Peta Tait is a leading Australian scholar whose work has addressed feminism, culturally situated viewing practices, and the performance of emotions in Chekhov. Her previous book, on aerial performance, provided an important point of reference for those working in the fields of popular entertainment, cultural identity, and body theory. Wild and Dangerous Performances: Animals, Emotions, Circus is Tait's first book to focus on animals.
Though Tait uses the historical shift from menagerie-style display to dynamic circus performances in the late nineteenth century as her starting point and ends with an Internet lion meme, this is not a straightforward social history. Tait draws on archives in Australia, England, and the United States, as well as memoirs, ethnology studies, and the thinking of contemporary animal studies theorists, to integrate the historical facts of several big cat and elephant trainers' careers with philosophical considerations of how emotional exchanges (between animals and trainers, animals and audiences, or among performing animals themselves) are embodied and shape the performance event. Additionally, Tait examines media representations of the circus and human–animal emotional exchange in films (including Born Free, and several from Disney), on the Internet, and at animal parks, arguing that circus acts shape audience expectations for other animal representations and encounters. In turn, the circus changes its performance modes in response to cultural shifts, most notably—in big cat acts—from an emphasis on dominance to the staging of familial relations.
Wild and Dangerous Performances has six chapters, four of which are dedicated to big cats, their trainers, and their representation. Chapter 1, “Calm Patience and Pyramid Poses,” examines the careers of German animal trader and trainer Carl Hagenbeck, British impresario Frank Bostock, Californian circus owner Al G. Barnes, and Barnes's head trainer, Louis Roth. Within this first chapter, the section “Darwinian Emotions” resonates with Jane R. Goodall's scholarship connecting science and performance, and provides ample evidence that society's increased thinking about animal emotions and temperament has affected historical shifts in the display and training of animals.
Tait's second chapter, “The Lion Roars from a Pedestal,” covers the careers of Alfred Court and Clyde Beatty (including Beatty's circus adventure films). Drawing from the work of circus historian Antony Hippisley Coxe, Tait evaluates how docility and ferocity were performed in acts developed by these two men: Beatty's (and other Americans') acts were associated with “noisy ferocity,” whereas “acts of obedient cleverness remained identified with European trainers and with Court” (38). Tait also briefly discusses British impresario Bertram Mills, BMC trainer Alex Kerr, and trainer Captain Alfred Schneider in this chapter, although her stated emphasis on felines forces her to neglect other animal bodies, most notably bears, which have their own physical intensities and cultural associations. Citing animal behaviorists George Schaller and Konrad Lorenz, Tait concludes that “[t]he staging of aggression in the modern circus both encouraged and reflected wider spheres of influence” and that big cats were understood to respond to human vocal and physical cues even while remaining “emotionally volatile” (72).
In the chapter “Dancing Elephants in Skirts,” Tait notes that as the spectacle of elephants' tremendous bodies lost novelty, they were trained to achieve ever more complex formations and tricks; the emotional tone of their acts changed from dignity to frivolity. She argues that elephants became increasingly feminized in the twentieth century, as exemplified by a 1942 elephant ballet choreographed by George Balanchine. These large animals were perceived as dangerous and in need of domination and restraint offstage, but evoked lighthearted and cheerful emotional atmospheres onstage.
Chapter 4, “Leopard around the Neck,” investigates sexualized and exoticized big cat trainers, looking at the careers of Martha Florine, Olga Celeste, Mabel Stark, Patricia Bourne, and Damoo Dhotre, the male, Indian, big cat trainer. Tait observes that “[t]he wearing of a live animal in the position of a fur collar was the ultimate display of species control in the circus,” and that “[t]he liveness of the animal body foreshadowed the deadness of fur in social fashions” (127). The section “Feelings for Species” in that chapter takes up the issue of speciesism and the instability of species categories, citing important theorists including Peter Singer, Donna Haraway, Elizabeth Grosz, Paola Cavalieri, Jacques Derrida, and Luc Ferry to get at the question, “Can feeling responses, including conflicted emotional feelings, confound the way in which boundaries are established around species and thus benefit nonhuman animals?” (146).
Tait's fifth chapter, “Born Free Again,” looks at “sex symbol” trainers Charly Baumann and Gunther Gebel-Williams and how, in the midst of animal rights and social liberation movements during the 1960s and 1970s, their suave charisma replaced the “hyper-masculine” (8) acts that preceded them. The film Born Free (1966) was a watershed moment for Western industrial societies' empathy with lions and, by extension, other large cats, and this affected audience expectations at the circus. In this chapter's section “Rights for Animal Emotions,” Tait brings together the thinking of key figures in the discourse, including Marc Bekoff, Tom Regan, Vicki Hearne, and Martha Nussbaum, but ends with the chagrined observation that “[t]he human right to animal emotions . . . remains an increasingly dominant force across films, television and throughout representation” (182).
Chapter 6, “Sensing Emotion,” serves as the book's conclusion and contains the heart of Tait's argument. She draws on work by such figures as Maurice Merleau-Ponty, Ralph R. Acampora, and Una Chaudhuri, and ends her book with the argument that “the arousal of emotional feelings should be central to the discussion of animals and of their treatment as beings in the world, but this needs to accommodate understandings of how contradictory and inexplicable emotions are an inseparable part of the fluctuating sensations of lived bodies” (198).
Major themes coalesce in Tait's evocative and often poetic chapter titles and section headings to inspire literary pleasure, but they also make it challenging to discern Tait's subjects at first glance. The combination of abstract titles and complicated, interwoven thematic histories makes the book's index an indispensible tool. Tait's focus on the emotional tone of animal performance across media, as well as her nuanced application of various theories and animal behavior studies, provides a strong model of the tremendous potential of interdisciplinary work. This is an illuminating and pleasurable book for those dedicated to the ever-expanding fields of animal studies and performance.
