the composer “ultimately withdrew from the twentieth century with an eccentric tenacity that calibrated the existential abyss into which he would otherwise have plunged” (218).
By situating Higginson, Krehbiel, Langford, and Ives as part of a U.S. fin de siècle, Horowitz provides in Moral Fire a timely refiguring of these subjects while also inserting music into a broader historical re-envisioning of this period. As he notes in the Prologue, recent years have seen renewed attention devoted to Gilded Age figures like Henry Ward Beecher, William Jennings Bryan, Thomas Wentworth Higginson, and Theodore Roosevelt, revealing each as a complex, idealistic individual driven by a sense of moral responsibility toward humankind.Footnote 4 The parallels Horowitz finds between these and his own fin-de-siècle musical luminaries (or activists)—for instance, between Bryan and Ives each as figures “inflamed within the confines of his special calling” (211) are indeed striking.
If his four portraits justify a renewed look at the Gilded Age, his provocative comparison of that period to our own—as part of the justification for a renewed look at the Gilded Age—invites scrutiny. Contrasting the late nineteenth century with today's cultural atmosphere, he writes, “I find that the relative easiness or moral complacency of present-day lives set off the prodigious individual energies and achievements of my fin-de-siècle subjects” (15). Horowitz asserts that thinkers in the interwar United States characterized the Gilded Age as insidiously vacuous and that, in doing so, they “cast a shadow on the past in order to brighten the present” (xii). But perhaps Horowitz casts too dark a shadow on his own present when he writes that today's youth “avidly specialize in vicarious forms of electronic interpersonal diversion. Our laptops and televisions ensnare us in a surrogate world that shuns all but facile passions” (6). The Occupy movement, renewed pushes for civil rights, and, specifically in the realm of art music, the flowering of El Sistema–inspired activities in the United States all point to a brand of activism that has been aided, not hindered, by new technologies. Far from diminishing today's ethical environment, Horowitz's study of the Gilded Age makes one hope that, in 2114, historians will look back at the turn of the twenty-first century and find that we have kindled a moral fire of our own.
