Like the cultural study of food in general, the transformation of the US restaurant trade between 1880 and 1920 will interest some of us more than others. Anyone who wants to know more about this topic, however, will very much enjoy Andrew P. Haley's Turning the Tables: Restaurants and the Rise of the American Middle Class, 1880–1920. Indeed, this, Haley's first book, belongs alongside Rebecca L. Spang's The Invention of the Restaurant: Paris and Modern Gastronomic Culture (2000), John A. Jakle and Keith A. Sculle's Fast Food: Roadside Restaurants in the Automobile Age (1999) and Psyche Williams-Forson's Building Houses out of Chicken Legs: Black Women, Food and Power (2006) in a sort of emerging genre of restaurant histories. Like those monographs, Turning the Tables offers a powerful historical argument, and sets it out in full and lively detail. As this argument unfolds, its two rather epochal stages become increasingly apparent. In the first of these two stages, Haley describes the growing prestige that French cuisine commanded over the course of the Gilded Age. This, Haley suggests, was the period of the “aristocratic restaurant” (7), playgrounds of the superrich, where “an informal system of discrimination embedded in the requirements of cash and culture” effectively excluded anyone “neither rich nor intimately familiar with the intricacies of dining in a French restaurant” (49). Haley traces the rise of such expensive establishments with patience and thoroughness, and lingers in particular on Delmonico's, the famous French restaurant that followed “fashionable New York … uptown,” moving to Fifth Avenue in 1862. Haley shows that Delmonico's reputation for refinement and excellence soon “extended beyond New York,” and that by the “end of the 1870s … restaurants across the country Gallicized their bill of fare, serving French food – or at least dishes with French-sounding names – to a public that was beginning to consider French cuisine a mark of high culture” (25–26). Yet the real momentum of Turning the Tables develops as Haley, coming to his argument's second stage, shows that the American public in fact harboured many different attitudes towards such Gallic restaurants, and that many among the middle classes in particular at this time turned against them and began to seek out establishments of different kinds. And many of the new kinds of venue that attracted their custom, Haley shows, might now seem to us more quintessentially American. The reaction against prestigious French food, after 1900 especially, helped boost cafeterias and steak houses, and encouraged the invention of automats among other “waiterless” establishments. Again, Haley chronicles the second stage of his history, with its reactions against French-language menus and the “daily bribe” of tipping, in full and lively detail. He could, perhaps, have said more in these pages about the fascinating contributions that African American cooks made not just to the leading American versions of classic French cuisine but also to the more affordable and less culinary dishes that grew popular amid the reaction against it. More dialogue surely needs to occur between Turning the Tables and such significant histories as Williams-Forson's Building Houses out of Chicken Legs and Jessica B. Harris's more recent High on the Hog: A Culinary Journey from Africa to America (2011). Such comparative work, however, might begin to take place as a result of this important publication. As it stands, Turning the Tables is essential reading for anyone wanting to know more about the roots of the American passion for dining out.
No CrossRef data available.
