This published dissertation on Mexico is, alas, wrought in the post-modernist style that passes in some quarters as cutting-edge anthropology: fuzzy thinking wrapped in pretentiously opaque language. One has to wade through some 60 pages of ‘multivocality of heritage’ (p. 12), ‘ethnographic interlocutors’ (p. 19, informants?), ‘trialectic of space’ (p. 32), ‘multiple spatial and spatializing planes’ (p. 33), ‘territorialization of heritage’ (p. 47), ‘monumentalized past’ (p. 36), and, of course, the ‘monumental ambivalence’ of the book's title, to discover that this unwitting parody of Foucault merely obfuscates Breglia's interesting subject and lively ethnography.
Chapters three to five, that contain the data, tell an engaging story in relatively fluent prose. Breglia deals with two intertwined themes: first, the privatisation of archeological patrimony; and, second, the varied and often conflicting views of heritage that local Mayans, archaeologists, and Mexican authorities and laws hold of archaeological sites. For the latter, she chooses two in different parts of Yucatán: one, world famous, Chichén Itzá, and the other, Chunchucmil, almost totally unknown (including to this reviewer). Not surprisingly, most of the data and the richest ethnography are contained in the two chapters on Chichén Itzá.
Chapter three provides an interesting historical account of the privatisation of the Chichén Itzá site, involving several notorious North American individuals and institutions, such as Edward Thompson, Sylvanus Morley, Harvard's Peabody Museum and the Carnegie Institution of Washington. Chapter four, the strongest chapter, is a vignette of the group of 36 custodians of Chichén Itzá. With a history of three or four generations of working in or around the ruins, local Mayas have formed a complex, lucrative and monopolistic relationship with the Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia. INAH supervises, maintains, protects, develops and administers some 110,000 historical monuments, 29,000 official archaeological zones, and hundreds of museums. Chichén Itzá, Mexico's premier Mayalandia, is now visited each year by a million or so day-trippers from the resort of Cancun, New Age cultists from California, and countless other tourists. Local Mayas naturally have a complex view of the site's monumental heritage, and, not least, of the monumental opportunities it offers the near-by Maya community of Pisté to fleece the tourists. The latter, however, are curiously absent from Breglia's account, but hilariously present in a lovely 1997 documentary film by Jeff Himpele and Quetzil Castañeda.
By contrast, in Chunchucmil, where excavations only began in the 1990s, local Mayas have little or no concept of an archaeological heritage. To them, heritage means the henequen haciendas from which the Mexican Revolution freed them, and the ejido system under which they now work the land. Vague hopes of developing a tourist industry around the new site mean little to them, and rightly so, as even such superb Mexican ruins as Ek Balam and Cacaxtlan receive only a sprinkling of visitors.
Unfortunately two concluding chapters lapse again into the turgid deconstructo-babble of ‘territorializing machinations of heritage’ and ‘overlapping territories of multiple discursive regimes.’ Mercifully, they are brief.
