THE NATIONAL DEBT INITIATIVE
Lyndon State College's (LSC) participation in the America's Future Initiative on the U.S. national debt, in association with Public Agenda, began with a grant application for funding to participate. After being awarded funding, as the sole political scientist, I was selected with approval by the administration to attend the September 11 to 13, 2008, opening conference in Washington, DC. Flying into Washington, DC, on September 11 surely was a sign of commitment. At the conference, participants were schooled on the initiative by George Mehaffy of the American Democracy Project, Andrew Yarrow of Public Agenda, the Concord Coalition's Diane Rogers, and Stuart Butler from the Heritage Foundation. As a political scientist, I was well-aware of much of what was presented, but to hear differing perspectives and review the data and presentation materials was an excellent experience.
Because skepticism is at the heart of science, I was careful to examine the strengths and weaknesses of the data. The reliance on extrapolation, which of course is necessary for prediction, was an obvious issue. Moreover, the importance of sifting through the economic ideological viewpoints and their corresponding assumptions remained relevant. As the America's Future Initiative is a normative venture, I perceived it to be necessary to make sure that professionalism and academic integrity did not take a backseat to ideological motivations, no matter how well-meaning. Yet, national debt is an issue as old as the United States and even older, as far back as the Stamp Act of 1763.
We witnessed the ballooning of debt in the 1980s; the reining in of the deficit by the end of the 1990sFootnote 1; and the return of deficit spending in the 2000s as a result of a return to the policies of the 1980s, the bursting dot-com bubble, and September 11, among other issues. Although ideological perspectives vary, the deficit issue is one for which there is a great deal of consensus. Remedies may differ, but any budget that relies on spending more than is being collected is destined to face some sort of reckoning in the long haul. Needless to say, this issue must be taken seriously, and efforts to expand understanding of the problems, challenges, and opportunities before us should be applauded. Because the Initiative sought to meet these ends, I was on board. Our last session on September 13 was an exploration of what we could do back on our individual campuses. I left Washington with ideas percolating in my head and a range of resources at my disposal.
Within two to three weeks, the bottom of the economy fell out as the banking industry collapsed. The bailouts were bad enough, but when banking structures topple, so does the economy (in this case, the U.S. and world economies). The game had changed. Although I would argue that Keynesianism never left us, few would doubt that pump-priming through government intervention was back in force. This situation, of course, meant deficit spending. In the long run, however, especially when considering entitlements and military expenditures, the issue of national debt remained. Accordingly, I soldiered on with the Initiative.
On October 6, 2008, I spoke about the U.S. national debt to a packed house of students and community members at LSC's Alexander Twilight Theater, using many of the materials provided at the conference. At the end of the presentation, I launched a YouTube video contest for presentations about the debt and possible solutions. The prizes were presented on February 3, 2009, in a public forum.Footnote 2 In addition, Diane Rogers and Stuart Butler were willing to come to northeast Vermont to give presentations about the U.S. national debt to the community on March 30, 2009. With the help of Linda Mitchell, chair of LSC's business department, the turnout was solid and included local media (there was even on-air time for the presenters and yours truly). Finally, I set up a time to present the movie IOUSA on campus in the fall.
At the June 2009 conference, I reconnected with my colleagues from the initial conference in September. Many of them presented their findings in sessions as we sought to expand our project to other campuses. We networked, rubbed elbows, and generally spread the word about what we were doing. We discussed the economic developments since September, how they impacted what we were doing, and where we were planning to take the initiative in the coming year. We also spent time socially, most notably at Camden Yards for an Orioles game, thanks to the planning of the American Democracy Project, and strengthened a collegiality that was already surprisingly powerful. We discussed the possibility of collaborating on publishing about our experiences in outlets such as PS.
I left the conference invigorated, ready to write about my experiences and move forward with the debt project. As I contemplated what I could add to a symposium, my mind centered on my experiences with these new colleagues from across the country. This initiative raises issues inherent in normative science—in particular, the debate about the role of political scientists in affecting policy. How does one stay true to the pursuit of evidence-based knowledge in complex systems in the political realm? How can we make our findings understandable, palatable, interesting, and relevant in a field that is so often perceived and portrayed in dichotomous terms? Do we sell our scientific souls in the process? In other words, where does the rubber meet the road? I attempt to address such questions below. Before I turn to this topic, I first reflect on collegiality in our profession in light of my experiences in the debt project.
COLLEGIALITY: THE BENEFITS OF DIFFERENT VENUES
The September start-up meeting, which consisted of participants from eight state institutions, and the American Association of State Colleges and University's (AASCU) annual conference in Baltimore were my first forays into a professional conference with a purely civic focus. My primary experiences prior to these meetings were annual conferences held by organizations of academic professionals. With these encounters as a general reference point, I naturally found myself comparing the two settings. I discussed my observations with others from the September meeting while we were in Baltimore, and I discovered that I was not the only one who was pleasantly surprised by the level of collegiality in projects with a civic motivation. In other words, although both styles of conference belong to the same genus, we are dealing with two different animals. There are structural and motivational differences that go a long way in explaining the variance in collegiality.
I begin by noting that these observations are not a broadside at political science conferences or our field in general. Clearly, political science has seen its share of mentors. For instance, Kristen Renwick Monroe highlighted the contributions of Joseph Cropsey, David Easton, and Lloyd and Susanne Randolph in the October Reference Renwick Monroe2008 issue of PS. In my experience, I benefited greatly from the mentoring of distinguished members of West Virginia University's political science department, from which I received my Ph.D.Footnote 3 Moreover, some years ago, when I e-mailed former APSA president Arend Lijphart to discuss my dissertation research on democratic institutions, I received multiple friendly and helpful replies, for which I was fully appreciative. And to think, I was just a graduate student with whom he had no prior connections.
APSA has also made progress in the drive for inclusion of women in conferences (Gruberg Reference Gruberg2007). There has also been an extension of interest in African American politics in political science journals (McClerking and Philpot Reference McClerking and Philpot2008). Conferences serve as instruments for social networking for hiring (Fowler, Grofman, and Masuoka Reference Fowler, Grofman and Masuoka2007) and intellectual exchange (Carter and Spirling Reference Carter and Spirling2008). On the other hand, political science is a competitive field in which school rankings can affect how academics hire, cite, or view one another (see Fowler, Grofman, and Masuoka Reference Fowler, Grofman and Masuoka2007; Schmidt and Chingos Reference Schmidt and Chingos2007). Political science also exhibits “disciplinary fragmentation,” in which some research towers over other work (see Sigelman Reference Sigelman2006a and Sigelman Reference Sigelman2006b). Rational choice modeling remains powerful, while other approaches may struggle to see the light of day (Carter and Spirling Reference Carter and Spirling2008, 378). Race and gender remain areas that seek greater sunlight.Footnote 4 Hence, hiring and theoretical competition and conflict create a particular atmosphere at academic conferences.
Such was not the case with the America's Future Initiative. Once again, structure and motivations help explain why. To begin, the venture was interdisciplinary, which gave us the opportunity to expand our professional networks. This naturally was the case, as we were brought into the initiative to join forces rather than compete. We were in agreement that the issue was worthy of the effort, even if we had differences over how best to address the problem. We were given freedom of action in how we went about promoting public understanding of the issue. We were provided with resources to accomplish our goals. At the end of the day, the process led to a camaraderie that was evident when we saw each other in Baltimore. We shared an unspoken understanding that we were all serving a part in the operation of a ship that was sailing in an agreed-upon direction.
Academic conferences are invaluable assets to our field and serve us well in our profession as both individuals and a group—for example, through their role in developing beneficial relations with our colleagues. Our shared experiences in the U.S. debt project, however, indicate that political scientists should consider participating in civic engagement projects to augment their professional experiences. Civic engagement is a different can of worms that offers the potential of collegiality in a shared effort that may not be found in other academic venues. More important, the opportunity exists to positively influence the world outside the classroom.
NORMATIVE VENTURES: THEY ARE MORE THAN A COOKBOOK
Normative efforts inherently seek to expose perceived problems and offer potential solutions. Yet, what is a problem to one may be inconsequential to others or, worse, a diversion from more serious and pressing issues. We all have our perspectives about “the way it ought to be,” and they affect our beliefs about what policies should be pursued. The possibility exists that our ideological, professional, or experiential blinders preclude a more encompassing view of the big picture. In other words, normative projects can cloud our professional responsibility towards objectivity.
Normative work may also be unpopular or raise the ire of a vociferous minority. In the case of the former, our work can be marginalized by a populace primed to dismiss it as biased. The latter scenario may put us in the cross-hairs of powerfully motivated narrow interests that may be equally or more challenging to fight, because, as Olson (Reference Olson1971) informs us, such interests regularly win the policy battle. These are but a few of the issues facing the political scientist that must be confronted when trying to effect what we see as positive change.
Making a difference, however, can be the most important work we do. Our efforts are most profound when they affect political behavior at the micro- or macro-level. Few would argue now that Gunner Myrdal's normatively-motivated An American Dilemma (Reference Myrdal1944), which reviewed the condition of pre–Brown v. Board of Education African American life, was a revolutionary moment in the history of social research that greatly contributed to positive change in racial policy in the United States. Although this standard is quite lofty, there is no reason we should not try to aim high when the evidence is present and the need great.
One of the core objectives listed on the APSA Web site is “serving the public, including disseminating research and preparing citizens to be effective citizens and political participants” (American Political Science Association 2009). I believe that the America's Future Initiative meets this objective and has provided a chance to make a positive difference. We are disseminating the data and various interpretations of what could be in store if nothing is done. We are educating students and citizens about our budgetary dilemmas while offering differing solutions to allow them to come to their own evidence-based conclusions. With this knowledge, people can fulfill their obligations toward being “effective citizens and political participants.” In fact, we have found evidence, both quantitative and anecdotal, that we are stoking people's interest in the issue.
Moreover, we have the freedom to present the issue as we see fit. This freedom is particularly necessary in light of the economic developments that we have witnessed since our start-up meeting. The game has changed and we have individually adjusted. Keynes has a place in what we are doing, given that we are seeking to empower citizens rather than indoctrinate them. Perhaps this is why people of varying political stripes who are involved in these efforts are comfortable with what is being done. In other words, we are not asked to be, nor do we act as, shills or ciphers for an ideologically driven, one-size-fits-all viewpoint.
How does the project stand in relation to the questions raised above? We have been able to stay true to the pursuit of evidence-based knowledge. We present hard data, acknowledge the pitfalls of extrapolation, and do not promote homogenous solutions. We do not portray the material in dichotomous terms, and we are quick to say that this is not a liberal or conservative, but an American, issue. Have we succeeded in making the material understandable, palatable, interesting, and relevant? That is a tough question. U.S. governmental budgeting is not as simple as it was in the past (see Wildavsky and Caiden Reference Wildavsky and Caiden1997) and can be a dry issue for many people. However, I would argue that we are making inroads in increasing understanding. At the very least, we are exposing people to information to which they may not have had ready access. In the process, we have made the issue relevant and salient, which in turn contributes to interest in the subject.
Did we sell our scientific souls? On the contrary, the evidence of the need to consider the challenges we face regarding the national debt is overwhelming. Accordingly, the America's Future Initiative is not an exercise in ideological propaganda, and we would not be a part of the initiative if it was. So, where does the rubber meet the road? Where an obvious need exists, based on the evidence, and where there are academics ready to step up and try to make a positive difference. Projects that meet evidence-based criteria provide the opportunity to put an active face on our profession and serve the public.
CONCLUSION
The American Democracy Project and Public Agenda have taken an informational step forward with the America's Future Initiative. These organizations provide resources and an organizational hub for those people interested in getting the word out to the public about the national debt. The project therefore serves a clear function recognized in APSA's core objectives. Moreover, the independence allotted to participating campuses allows for flexibility in the face of changing economic circumstances. The experience, however, has amounted to more than just addressing such critical instrumental functions and has provided an excellent opportunity for professional development.
Normative ventures such as the U.S. debt project offer scholars the chance to develop collegial ties in a manner that is different from and complementary to academic conferences. Working toward a shared goal helps create bonds among participants in a style that augments networks developed at the naturally more competitive academic conferences. In fact, the process has brought people of competing perspectives together in consensual recognition of the significance of the issue. In other words, we did not have to confine ourselves to homogenous viewpoints to fulfill our civic duties in concert.
Scholars may correctly be apprehensive about tying their names to agenda-setting activities. Speaking out with certainty in uncertain realms can belie the scientific norm of objectivity. On the other hand, if we sequester ourselves in academic ivory towers, we fail to apply our knowledge toward addressing real-world problems. The evidence in this case indicates where the scientific rubber meets the political road. The rubber and road meet when one can maintain academic integrity while providing a public service.
