Undocumented transit migration has come to be one of the most criminalised and persecuted forms of migration worldwide. Whether in Europe or across the Americas, media and political discourses have fabricated a hegemonic narrative of undocumented migrants as racialised subjects whose most relevant feature is that they unlawfully traverse national borders, usually aided by smugglers. This narrative has reinforced the idea that they are external menaces to the national security of transit and destination countries and because of this they ought to be controlled and punished. Yet, beyond that biased and oversimplified perspective, much has been left aside regarding the structural causes that produce this type of migration as well as who undocumented migrants are and the everyday struggles they face to survive.
Thus, ethnographically based reflections which contest the hegemonic narrative are needed and welcome. Noelle K. Brigden's book The Migrant Passage draws upon an interdisciplinary approach that emphasises a critical dialogue between international relations and anthropology. She analyses why and how undocumented Salvadorean, Honduran and Guatemalan transit migrants undertake treacherous and uncertain clandestine journeys across the Central American–Mexican–US transit corridor and how this passage is determined by the border politics of neoliberal globalisation.
Constructed from a migrant-centred perspective, the book attempts to understand how the dialectical relationship between autonomous mobility and enforced immobility has shaped the transit corridor. Brigden takes George Marcus’ exhortation to ‘follow people’ (p. 27) seriously and spends two years of fieldwork across multiple sites within the corridor to trace the mobility and immobility of undocumented women and men of diverse ages, class origins and nationalities. This is how the author collects stories about migrants’ lives in their homelands and while en route, as well as maps created by them about how they envisioned their transit before, during or even after it happened. Their memories, reflections and imaginations allow her to conclude that the migrant passage is simultaneously an imagined and material, physical and virtual experience that re-configures space. For Brigden, putting herself into motion means playing an active role as a researcher who adopts what she calls a ‘performing ethnography’ (p. 104). This method combined with critical cartography and a line-of-sight ethnography (p. 145) enables her to advance a transformative and fluid research methodology which ultimately mirrors migration practice. The book's methodological approach might serve to study other transit experiences, and this is undoubtedly one of its main contributions.
Unpacking the migrant passage is a twofold analytical challenge. First, it means to unveil the tactics and strategies that undocumented migrants accumulate, exchange and invent to set themselves into motion and to survive along a territory riddled with violence. Second, it also implies a critical understanding of how structural causes – such as systemic inequality, abject poverty, racism, the history of Central American civil wars and the interventionist role of the United States – have impacted on migrants’ lives and determined the migrant passage. Brigden herself embarks on this challenge and through a combined micro-political and structural analysis demonstrates how each of the individual stories that comprise her book cannot be grasped without a critical inquiry into neoliberal state policies and into the ‘long-reaching shadow of the [US] border’ (p. 7). What is more, the author proves that the transnationalisation of the US border policy southwards together with state exclusionary policies of hierarchical and racialised citizenship have directly impacted the everyday lives of transit migrants who are forced to confront multiple types of borders.
Brigden chooses a theatrical metaphor as a narrative strategy. She describes the scenario, the plot, the script and climax, the characters and their transformative roles along the six chapters of the book. The scenario where the migrant passage unfolds is part of a larger political theatre in which the intensification of migration policing and migrant suffering is part of a border spectacle of racism and violence against undocumented migrants.
The author's dramaturgical perspective means that to traverse the transit corridor – a space of risk, danger and potential harm – migrants insistently display ‘survival plays’ made up of improvisations (pp. 44, 102). In this context, improvisations should not be underestimated but seen as a social and political strategy. Information, as the author argues, can be a ‘resource and a curse’ (p. 7). Migrants accumulate knowledge traded with their migrant family and friends; but, while en route, if they do not learn new practices and protocols to negotiate, their passage can be blocked. Improvising and performing social roles and gender and nationality identities is therefore a survival strategy that determines the migrant passage. This is what configures the micro-political spatial and ambiguous interrelations between migrants, strangers, border agents, smugglers, bandits, local actors, enganchadores (recruiters), priests, researchers and numerous other actors who take part in the transit corridor.
A remarkable final contribution is that Brigden demonstrates that the corridor is a contingent space built upon continuity and change. The migrant passage has been a historical experience within the Central American region since at least the mid-1980s, when Salvadorean and Guatemalan refugees traversed the corridor looking for protection. Migrants, smugglers, enganchadores and border agents were already shaping the corridor; yet, there have been unquestionable changes. New characters have appeared, like deportees, mareros (members of a gang called Mara Salvatrucha) or zetas (members of a cartel called Los Zetas), who have reconfigured the political economy of the transit corridor. Though risk and violence were always present in the clandestine passage, nowadays they are exacerbated. The leading regional migratory policies of control belts and toughness for deterrence, together with the proliferation of drug cartels and criminal gangs, have resulted in the increase in mass graves of migrants. Against this increasingly violent space, migrants’ improvisations and performances turn out to be part of a daily political struggle deployed by women and men on the move to survive.
This book is a portrait of underground globalisation in action and hence a counter-hegemonic narrative of undocumented migration in the Americas. It is a definitive contribution to transnational migration scholarship, which has overlooked what long-distance transits entail and mean politically. Though focused on Central American experiences, this book speaks to a wider US, Latin American and global audience. Transit corridors, such as the one studied in this book, proliferate on a global scale. Yet, as Brigden concludes, they do not necessarily take migrants to their destinations, but to unimaginable violent ordeals. We should be receptive therefore to Brigden's call for a new understanding of sovereignty, beyond a border security approach. Her call for route studies means focusing on mobility and on the sovereignty that people have to set themselves into motion as a way to cope with layers of violence and to struggle for their lives. Her call to understand the power of social sovereignty materialised on the route must be embraced as a way to critically identify possible new spatial transformative paths in our violent times.
