With this book Tacitus (‘T.’) becomes one of a handful of ancient authors honoured with his own Cambridge Companion. Yet just as his star joins that firmament, in his Introduction editor A. J. Woodman conjures up a bleak future in which no one will be able to read T. in Latin. His introduction ends with a tentative wish that the volume might for a moment stave off this onrush of oblivion and perhaps entice some readers to learn Latin. Obviously this is rather more of a burden than the average companion assumes, and one that mirrors, strikingly, the resistance to an environment of forgetting that T.'s work constitutes.
The more ordinary job of a Companion is registered in the preface: to speak to a wide audience, from expert to a range of kinds of neophyte. The approach to this end is ‘to provide a practical demonstration of current work on Tacitus as written by experts’ (xv). Here the volume shines. The essays are of very high quality, and the resourceful contributors consistently weave ‘what you need to know’, in an accessible way, into original and thought-provoking interpretations. The set of topics covered, in turn, reflects a tight and economical plan. No space is given to subjects of narrow or idiosyncratic interest: every essay deals with a basic question, and the contributors have worked conscientiously within their essays to demonstrate why that question is basic. Further subjects might have been considered for inclusion, but above all I think readers with chiefly historical interests will feel the lack of practical help. No doubt the broader impression communicated in the introduction and underscored everywhere else in the book, that T.'s work is profoundly literary, is a thing — maybe the main thing — a historian needs to know, but a concentrated treatment of T.'s sources, his use of them, and the conditions of history-writing at Rome might have served that readership well.
The papers are organized into four groups: ‘Contexts’, ‘Texts’, ‘Topics’, and ‘Transmissions’. In ‘Contexts’, first A. M. Gowing surveys for us what the Roman historiographical tradition looked like and what T. may have been reading: Cato, Sallust, and Livy loom large (disclosure: this reviewer is a former student of G.'s). Woodman himself tackles T.'s life and times, touching on the well-known but sparse data for his career, but teasing out new interactions between T.'s work and Pliny, and Suetonius and the Flavian poets too, and tentatively advancing a new interpretation of the record to support the notion that the perspectives of T. and Trajan diverged late in their lives.
In the next section, ‘Texts’, T.'s writing is sliced up by work or (in Annals) by princeps. In a few pages A. R. Birley pulls together a wide range of political, historical and literary aspects of Agricola — poor Calgacus is left stranded at the end, though. Richard F. Thomas then demonstrates the thoroughly literary character of the Germania: genre, allusion and style predominate. Sander M. Goldberg argues that Dialogus is polyvocal and of doubtful conclusion; I find Aper's interest in the malodorous Eprius Marcellus and Vibius Crispus more troubling than he does. T.'s presentation of Rome's breakdown and incipient recovery in Histories is covered by Rhiannon Ash fully and clearly in brief compass. In a reading of Ann. 1–6, Christina Shuttleworth Kraus shows us a Tiberius who is the product of a pattern of synkrises — with principes past and future, with Germanicus, with Agrippina and with Livia. For S. J. V. Malloch, the Claudian Annals suppress Claudius; in these books, we also see T. preferring ‘artistry and thematic coherence’ (122) to chronology. E. E. Keitel accounts for the Neronian books by discussing the deaths in them, an approach that — significantly — enables her to touch on most major features of these books.
Section 3, ‘Topics’, deals with matters that cross the corpus or present special problems in a work. Christopher Pelling argues that the ‘personal voice’ of T., whether implied or made explicit through an ‘I’, trains the reader and shapes his or her experience. Miriam T. Griffin scans T.'s work for a philosophy of history and finds his thinking unimpressive; for her, his real strength lies in ‘his skill in handling [his] material … and the persuasiveness of his narrative’ (177), a contention three case-studies are enlisted to support. We next hear twice from S. P. Oakley. In his first piece he surveys T.'s preoccupation with the Senate and with the relationship between senator and emperor; here the organizing concept is libertas. Next he gives a concise overview of the chief characteristics of T.'s style and language, with helpful examples and attention to the effect of T.'s choices. There follow a pair of offerings from D. S. Levene. His first essay argues that the speeches in Histories and their impact emphasize that with the Principate the location of power has shifted and ‘that the ostensible holders of power are acting on an illusion of personal authority that they can in fact maintain only with the support of others’ (223). The subject of the second is warfare in Annals, where T. mainly presents campaigns and battles with little detail or drama; for Levene, the effect of this is to portray the deadening of martial virtue under the Principate, and the few exceptions to the pattern underscore the achievements of Germanicus.
‘Transmissions’, the fourth and final section, is an absorbing series of studies in T.'s legacy. R. H. Martin, to whose memory the volume is fittingly dedicated, surveys the MS tradition, the first printed editions, and the contributions of the great early modern scholars to the constitution of T.'s text. Alexandra Gajda's chapter tracks, by contrast, the contribution of T. to early modern European political thought (and, to a degree, action): I am struck to see here, and in subsequent essays, how many and diverse are the perspectives that T.'s work has been taken to support. Gibbon, I am not surprised to learn in Paul Cartledge's essay, was fundamentally shaped by T., but I am happy to see the limits of that influence explored and its varieties specified and exampled. I read with grim apprehension C. B. Krebs' concise history of the reception of the Germania, knowing the work's eventual place in the mad imaginings of the architects and creatures of the Third Reich. Martha Malamud's case-studies of twentieth-century novelists who knew T. show the power his narratives had for those who witnessed the disillusionments, struggles, and atrocities of that century. Finally, Mark Toher lays out the diversity and depth of the influence T. exerted on Sir Ronald Syme, the man who for fifty years has defined T. for classical scholars: the influence is a matter of method, of outlook, of judgement, but above all of style.
Both long-time enthusiasts of T. and those whose interest is only now stirring should be grateful to have this well-conceived and well-executed volume.
