One look at the best-selling books on the Middle East and it is clear that Yemen has captured center stage. Anthropologist Gabriele vom Bruck's excellent case study offers an important contribution to this literature. More than that, this lucidly written study of the effects of systemic political and cultural change on a segment of Northern Yemeni society since 1962 should be required reading to any political analyst working on the country today.
What stands out in this rich and complicated story of transition is the fact that vom Bruck accessed the former ruling urban elite of Northern Yemen. This in itself is invaluable to those of us wishing to understand the intercommunal dynamics at play in and around the region of Saʿdah, the epicenter of the so-called “Huthi” insurrection today. In spite of its 2005 publication date, vom Bruck's patient and sensitive work sheds light on rarely considered personal traumas that remain relevant today.
This book fills any number of holes in a scholarship focused primarily on rural farming communities. Despite the excellent work of Martha Mundy and Shelagh Weir in particular, this aspect seems to have obscured largely urban, educated groups associated with a Zaydi sāda (sing. sayyid) class in North Yemen. One consequence of this neglect is a misreading of Northern Yemeni power politics by less accomplished social scientists, leading to the heavy emphasis on “tribalism” at the expense of other sociopolitical forces in North Yemen. In vom Bruck's study, the sāda are presented as directly engaged in a complicated intersection of forces that reflect personal claims to “tradition” via the use of taqlīd (the evocation of religious orthodoxies within Zaydi practice), long ignored in studies on “tribal shaykhs.” In exploring how these former ruling elites and their children articulate a sense of “past” and “self” in what she calls their “individual subjectivity,” vom Bruck offers insight into the evocation of taqlīd among sāda as a reflection of an instinct for self-preservation in an otherwise hostile country.
Mediated by teachers, mothers, and oral historians, this “evolving” tradition includes a doctrine of social discipline shaped by sāda commitment to religious studies. This is developed in Part I of the book through the analysis of the “anatomy” of social interactions among the sāda, which are linked to a historical relationship with power structures all but eradicated by 1962. This empty core of sāda society leaves vom Bruck's subjects actively “remembering” a place in society that no longer exists in the terms on to which they seem to stubbornly hold. This second part of the book sheds light on the strategic manner in which an individual's memories of childhood, for instance, serve as the foundations for the adult's political and social orientation. Such an angle ultimately helps us appreciate how community is sustained (often with the strong hand of the mother and wife [pp. 131–62]) in the face of hostilities that threaten the very existence of the community.
As a result of her tireless interviews with a broad range of informants, vom Bruck is able to share with her readers the rigorous test the community uses to determine an individual's inclusion. Linked to its association with “houses of learning,” such criteria for inclusion (until 2005 at least) serve as the exclusive legitimating force within an otherwise marginal community of sāda. The emphasis on pedagogical tradition, in other words, constitutes an interesting case of negotiated principles that flow between an exclusionary association through the taqlīd and the need to somehow assimilate in a postrevolution society encouraged to despise this former elite. The tensions are handled especially well by vom Bruck in Chapter 11, which highlights the contrast between this self-association with a dignity of tradition in the face of the modern materialism of Yemen and a political force that tries to mobilize the “masses” against these people. To some, such forces were overwhelming.
Throughout Part IV, vom Bruck elaborates on the painfully unsuccessful acts of political subordination by some within the community (sometimes by wearing expensive clothes or retelling defamatory stories/rumors/jokes about the generic sayyid [see Chapters 9 and 10]) who want to integrate into larger postunification Yemeni society. Drawn from this careful analysis of how certain sāda eagerly hope to balance being a sayyid with the demand that they demonstrate loyalty to some form of larger “Yemeni” society, vom Bruck's excellent ethnography may prove useful to understanding some of the sources of conflict in the North today. While I have argued elsewhere that the so-called “Huthi” group actually constitutes a much more diverse set of interests resisting the ʿAli Abdullah Salih regime, the core demands of the Huthi are linked to these sāda in that many among the fighters identify the latter as natural leaders of the larger Zaydi community.
In this respect, it is somewhat disappointing that vom Bruck iterates in her concluding sections an optimism that the escalation of violence surfacing in the region would subside. The idea that conflict in the North could be resolved through some vague notion of “an inclusive national identity” (p. 254) seems in hindsight to be completely misplaced. Clearly this “inclusive national identity” is nowhere in sight in Yemen today.
And yet, despite her misplaced optimism that some “Yemeni” consciousness could find its way into the daily functions of the country's politics (a misreading of the Salih regime more than the unwillingness of sāda to assimilate into a larger Yemen) this book is not only essential reading for everyone writing about present-day Yemen but is also a valuable addition to the classroom. In this respect, I have found that upper-level undergraduate students are particularly appreciative of the depth and personal access the book offers. The sāda prove to be complex and highly articulate agents of postrevolutionary Yemen whose complicated adjustments helped students appreciate the depth of Yemeni society and its hitherto-ignored urban religious/educated elite. For this alone vom Bruck deserves praise.
