No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
Curtis Ryan's Jordan in Transition fills a major gap in the literature as a timely, well-written, and accessible book. Ryan places the passage from Hussein to Abdullah within the context of multiple, overlapping transitions since the late 1980s—in foreign policy, economic policy, and domestic liberalization. Of these transitions, Ryan argues, political liberalization has been the least complete. With lively prose and an impressive base of primary research and interviews, Jordan in Transition is the best single book-length introduction available to Jordanian politics.
Ryan grounds his discussion of these transitions within a theory of “the political economy of regime security.” The emphasis on the primacy of economic considerations recalls Laurie Brand's decade-old claims for the centrality of “budget security” to Jordanian foreign policy. Beyond capturing an additional decade of history, Ryan's approach is both more subtle and more flexible, and he applies his argument to a wider range of topics. Ryan does not overplay his claims for political economy, and in his concrete discussions of foreign policy and liberalization the political economy of regime security often disappears for pages on end in favor of shrewd, grounded analysis. While this can be frustrating for the political scientist looking for the testing of specific hypotheses, it works well for a pragmatic but theoretically grounded analytical overview of recent Jordanian politics.
Ryan's strength is his intimate knowledge of Jordanian politics and extensive research; his familiarity with a wide range of theoretical traditions; and the breadth of his coverage of topics. He draws on an impressive array of Arabic-language sources and has interviewed many of the appropriate individuals in a series of research trips spanning nearly a decade. His discussions of Jordanian–Palestinian relations and of the political impact of economic reforms are subtle and nuanced and attentive to the texture of its politics, and they refrain from making the generalizations that tend to mar discussion of that subject. The discussion of the tense times surrounding the transition from Hussein to Abdullah is first-rate, as is the detailed analysis of the 1997 general election and the 1999 municipal elections. The comparison between the 1989 and 1996 riots nicely captures what had changed and what had not after years of “transition.”
Ryan is convincing on the limits of the Jordanian experiment with liberalization and offers a gloomy verdict on the results of the fevered and excited liberal moment of the early 1990s. He argues convincingly that economic development occupies a rather higher position in elite priorities than does genuine democratization. His straightforward presentation of the manipulation of the 1993 and 1997 elections leaves little doubt about the chilling effect of regime policy on democratic choice. The general trajectory of a regime backsliding on its liberalizing promises emerges clearly. Given the importance of its “moderate” and “pro–Western” image to relations with the United States, one almost wonders from Ryan's account whether the process is more about putting on a liberal face to the outside world than it is about internal reform. Such an argument would fit nicely with Ryan's political-economy argument, since it would place the pursuit of American aid and international investment at the center of the story.
His explanation of Jordan's decisions in the Gulf War, and of Jordanian foreign policy more broadly, is less convincing. The book does an excellent job of describing the deep shifts in foreign policy over the course of the 1990s, as Hussein tied Jordan's fortunes to the peace process and to close relations with the United States. Like others who emphasize economic factors, however, he has difficulty accounting for the cross-pressures of Iraqi and Gulf (and American) economic interests and tends to downplay the importance of more political incentives and constraints. It is in this chapter that the tension between his political-economy analysis and rich empirical analysis comes into greatest tension. He repeatedly introduces public opinion, the king's personal preferences, or other non-economic variables on an ad hoc basis to explain outcomes, without modifying his theoretical claims in response.
The chapter on economic adjustment offers a clear-eyed assessment of Jordan's efforts, with an eye more toward its political impact than its economic success or failure. Oddly, given the book's emphasis on economic factors, little detailed evidence is presented here about the impact of economic liberalization. A richer presentation of Jordan's changing economic circumstances, and the extent of its reforms, would have been appropriate.
Although Ryan's presentation is fresh and compelling and offers a wealth of useful detail, few of his conclusions will surprise readers familiar with Jordanian politics or the growing scholarship on the country. For example, the central argument that Jordan began its liberalization process in 1989 defensively and then began to retreat over the course of the 1990s follows rather than challenges the conventional wisdom. This can in part be attributed to the book's aspirations to provide an accessible and comprehensive introduction to Jordan's politics—something at which it succeeds. Still, the book would have been even better had Ryan been able to translate his rich knowledge of Jordan and his theoretical insights into more surprising or controversial conclusions. Overall, Jordan in Transition is a welcome addition to the growing literature on Jordan. It is now the best available single-book introduction to Jordanian politics at the undergraduate level and would be useful for courses on Middle East politics, comparative politics, foreign policy, and democratization.