Curiosity and wonder have emerged as key concepts for understanding the set of transformations formerly known as the scientific revolution. R. J. W. Evans's preface to this collection briefly outlines these concepts and recent developments in relevant areas of historical scholarship. The more detailed introduction by Evans's co-editor, Alexander Marr, discusses the problems facing anyone attempting to define the concepts over a period when both underwent large changes, and when the relationship between them and with various forms of knowledge shifted and was redefined. In Marr's view, tracking curiosity and wonder brings otherwise submerged interconnections between objects, texts, individuals and ideas to the surface, where the historian can follow them across conventional disciplinary boundaries. The case studies offered here aim thus to reveal, in Marr's words, ‘the ways in which curiosity and wonder changed or remained stable over time, in different contexts, and from place to place’ (p. 8).
The reader's journey begins with Wes Williams's chapter on Renaissance travellers' tales. In these we see the association in the period of danger and authority, and the importance of the credibility of authors of accounts of their travels. The following chapter, by Neil Kenny, explores curiosity in terms of narratives, collecting and the relationships between them. He shows the value of respecting the ways that these terms were changed and redefined – a theme which recurs throughout the papers in this volume. Also dealing with collections of objects, Andrea Turpin discusses the organization of the collections of Duke Cosimo I de' Medici, showing that, in this context, objects from the New World were integrated within other, older categories, and did not constitute a separate category simply because of their geographical origin. In Claire Preston's chapter, on sixteenth- and seventeenth-century English literature, we see that by this time, in this place, wonders had become the subject of satire and parody. Nevertheless, as the succeeding chapters show, this development did not mean that the concept was no longer current. Peter Forshaw, for instance, shows the ways that wonders were an essential part of the discovery of knowledge and secrets for the late sixteenth-century writer Heinrich Khunrath.
Also dealing with occult themes, Stephen Clucas considers the potential motives of Meric Casaubon in publishing John Dee's account of his communication with spirits. Clucas suggests that the publication was intended as an attack on contemporary trends, including the interest in occult philosophy among learned readers. Automata, which had at times been associated with occult knowledge, are the subject of Alexander Marr's chapter, which discusses the debates about their status that continued into the Enlightenment. Moving from machines to medicine, Deborah Harkness writes about how curiosity about the body was manifested, and the ways in which it took different forms in different places. She argues that developments at Continental European universities in anatomy, and dissection in particular, seem to have had less impact in England, where the focus was instead on the culture of therapeutics. Two chapters focusing on the eighteenth century conclude the volume, bringing the chronological focus into the Enlightenment. Paola Bertucci returns to the theme of travel narratives and shows that interest in marvels and wonders was still strong in Enlightenment Italy. Focusing on Jean Antoine Nollet's account of his travels, she argues that his account of his experiments to debunk marvels provided a way for him to prove his abilities as an experimental philosopher. George Rousseau considers the idea of people as curiosities, and what it meant to be called lusus naturae in this period. In the volume's epilogue, Rousseau traces the path of curiosity into the nineteenth century, suggesting that ideas of curiosity and wonder can be traced in the emerging subjects of psychology and psychoanalytics.
Covering over three hundred years and ranging across Europe, Curiosity and Wonder from the Renaissance to the Enlightenment presents ten snapshots of its title concepts and their intertwinings. Taken together, the individual chapters show the complexity and changeability of a pair of topics that have come under increasing scrutiny in recent decades. Avoiding a linear narrative, the volume nonetheless provides insight, especially with the help of Marr's introduction, which highlights some of the themes running through the case studies, providing ways to see the links between the contributions as well as the differences between them.
