I. INTRODUCTION
Haley Moss was diagnosed with autism at age three. At the time, her parents were told that achievements such as obtaining a driver’s license, graduating from high school, or even making friends were unlikely. Even after she proved the experts wrong and gained acceptance to law school, Moss saw continued challenges for students with disabilities. “I remember in my first year of law school, there was a blind student in my section, but she did not return for the second semester—and I wondered why,” she told us.Footnote 1 “Law school is not always as accessible as it could be for people with disabilities.”Footnote 2 But those people are essential to the functioning of our legal system, she added: “We need all types of minds to get all kinds of jobs done.”Footnote 3
That understanding is the motivation behind Diversity and Inclusion in the American Legal Profession: Discrimination and Bias Reported by Lawyers with Disabilities and Lawyers Who Identify as LGBTQ+, a new study by Peter Blanck, Fitore Hyensi, and Fatma Altunkol Wise.Footnote 4 Among other findings, it notes that lawyers with disabilities are more likely than those without disabilities to report discrimination, in both subtle and overt forms; that individual and organizational factors, such as other components of a lawyer’s identity and the type of firm at which they work, impact those reports of discrimination; and that while extensive research already exists on diversity, equity, and inclusion (“DEI”) in the field of law,Footnote 5 this study is an “incremental step” to extend that focus to include lawyers with disabilities.
The Law School Admission Council (“LSAC”) has made disability inclusion a cornerstone of its DEI efforts in recent years and is committed to ensuring that law students with disabilities receive a fair shot in their journey toward a law degree.Footnote 6 But, Blanck et al. remind us that the challenges facing these students and lawyers are complex—and thus require intentional, nuanced solutions. Those challenges must be considered not in isolation, but in relation to the compounding effects of bias based on race, gender, class, sexual orientation, and other factors.
That intersectionality was personal for Moss, who, as a woman with a disability, faced dual obstacles during law school.Footnote 7 But, she knew the legal system needed her voice, and that it was important to persevere. She recalled a memorable conversation with an attorney who, like her, had autism. “It was very meaningful to talk with someone with their own firm who had the same diagnosis as me,” she said.Footnote 8 “It shows we’re out there.”Footnote 9
Indeed, talented and valuable lawyers and law students with disabilities are out there, and LSAC stands ready to help them add their vital voices to the legal profession. Blanck et al. provide insight for how to proceed in this important effort, and their study serves as a reminder of how much further we must go to create a legal system that is equitable and inclusive—and, in turn, is fully representative of our society as a whole.
II. BACKGROUND: LSAC
Since its founding, LSAC has been committed to promoting access and equity in law school admission and creating opportunities for candidates to succeed. Our flagship exam, the Law School Admission Test (“LSAT”), was created in response to the legal field being dominated by white men from privileged backgrounds.Footnote 10 Admission to law school often hinged on the endorsement of a family member who already was a prominent faculty member, lawyer, or judge.Footnote 11 Through a standardized way of assessing the skills needed to be successful in law school, the LSAT serves as one important factor in a holistic admission review process.Footnote 12 In other words, the LSAT was created to measure a candidate’s potential, not privilege.
At its core, then, LSAC is an organization aiming to give all law school candidates an equal opportunity for admission. But, we would be remiss not to mention aspects of LSAC’s history that relate to candidates with disabilities. In 2014, the organization entered into a consent decree in response to a Justice Department lawsuit over LSAC’s handling of testing accommodations for candidates with disabilities.Footnote 13 Under the consent decree, LSAC paid significant penalties and damages to affected test takers, changed its policies for accommodating such test takers, and implemented additional practices to support candidates with disabilities who take the LSAT.Footnote 14 This experience was a welcomed and humbling opportunity to be at the forefront of change. This was a lesson about not just doing the right thing, but about setting an example for all law schools.
Much has changed since 2014. Under President and CEO Kellye Y. Testy’s leadership since 2017, LSAC has strived to open the lines of communication between the organization and groups that represent and advocate for candidates with disabilities. In this and other ways, LSAC aims to support those with disabilities, in part by realizing that we are not the experts in this area. Instead, we must listen to, and learn from, candidates, students, and lawyers with disabilities and from disability advocates to understand what those in their communities need to be successful in this area. With this philosophy in mind, LSAC has become an organization centered on equity for all and is committed to working with law school administrators and faculty and other legal professionals on these efforts.
Our recent move to the online, remotely-proctored LSAT-Flex, made necessary by the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, has enabled candidates to take the LSAT at home, on their own computer.Footnote 15 Additionally, this online version of the LSAT was designed from the beginning with accommodation features as a top priority. And, while we have committed to bridging the “digital divide” by providing testing equipment and a quiet space with internet access to those who need it, LSAC continues to work to provide test takers the additional accommodations they may require.
LSAC’s commitment to people with disabilities is not limited to the LSAT. We continue to expand our staff, our collective expertise, and our DEI initiatives to reflect feedback from candidates and others in the disability community on what support is needed and valued. Blanck et al. remind us, however, that more work remains to ensure that those with disabilities feel fully supported not just as candidates and law school students, but as lawyers seeking justice for their clients.Footnote 16
III. THE CURRENT RESEARCH
The study by Blanck et al. reveals much about the challenges faced by lawyers with disabilities. It is important to keep in mind, however, that these issues are layered and complex, and that additional research will be key to moving the mission of DEI in the legal profession forward as it relates to lawyers with disabilities and to other minoritizedFootnote 17 groups.
The findings of the earlier phases of this study of lawyers with disabilities and lawyers who identify as LGBTQ+ revealed that, in our efforts to support diversity and facilitate inclusivity, we must recognize the nuance and complexity of inequity at the intersection of identities, especially at the intersection of multiple marginalized identities.18 Counter to the predictions of Blanck et al., “being a person with a disability was negatively associated with having an accommodation granted.”Footnote 18 But, that likelihood varied depending on each lawyer’s additional marginalized identities: older lawyers, on average, reported a higher likelihood of having accommodations granted, but women and racial and ethnic minorities saw that likelihood go down with age.Footnote 19 Likewise, LGBTQ+ lawyers who are racial minorities were less likely than White LGBTQ+ lawyers to receive accommodations.Footnote 20
Earlier, we discussed LSAC’s approach to testing accommodations for candidates with disabilities.Footnote 21 This approach, which has evolved over time, represents a proactive and nuanced effort, developed in partnership with disability advocates, to improve access to the LSAT. While acknowledging that more work remains to be done,Footnote 22 we encourage law firms to consider a similar approach to ensure their lawyers with disabilities receive the same fair treatment.Footnote 23
The current phase of the studyFootnote 24 by Blanck et al. focuses specifically on discrimination and bias reported by lawyers with disabilities and lawyers who identify as LGBTQ+. It finds that lawyers with disabilities show a higher likelihood of reporting only subtle discrimination (unconscious or unintentional, and entrenched in common, everyday interactions, such as harassment, jokes, incivility, avoidance, and so on), along with a higher likelihood of subtle discrimination combined with overt discrimination (defined as differential and unfair treatment with visible structural outcomes, such as workplace policies and practices).Footnote 25 Women, as compared to men, and minorities were found to be more likely to report all three types of discrimination (subtle, overt, and a combination of subtle and overt).Footnote 26 Reports of discrimination were less likely from lawyers working at private firms, but more likely (in terms of subtle discrimination) from lawyers working at larger organizations.Footnote 27
Overall, this latest study illustrates that primary and multiple minoritized identities are associated with reports of discrimination and bias in the field of law. This is unsurprising, given that such discrimination and bias exists in virtually every corner of our society. Progress has been made, but much work remains to ensure that lawyers are evaluated by the quality of their work, rather than by stereotypes and stigma tied to their race, ethnicity, gender identity, sexual orientation, and disability. Access is not enough. As a legal community, LSAC, law schools, and stakeholders must work together to collectively address inequity along the entire journey from application, enrollment, success in law school, licensure, and in practice.
IV. FUTURE RESEARCH: AMPLIFYING VOICES AT THE INTERSECTION
It is important to note that these studies only scratch the surface of these complex issues. For instance, the studies’ data are derived from the responses of 3590 individuals who completed an online survey.Footnote 28 For a wide range of reasons, including the negative stigma of their identities, many lawyers with disabilities and other minoritized lawyers may have chosen not to respond. While the data gathered by Blanck et al. is illuminating, more data is needed to gain a clearer picture of the challenges faced by lawyers with disabilities, particularly those who face compounded inequity at the intersection of their other identities. The fear of being perceived as less than, as incompetent, or as getting an unfair advantage if they are granted an accommodation is real for many.
For much of her life, Dr. Angélica Guevara was one of them. Growing up in poverty in Los Angeles as the daughter of immigrants from Mexico, Guevara faced numerous hurdles to achieving her dream of a legal education, including domestic violence and alcoholism at home, and what she calls the “ingrained gender roles” of her culture, which discouraged the idea of even graduating from high school.Footnote 29 She persevered and was admitted to college because of her strong grades, but an undiagnosed reading and writing disability—one that makes it difficult for her to read and follow more than a paragraph at a time—soon began posing challenges to her studies. Faculty members suggested she be tested for a disability, but she was hesitant. “I was taught where I grew up that you’re not a whole person if you’re disabled—that God is punishing you,” she recalls.Footnote 30 “My initial reaction was an example of that stigma.”Footnote 31
Once Guevara was diagnosed, she was able to receive accommodations, such as having her books scanned and having emails read aloud via a computer program.Footnote 32 She began to excel in her classes. But sometimes, there were delays in scanning the books, leaving her scrambling to catch up with her classmates. And during her law school and Ph.D. programs, she dealt with “impostor syndrome,” the feeling that those accommodations flagged her as being undeserving. “If you have a disability, there’s still so much stigma and fear, especially if you have a non-apparent disability,” she says, recalling one job she lost for disclosing her neurodivergence to a client.Footnote 33 While she landed the prestigious William H. Hastie Fellowship at University of Wisconsin Law School, she still faces challenges finding employment in her chosen field.
But a turning point, she says, came when she began sharing her true self with those around her. “Once I got to the Ph.D. [level] and started educating myself [on neurodivergence], I disclosed my disability to friends and family more openly,” she says.Footnote 34 “My first feeling of liberation was when I was able to be fully open about it and have the courage to say it out loud. Even if that meant not getting the job, or even if it meant there were consequences. Because I was really tired of not being my full self.”Footnote 35 She also knew it was important, she says, to set an example for those who come from multiple marginalized and minoritized identities. “I know that every time I disclose, it helps another person after me,” she says.Footnote 36
Guevara now works to educate law firms on disability, and to urge them to move from a medical model of disability, and its “us vs. them” mentality, to a social model, where disabilities are a normal part of human variation.Footnote 37 But she also encourages people like her to develop a sense of inner strength around the knowledge that society does not determine their worth. “Once you have that, you’re able to talk openly about your disability,” she says.Footnote 38 “The more you do that, the more courage it gives other people to do the same.”Footnote 39
The persistence of barrier after barrier is striking in Guevara’s story and telling of the prevalence of stereotypes and stigma that plague higher and legal education, the legal workplace, and society. Intersectionality argues that focusing on one dimension of social stratification, or a person’s identity, overlooks the complexity of how these multiple identities simultaneously impact individuals’ lived experiences.Footnote 40 In Guevara’s case, not only did she have to face the endemic stereotypes of being presumed incompetentFootnote 41 as a woman of color—a Latina who came from poverty—she had to do so with the additional layer of fear and stigma many people with disability face.Footnote 42 Would getting accommodations reaffirm or even exasperate the stereotypes and imposter feeling that she is less than, less capable, less worthy of a seat in law school, in graduate school, and in the workplace? Disability disclosure is hard to do for so many, and even more so when such disclosure can be perceived as reaffirming existing negative stereotypes associated with one’s race, ethnicity, gender identity, or sexual orientation.
Guevara’s story is just one example of the complexity of inequity and inequality at the intersection of multiple minoritized identities as it relates to disclosure or requesting an accommodation. We hope future research in this area will further explore those complexities and amplify their voices. Until then, Guevara offers words of encouragement. “We are enough,” she says.Footnote 43 “Even though one belongs to multiple marginalized identity groups where social treatment makes us feel ‘not good enough,’ there is dignity in defining our self-worth and fighting the stigma, despite our circumstances.”Footnote 44
V. OPERATIONALIZING THE FINDINGS: FOSTERING BELONGING
While more research is needed, Blanck et al.’s current findingsFootnote 45 are important for our understanding of how to address inequity in the legal profession, and how to create a profession that welcomes, supports, and leverages diversity in the pursuit of justice for all people. Often, we find that the lack of such an inclusive environment is self-perpetuating. When minoritized lawyers experience the legal profession in a way that includes discrimination and bias, even in subtle or implicit forms, the result is an unwelcome working environment. Such lawyers are made to feel that they do not belong or are not valued, and as a result, they either leave the profession or do not reach their full potential.
Diversity, equity, and inclusion efforts should strive to facilitate and promote a sense of belonging. As authors Liz Fosslien and Mollie West Duffy explain: “Diversity is having a seat at the table, inclusion is having a voice, and belonging is having that voice be heard.”Footnote 46 A sense of belonging is about feeling valued, feeling comfortable being yourself, and feeling like you are a part of the community. Belonging is about trust and safety. The research is clear: a sense of belonging is crucial for performance, persistence, and wellbeing.Footnote 47 Therefore, explicitly addressing bias and discrimination—rooted in ableism, along with racism, homophobia, and sexism—is a step toward ensuring that talented, diverse professionals have their voices heard. It is a step in facilitating the development of a sense of belonging among groups that for far too long have been marginalized and silenced.
LSAC continues to base its work around the cause of ensuring access and equity in legal education and the law school admission process. No LSAC product, including the LSAT-Flex, is launched without diligent, comprehensive accessibility testing. Additionally, the organization now employs an accessibility coordinator, with a strong passion for disability support, who will lead LSAC’s efforts in these areas.
Our work, and the work of the larger legal community, is just beginning, and Blanck et al. are providing the guideposts necessary to chart our future course toward a world where minoritized individuals feel they truly belong and are valued in the world of law throughout their journey as applicants, as law students, and as professionals in the workplace.
VI. CONCLUSION
Haley Moss, the woman we introduced early in this Comment, knew she belonged in the legal system: she was passionate about helping people, making a difference, writing, and speaking—all things that lawyers do. Armed with that passion, she graduated from the University of Florida, then earned her law degree from the University of Miami School of Law on her way to becoming the state of Florida’s first openly autistic lawyer. She worked for a firm in Florida, then started her own public speaking business, through which she shares her insights on disability and neurodiversity at work. “If more people with disabilities go to law school and begin working in our communities,” she told us, “they’ll be able to create the change we need.”Footnote 48
The stories shared by Moss, Dr. Guevara, and so many other lawyers with disabilities show us what these amazing individuals have to add to our profession. But simply increasing diversity in the field of law is not enough. We must be intentional about inclusion, address inequities, and facilitate a sense of belonging. By fostering a sense of belonging, we can help lawyers with disabilities, LGBTQ+ lawyers, and other underrepresented and minoritized lawyers grow, advance in their careers, and express their authentic selves to provide quality representation for their clients and to increase access to justice for many at the margins of our society.Footnote 49 As Blanck et al. demonstrate, the best path forward to foster that belonging requires addressing inequity we see in the workplace, which is nuanced at the intersection of multiple minoritized identities. This research gives the legal community vital insights into the challenges we face, the complexities inherent in those challenges, and the entrenched discrimination we must overcome to make our profession a place where those with disabilities truly have a voice. Now, we must identify our next steps and act decisively to implement them.
LSAC is proud to partner with our member law schools and broader legal community in this important effort. Our sincere thanks to Blanck et al. for this informative and essential series of studies, and we look forward to future studies that provide even more clarity on issues relating to bias and discrimination not just in the legal workplace, but throughout the entire journey.
