This interesting book by Claire Holleran explores the structure and organization of the retail trade in the city of Rome, providing a much needed general treatment of the topic. H.'s study draws on a varied and rich body of material: literary, epigraphic, iconographic, and archaeological.
After a short introduction setting out the aims of the book and its place in the wider scholarly context, the reader encounters six thematic chapters: ch. 1, on retail trade and the economy, defines the wider social and economic environment in which Rome's retail trade operated; ch. 2 investigates the relationship between retailers and wholesale trade; ch. 3 addresses the form and function of tabernae; ch. 4 discusses markets and fairs; ch. 5 is concerned with street traders, hawkers and pedlars, while ch. 6 focuses on élite consumption. The discussion engages well with current debates in the field of ancient economic history and the author's deliberate choice to organize her study not according to type of commodities, but to focus on the specific retail mechanisms, the institutions, and the different functions they performed, serves very well H.'s aim to contextualize the retail trade within the wider urban economy (262).
Both ch. 1 and ch. 5 use comparative data from other pre-industrial societies: the history of English retail offers a helpful comparison for placing ancient Rome within the larger context of retail history and defining the complexity of Roman distribution networks, while nineteenth-century London and contemporary Lagos are used in the discussion of street trade.
The use of comparative data from very different societies and historical periods stresses a recurrent problem faced by ancient historians: the lacunose state of the evidence. Some might ask whether the chosen parallels are indeed appropriate comparisons for ancient Rome, where normal mechanisms of retail trade co-existed alongside the state distribution system of the annona, the state involvement in the large-scale import of foodstuffs such as olive oil, and the private supply system of large élite households relying on the products of their villa estates. Pre-modern Naples might have been a more fitting parallel than London, considering also the presence of a high number of slaves and freedmen/freedwomen, who were mainly servants in élite households, but who in some cases also played an important rôle as money lenders/providers of small credit (cf. G. Boccadamo, Napoli e l'Islam (2010)). H. is certainly right in drawing attention to street trade, even if sometimes to state the obvious. Literary sources make frequent reference to hawkers and pedlars, which must have been quite common in a metropolis like Rome, providing a source of low income for people at the bottom of the social scale.
By focusing on the general mechanisms of retail trade, H. succeeds also in bringing to the fore issues which can benefit from future research. One such example is the discussion, in ch. 2, on the wharves of the Tiber and associated horrea and facilities, which were not exclusively related with wholesale trade and large-scale distribution within the city. New archaeological investigations can potentially shed new light on the relationship between wholesale and retail trade if other scholars have such a question on their research agenda. The recent large-scale excavation (covering an area of c. 1 ha) carried out in connection with the development of the Nuovo Mercato Testaccio in Rome, in the general area once occupied by the large late Republican horrea, may in fact contribute new important data to this debate.
An aspect of the book not to be undervalued is that, since it analyses and coherently brings together information scattered in a variety of earlier studies, it will also be a useful teaching resource. Examples of clear discussions include the treatment of tabernae, a section that engages more directly with the archaeological evidence, although, because of issues of preservation, much of the data used come from Pompeii rather than Rome; and the discussion of the macella, which, at least in Rome, specialized in luxury foodstuffs for the élite. How assumptions about famous architectural complexes can actually be misguided is exemplified by the case of the ‘Markets of Trajan’ in Rome. This complex is often presented in tourist guides as the ‘first shopping mall’, but in fact it was a complex featuring archives, offices, public halls, possibly commercial units, and even residential buildings (168).
While there were in the city places for retail clearly catering exclusively to élite customers — the margaritarii of the Via Sacra come to mind and Pliny the Elder's moralizing attacks against those who used pearls even on their sandals — élite consumption was full of contradictions. The idea of élite self-sufficiency remained an important tenet even in the imperial period and the marketplace was more often than not seen in a negative way, so that most of the goods for the wealthy were actually acquired through private channels and within the privacy of their households. H. concludes that the retail network was the most important mode of goods distribution in Rome and encompassed distinct but complementary modes of sale. The structure of the retail network was determined by the nature of goods sold and by patterns of consumption; it evolved mostly in an unplanned fashion, in response to the needs of the population, so it was essentially a market-driven phenomenon.
This clearly written book opens the way to future studies on the retail trade in the ancient world. Indeed several questions come to mind while reading this work: how different was Rome from the other cities of the Empire? Did different organizational methods affect the prices of products and the manner (in cash or on credit) in which they were sold? How can the distinction between the migrant and sedentary forms of retail be explained? Although the focus of this book is on the city of Rome, the theoretical framework H. uses offers a conceptual point of reference that will certainly be of great value to studies on similar and related topics in other parts of the Roman world and her work will be an important point of reference in future discussions on ancient urban economies.
