Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T06:29:50.027Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Near-wall numerical coherent structures and turbulence generation in wall-modelled large-eddy simulation

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 August 2023

Hirotaka Maeyama*
Affiliation:
Department of Aerospace Engineering, Tohoku University, 6-6-01, Aramaki-aza-Aoba, Aoba-ku, Sendai, Japan
Soshi Kawai
Affiliation:
Department of Aerospace Engineering, Tohoku University, 6-6-01, Aramaki-aza-Aoba, Aoba-ku, Sendai, Japan
*
†Email address for correspondence: hirotaka.maeyama.b5@tohoku.ac.jp

Abstract

Near-wall turbulence structures and generation in the wall-modelled large-eddy simulation (WMLES) are revealed. To elucidate the turbulence structures driving a near-wall turbulence generation in the WMLES, flat-plate turbulent boundary-layer flows calculated by the WMLES and direct numerical simulation (DNS) are closely investigated. A conditional-averaging technique is applied to the instantaneous flow fields and the near-wall statistical structures of the ejection and sweep pairs, which produce the turbulence, are revealed to exist even in the WMLES although the structures are non-physically elongated compared with those obtained by the DNS. Since the near-wall turbulence structures in the WMLES are revealed not to be disordered, but to be coherent structures with low- and high-speed fluids alternating in the spanwise direction, it is suggested that the near-wall turbulence generation in the WMLES is explained by the numerically elongated coherent structures. Furthermore, the Reynolds number effects of wall-bounded turbulent flows, i.e. the appearance of the outer peak in the energy spectrum of the streamwise velocity fluctuations at increasing Reynolds numbers, is found not to be reproduced by the WMLES, and the origin of the outer peak is discussed in association with the inner–outer-layer interactions. The near-wall turbulence structures in the WMLES could depend heavily on the computational grids and the numerical methods. Therefore, additional cases varying the grid resolutions and the numerical methods (numerical schemes and sub-grid-scale models) are also conducted to confirm the consistency of the present conclusions.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic of the WMLES.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Schematic of the zero-pressure-gradient flat-plate turbulent boundary layer flow. The near-wall vortical structures are visualized by the Q-criterion coloured with instantaneous streamwise velocity normalized by the sound speed of the uniform flow $u/a_\infty$. The cross-sectional plane shows the instantaneous streamwise velocity.

Figure 2

Figure 3.The evolutions of the skin friction coefficient $C_f$ in terms of the momentum thickness-based Reynolds number $Re_\theta$. Red, $Re_\tau \approx 700$; green, $Re_\tau \approx 1250$; blue, $Re_\tau \approx 2300$. Circles, DNS; lines, WMLES.

Figure 3

Table 1.Grid properties for the present DNS and the WMLES. The statistics are obtained at $x=30\delta _0$ downstream from the inlet: $Re_\tau$, friction-based Reynolds number; $Re_\theta$, momentum thickness-based Reynolds number; $N_x,\ N_y,\ N_z$, numbers of computational grid points in streamwise, wall-normal and spanwise directions, respectively; $\Delta x^+,\ \Delta y_w^+, \Delta y_\delta ^+,\ \Delta z^+$, grid resolutions in wall units, where $\Delta y_w^+$ is the grid resolution at the first grid point off the wall and $\Delta y_\delta ^+$ is that at the outer edge of the boundary layer; $\delta / \Delta x,\ \delta / \Delta z$, grid resolutions in $\delta$ units; $N_\delta$, number of computational grid points in the wall-normal direction within the boundary-layer thickness $\delta$.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Turbulence statistics obtained by the WMLES and the DNS. (a) Mean streamwise velocity, (b) Reynolds shear stress. Red, $Re_\tau \approx 700$; green, $Re_\tau \approx 1250$; blue, $Re_\tau \approx 2300$. Circles, DNS; lines, WMLES (solid, above the matching location; dash-dotted in (b), below the matching location).

Figure 5

Figure 5.Shear-stress balance at (a) $Re_\tau \approx 700$, (b) $Re_\tau \approx 1250$, (c) $Re_\tau \approx 2300$. Blue, Reynolds shear stress; green, molecular viscous shear stress; red, SGS viscous shear stress (only for WMLES); black, total shear stress. Circles, DNS; lines, WMLES (solid, above the matching location; dash-dotted, below the matching location).

Figure 6

Figure 6.Quadrant analysis of the Reynolds shear stress $-\bar {\rho }\widetilde {u''v''}$ at (a) $Re_\tau \approx 700$, (b) $Re_\tau \approx 1250$, (c) $Re_\tau \approx 2300$. Green, Q1 $(u''>0,v''>0)$; blue, Q2 $(u''<0,v''>0)$, black, Q3 $(u''<0,v''<0)$; red, Q4 $(u''>0, v''<0)$. Circles, DNS; lines, WMLES (solid, above the matching location; dash-dotted, below the matching location).

Figure 7

Figure 7.(a–c) Show TKE budget terms at (a) $Re_\tau \approx 700$, (b) $Re_\tau \approx 1250$ and (c) $Re_\tau \approx 2300$, respectively. Cyan, convection; red, production; black, turbulent diffusion; magenta, velocity–pressure interaction; green, viscous diffusion; blue, energy dissipation. $(d)$ Shows the comparison of the production terms premultiplied by normalized distance $y^+P$. Red, $Re_\tau \approx 700$; green, $Re_\tau \approx 1250$; blue, $Re_\tau \approx 2300$. Circles, DNS; lines, WMLES (solid, above the matching location; dash-dotted, below the matching location).

Figure 8

Figure 8.Instantaneous streamwise velocity fluctuations at the cross-section $x=30\delta _0$; (a) DNS $(Re_\tau \approx 700)$, (b) WMLES $(Re_\tau \approx 700)$, (c) DNS $(Re_\tau \approx 1250)$, (d) WMLES $(Re_\tau \approx 1250)$, (e) DNS $(Re_\tau \approx 2300)$, ( f) WMLES $(Re_\tau \approx 2300)$. The region is $0.8\delta _0$ in the wall-normal ($y$) direction and $2.0\delta _0$ in the spanwise ($z$) direction.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Instantaneous streamwise velocity fluctuations on the wall-parallel plane at $y^+\approx 15$. (a) DNS $(Re_\tau \approx 700)$, (b) WMLES $(Re_\tau \approx 700)$, (c) DNS $(Re_\tau \approx 1250)$, (d) WMLES $(Re_\tau \approx 1250)$, (e) DNS $(Re_\tau \approx 2300)$, ( f) WMLES $(Re_\tau \approx 2300)$. The region is $15.0\delta _0$ ($25.0\delta _0 < x < 40.0\delta _0$) in the streamwise ($x$) direction and $6.0\delta _0$ in the spanwise ($z$) direction.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Premultiplied energy spectra of the streamwise velocity fluctuations at $y^+\approx 15$; (a) wall units, (b) $\delta$ units. Red, $Re_\tau \approx 700$; green, $Re_\tau \approx 1250$; blue, $Re_\tau \approx 2300$. Circles, DNS; lines, WMLES.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Instantaneous streamwise velocity fluctuations for high Reynolds number cases. Cross-section at $x=30\delta _0$, (a) $Re_\tau \approx 4100$, (c) $Re_\tau \approx 7800$, (e) $Re_\tau \approx 14\,000$. Wall-parallel plane at first grid point off the wall, (b) $Re_\tau \approx 4100$, (d) $Re_\tau \approx 7800$, ( f) $Re_\tau \approx 14\,000$. The region is the same as figures 8 and 9, respectively.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Fractional contributions to the total Reynolds shear stress by each quadrant event lying outside the hole as a function of the magnitude filtering parameter $H$ at the height of $y^+\approx 15$. The profiles are calculated from the results at $Re_\tau \approx 2300$; (a) DNS, (b) WMLES. Green, Q1; blue, Q2; black, Q3; red, Q4; grey lines; all quadrant values lying inside the hole. Symbol (cyan open circle), frequency of occurrence of the quadrant event inside the hole.

Figure 13

Figure 13.Schematic of the searching area for the Q2–Q4 pair.

Figure 14

Figure 14.Conditionally averaged streamwise velocity fluctuations of the Q2–Q4 pair on the cross-section ($x=30.0\delta _0$); (a) DNS $(Re_\tau \approx 700)$, (b) WMLES $(Re_\tau \approx 700)$, (c) DNS $(Re_\tau \approx 1250)$, (d) WMLES $(Re_\tau \approx 1250)$, (e) DNS $(Re_\tau \approx 2300)$, ( f) WMLES $(Re_\tau \approx 2300)$. The computational grid is superimposed in the results of the WMLES. The region is $0.32\delta _0$ in the wall-normal ($y$) direction and $0.6\delta _0$ in the spanwise ($z$) direction.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Conditionally averaged near-wall three-dimensional turbulence structures of the Q2–Q4 pair. Blue iso-surface, Q2 (low-speed streaks); red iso-surface, Q4 (high-speed streaks). The iso-surfaces are defined at $\widehat {u''}/\overline {u_\tau }=-1.5$ for Q2, and $\widehat {u''}/\overline {u_\tau }=1.5$ for Q4. (a) DNS ($Re_\tau \approx 700$), (b) WMLES ($Re_\tau \approx 700$), (c) DNS ($Re_\tau \approx 1250$), (d) WMLES ($Re_\tau \approx 1250$), (e) DNS ($Re_\tau \approx 2300$), ( f) WMLES ($Re_\tau \approx 2300$). The grid spacing shown at the wall is 0.05$\delta _0$ in both the streamwise ($x$) and spanwise ($z$) directions.

Figure 16

Figure 16.Cross-section streamlines computed from $(\hat {v},\hat {w})$ at $x=30.0\delta _0$ superimposed on the conditionally averaged streamwise velocity fluctuations obtained by the WMLES at $Re_\tau \approx 2300$ (same as figure 14f).

Figure 17

Figure 17.The spanwise length scale of the near-wall turbulence structures in the WMLES. (a) spanwise correlation of the streamwise velocity fluctuations. Red, $Re_\tau \approx 700$; green, $Re_\tau \approx 1250$; blue, $Re_\tau \approx 2300$, magenta, $Re_\tau \approx 4100$; cyan, $Re_\tau \approx 7800$; black, $Re_\tau \approx 14\,000$. (b) The spanwise length scale of the near-wall turbulence structures non-dimensionalized with three different viscous length scales. Red, wall-unit scaling; green, semi-local scaling (Coleman et al.1995); blue, semi-local scaling including SGS eddy viscosity.

Figure 18

Figure 18.Reynolds normal stresses obtained by the WMLES and the DNS; (a) wall unit, (b) $\delta$ unit. From upper to lower, streamwise $\bar {\rho } \widetilde {u''u''}$, spanwise $\bar {\rho } \widetilde {w''w''}$ and wall-normal $\bar {\rho } \widetilde {v''v''}$ components, respectively. Red, $Re_\tau \approx 700$; green, $Re_\tau \approx 1250$; blue, $Re_\tau \approx 2300$. Circles, DNS; lines, WMLES (solid, above the matching location; dash-dotted, below the matching location).

Figure 19

Figure 19.Premultiplied spanwise energy spectra of streamwise velocity fluctuations $k_z \varPhi _{u''u''}$; (a) DNS $(Re_\tau \approx 700)$, (b) WMLES $(Re_\tau \approx 700)$, (c) DNS $(Re_\tau \approx 1250)$, (d) WMLES $(Re_\tau \approx 1250)$, (e) DNS $(Re_\tau \approx 2300)$, ( f) WMLES $(Re_\tau \approx 2300)$.

Figure 20

Figure 20.Premultiplied spanwise energy spectra of streamwise velocity fluctuations at $y/\delta \approx 0.15$ in terms of $\lambda _z/\delta$. Red, $Re_\tau \approx 700$; green, $Re_\tau \approx 1250$; blue, $Re_\tau \approx 2300$. Circles, DNS; lines, WMLES.

Figure 21

Figure 21.Instantaneous streamwise velocity fluctuations in the wall-parallel plane at $y/\delta \approx 0.15$; (a) DNS $(Re_\tau \approx 700)$, (b) WMLES $(Re_\tau \approx 700)$, (c) DNS $(Re_\tau \approx 1250)$, (d) WMLES $(Re_\tau \approx 1250)$, (e) DNS $(Re_\tau \approx 2300)$, ( f) WMLES $(Re_\tau \approx 2300)$. The region is $15.0\delta _0$ ($25.0\delta _0 \le x \le 40.0\delta _0$) in the streamwise ($x$) direction and $6.0\delta _0$ in the spanwise ($z$) direction.

Figure 22

Figure 22.Length-scale decomposition of the streamwise velocity fluctuations. (a) All length scales (same as figure 18a), (b) only small length scales ($\lambda _z/\delta \leq 0.7$), (c) only large length scales ($\lambda _z/\delta >0.7$). Red, $Re_\tau \approx 700$; green, $Re_\tau \approx 1250$; blue, $Re_\tau \approx 2300$. Circles, DNS; lines, WMLES (solid, above the matching location; dash-dotted, below the matching location).

Figure 23

Figure 23.Comparisons of turbulence statistics between the present DNS and the open database (Schlatter & Örlü 2010). (a) Mean streamwise velocity, (b) Reynolds stresses. Red, $Re_\tau \approx 700$; green, $Re_\tau \approx 1250$. Circles, Schlatter & Örlü (2010); lines, present.

Figure 24

Figure 24.Comparisons of the TKE budget between the present DNS and the open database (Schlatter & Örlü 2010); (a) $Re_\tau \approx 700$, (b) $Re_\tau \approx 1250$. Cyan, convection; red, production; black, turbulent diffusion; magenta, velocity–pressure interaction; green, viscous diffusion; blue, energy dissipation. Circles, Schlatter & Örlü (2010); lines, present.

Figure 25

Figure 25.Conditionally averaged streamwise velocity fluctuations of the Q2–Q4 pair on the cross-section ($x=30.0\delta _0$) and the iso-surface of the three-dimensional structures; (a) $Re_\tau \approx 4100$ (cross-section), (b) $Re_\tau \approx 4100$ (iso-surface), (c) $Re_\tau \approx 7800$ (cross-section), (d) $Re_\tau \approx 7800$ (iso-surface), (e) $Re_\tau \approx 14\,000$ (cross-section), ( f) $Re_\tau \approx 14\,000$ (iso-surface). Colour contour and the imposed grid are the same as figures 14 (cross-section) and 15 (iso-surface).

Figure 26

Figure 26.Premultiplied spanwise energy spectra of streamwise velocity fluctuations $k_z \varPhi _{u''u''}$ of the WMLES at higher Reynolds numbers; (a) $Re_\tau \approx 4100$, (b) $Re_\tau \approx 7800$, (c) $Re_\tau \approx 14\,000$. Colour contour is the same as that of figure 19.

Figure 27

Table 2.The nomenclatures are the same as those of table 1.

Figure 28

Figure 27.Conditionally averaged streamwise velocity fluctuations of the Q2–Q4 pair on the cross-section ($x=30.0\delta _0$) and the iso-surface of the three-dimensional structures. (a) Coarse (wall parallel, cross-section), (b) coarse (wall parallel, iso-surface), (c) fine (wall parallel, cross-section), (d) fine (wall parallel, iso-surface), (e) coarse (wall normal, cross-section), ( f) coarse (wall normal, iso-surface). The colour contour and the definition of the iso-surfaces are the same as figures 14 (cross-section) and 15 (iso-surface).

Figure 29

Figure 28.The spanwise length scale of the near-wall turbulence structures non-dimensionalized with three different viscous length scales when varying the wall-parallel grid resolutions. The symbols are the same as figure 17(b).

Figure 30

Figure 29.Premultiplied spanwise energy spectra of streamwise velocity fluctuations $k_z \varPhi _{u''u''}$. (a) Coarse (wall parallel), (b) fine (wall parallel), (c) coarse (wall normal). The colour contour is the same as that of figure 19.

Figure 31

Figure 30.Length-scale decomposition of the streamwise velocity fluctuations when varying the wall-parallel grid resolutions. (a) All length scales, (b) only small length scales ($\lambda _z/\delta \leq 0.7$), (c) only large length scales ($\lambda _z/\delta >0.7$). Circles, DNS; lines, WMLES (solid, above the matching location; dash-dotted, below the matching location). Red, coarse (wall parallel); green, original; blue, fine (wall-parallel).

Figure 32

Figure 31.Conditionally averaged streamwise velocity fluctuations of the Q2–Q4 pair on the cross-section ($x=30.0\delta _0$) and the iso-surface of the three-dimensional structures. (a) KEEP(+filter)+SMS (cross-section), (b) KEEP(+filter)+SMS (iso-surface), (c) KEEP+SMS (cross-section), (d) KEEP+SMS (iso-surface), (e) compact(+filter)+SMG (cross-section), ( f) compact(+filter)+SMG (iso-surface). The colour contour and the definition of iso-surfaces are the same as figures 14 (cross-section) and 15 (iso-surface).

Figure 33

Figure 32.The spanwise length scale of the near-wall turbulence structures non-dimensionalized with three different viscous length scales. The symbols are the same as figure 17(b).

Figure 34

Figure 33.Premultiplied spanwise energy spectra of streamwise velocity fluctuations $k_z \varPhi _{u''u''}$; (a) KEEP(+filter)+SMS, (b) KEEP+SMS, (c) compact(+filter)+SMG. The colour contour is the same as that of figure 19.

Figure 35

Table 3.The nomenclatures are the same as those of table 1.