Michel Foucault's Discipline and Punish (Paris: Gallimard, 1975) incited historians working on different subjects and periods to scrutinize many kinds of disciplinary institutions and practices. Since the 1970s and 1980s, a voluminous body of literature has accumulated on centers of incarceration, mainly hospitals, mental institutions, schools, poor houses, reformatories, and, of course, prisons. Historians of the late Ottoman Empire have also produced significant research inspired by the Foucauldian analysis of surveillance and control. Nineteenth-century Ottoman reforms and centralization policies have been almost categorically analyzed with reference to governmentality. In addition, authors of numerous monographs on Ottoman institutions have used Foucault's ideas to theoretically frame their work. Surprisingly, Ottoman prisons have not been subject to this kind of analysis. Kent F. Schull's excellent and original book fills this lacuna by examining the transformation of the Ottoman criminal justice system, with particular reference to prisons and incarceration.
While clearly influenced by Foucault, Schull aspires to go beyond the idea that prisons are sites of social control and discipline. In fact, the study assumes the interconnectedness of policing, criminal codes, courts, and incarceration. According to Schull, the penal institution is a “social institution”—a microcosm that embodies and regenerates wider cultural categories—because punishment is “grounded in wider patterns of knowing, feeling, and acting” (p. 11). And indeed, the author treats prisons as such throughout the work. The book describes in detail the major political developments of the period under study (changing regulations, sultans’ attitudes, regime changes, major reforms, ideologies, wars, etc.), which will be of particular benefit to readers without a background in Ottoman history.
Despite the author's use of terminology pointing to periodization—for example, “late Ottoman,” “Tanzimat,” “modernization,” and “centralization”—his narrative does not emphasize the differences between prison reforms of the long 19th century. On the contrary, the author claims that each Ottoman administration built on the efforts of its predecessor: just as Abdulhamid II's reforms were an expansion of prior ones (p. 46), the Committee of Union and Progress used Hamidian prison regulations as a template for its own reforms (p. 52). Schull therefore treats the Tanzimat, Hamidian, and Young Turk periods not as discernibly separate regimes with different approaches to criminal justice, but rather in terms of continuity. The keyword in his understanding of late Ottoman prison reforms is “culmination.” Rupture only comes with the loss of World War I and the Entente occupation of Istanbul, when the Committee of Union and Progress’ loss of power and the difficult wartime circumstances caused prison conditions to deteriorate quickly (pp. 60, 195). The book's conclusion, which is based on several reports by Allied officers in Istanbul and the account of Clarence Richard Johnson, the author of Constantinople To-Day; or, The Pathfinder Survey of Constantinople (1920), also stresses that the new Republican regime chose not to implement the regulations it inherited from its Ottoman predecessor. While many historians of the Ottoman Empire over the past decades have been emphasizing continuity from the late Ottoman to the early republican period, Schull invokes the relevance of the older rupture theory in the case of prison reforms.
The author admits that the first two chapters, in which he gives an overview of Ottoman criminal justice practices, reforms, laws, and regulations, are state centered. The following chapters, however, “contrast the particular reform efforts with the actual experiences of the inmates” (p. 12). To access these experiences, Schull unearthed invaluable, rare, and unused documents from the Ottoman archives, including detailed prison statistics collected from across the empire. A significant portion of these statistics come from 1911 to 1912, 1914, 1916 to 1917, 1918 to 1919, and 1919 to 1920. The charts contain information on age, marital status, occupation, ethnic, religious, and national identity (or a combination thereof), literacy, criminal history, date of incarceration, and prison sentence. Social historians informed by postcolonial theory have underlined the difficulty of hearing the voices of the subaltern, especially due to the scarcity of primary sources relating to subordinated groups. Reading the documents against the grain has been the social historian's great savior. As Schull's book demonstrates, researchers are now managing to read numbers against the grain as well. In pursuing this technique, Prisons in the Late Ottoman Empire offers insight and inspiration for scholars wanting to write “history from below.”
In addition to statistics, the book relies on documentation from the Ottoman archives such as photographs of prisons and prisoners, architectural designs, building projects, and reports on expenditures, hygiene, sanitation, and health. The photographs are especially valuable for their depiction of prison life, but unfortunately they are too small and in black-and-white rather than color print. This is a missed opportunity to allow readers to see the rich details of the Karesi central prison. Given the lamentable situation of the documents in the frequently flooded new location of the Prime Ministry's Ottoman Archives in Kağıthane, let us hope that Schull at least has copies of this precious material for future use.
Schull's research brings to life miserable prison conditions, such as overcrowding, filth, disease, poor ventilation and lighting, lack of running water, and insufficient sources of drinking water. The basic requirements of the new prison regulations, such as dormitory style wards and the availability of washrooms, toilets, running water, electricity, ventilation, a courtyard, a kitchen, and an infirmary, were not uniformly established and remained more like luxuries. Schull also provides a glimpse of the everyday life of prisoners through a focus on idleness, gambling, fights, malnutrition, and so forth. However, the data on which he draws is entirely anonymous. There are no real names, life stories, or personal accounts, making it almost impossible to trace the actual person within “the general summary.” This is disappointing for social historians who seek to recover life stories of ordinary people. The discussion of new spatial relations, especially for female inmates (Chapter 4), and of juvenile delinquency and notions of childhood (Chapter 6), only vaguely give voice to women and children. Both chapters present excellent overviews of changing patterns of incarceration with reference to new reforms and regulations, the state's increased involvement in the lives of women and children, and novel conceptions of gender and childhood. However, women and children remain confined in the state discourse and do not appear to have agency as historical actors.
Schull's book challenges the stereotypical image of the “Turkish Prison,” which was represented as a barbarous and venal space in the film Midnight Express. The book claims that Ottoman authorities succeeded in reforming the empire's prisons and criminal justice system over the course of the 19th century. As a citizen and resident of Turkey, the word “prison” reminds me not of Midnight Express but of the 19 December 2000 Return to Life operations. While implementing F-type cells in prisons across Turkey, around 10,000 security guards violently attacked prisoners in more than twenty prisons who had initiated a hunger strike in protest of the new system. The security guards ultimately killed thirty prisoners and injured hundreds more. In Foucauldian terms, the state attempted to enhance its sovereignty over prisoners, while the latter resisted fiercely. Prisons in the Late Ottoman Empire gives an account of poor conditions and difficult circumstances in Ottoman prisons in addition to glimpses of amelioration. Left out, however, are instances of inmate resistance to these reforms. The uprisings and disturbances touched on by the author (p. 116) should be the subject of future analysis.
