On September 8, 2007, the Heidelberg Institut für Kunst und Recht (IFKUR, Institute of Art and Law)Footnote 1 hosted guests interested in art and law from all over Germany, Switzerland, and Austria. More than 100 participants attended the institute's First Heidelberg Day of Art Law on “The Artist's Law—The Art of Law (Des Künstlers Rechte—Die Kunst des Rechts).” The conference was held in the Heidelberg Town Hall's ballroom. The first part of the day was dedicated to various legal aspects of the freedom of art, and the second part was devoted to legal challenges concerning the exploitation of artistic works.
The first lecturer, Achim Krämer (barrister at the Bundesgerichtshof, the German Federal Court for Civil and Criminal Matters, Karlsruhe) elaborated on freedom of art versus personality rights in the case of Esra decided by the German Bundesgerichtshof in 2005.Footnote 2 In this case the plaintiffs, a former girlfriend of the author and her mother, try to stop the publication of the novel Esra,Footnote 3 written by Maxim Biller (born 1960). In this novel the author writes about an intimate relationship between the title figure of the novel, Esra, and the first-person narrator, an author called Adam. The plaintiffs complain that the novel violates their personality rights, because the characters of the novel are too closely and too obviously related to their own—the plaintiffs'—lives. The German Federal Court decided in favor of the plaintiffs. The court held that the plaintiffs' constitutionally guaranteed personality right (article 2 [1] Grundgesetz—the German Federal Constitution) prevailed over the freedom of art (article 5 [3] Grundgesetz). The German Federal Constitutional Court confirmed this judgment.Footnote 4
Attorney-at-Law Peter Raue (Hogan & Hartson Raue, Berlin) gave a lecture on another aspect of conflict: freedom of art versus personality rights, referring to the case Nur eine Tablette (Just One Pill) decided by the Oberlandesgericht (Court of Appal) Hamburg in 2007.Footnote 5 The case involves a dispute over a controversial German television filmFootnote 6 about the 1960s thalidomide birth-defect scandal. Nur eine Tablette is a dramatization of the true story of a German lawyer who, after his child was born deformed as a result of the drug Contergan, fought a case against the pharmaceutical industry (Grünenthal), representing numerous plaintiffs. The film has been at the center of a lawsuit that threatened to restrict producers' rights to change even minor details in bringing factual stories to the screen. The Court of Appeal of Hamburg permitted the television show on November 7–8, 2007. A third aspect of possible conflicts concerning the freedom of art was outlined by Peter Michael Lynen (chancellor of the Kunstakademie Düsseldorf, director of the Centre of International Art Management, CIAM, Cologne). He reported a conflict that arose on the occasion of the exhibition of a work of art created by a student of the Kunstakademie Düsseldorf. When the academy exhibited the work—a mosque surrounded by missiles instead of minarets—the academy, as well as the artist were faced with anonymous threats by people who felt the work was offensive. In the ensuing discussion, Kurt Siehr (Max-Planck-Institute, Hamburg) pointed out the problem of a work of art situated in one country violating the laws and/or ethical standards of another country. This, in turn, could possibly lead to situations wherein foreign legal standards might have to be taken into consideration in deciding a local case.
A lecture on the freedom of architectural work versus the protection of cultural assets was presented by Gerte Reichelt (Ludwig Boltzmann Institute of European Law, Vienna), referring to the case of the Dresdner Waldschlösschenbrücke.Footnote 7 Gerte Reichelt elaborated on the question of the extent to which requirements of the UNESCO World Heritage Convention 1972Footnote 8 must be considered by applying provisions of national laws. She specifically referred to the effect of European legislation on national laws—especially of articles 3, 10, and 151 European Community Treaty; articles 6 and 7 of the 1972 UNESCO convention; and the role of the ordre public in national legal systems. In the discussion Siehr posed the following question: If state-aided financial support is granted for public works (e.g., as in this case, the construction of a bridge), to what extent must the UNESCO convention of 1972 be taken into account? This raises the question as to what extent provisions of international conventions can indirectly affect national administrative actions.
Joachim von Ungern-Sternberg (judge at the Bundesgerichtshof, the German Federal Court, Karlsruhe) gave the lecture, “Moral Rights versus Ownership—The Architect and the Client,” an impressive overview of the legal conflicts that arise in connection with architectural works.Footnote 9 Disputes about alterations of buildings that may lead to a derogation of the architectural work remain a major problem. Ensuing discussion raised issues concerning different kinds of buildings, such as museums and liturgical buildings.
The second half of the day began with a speech by Erik Jayme (Heidelberg) on the case of Motezuma decided by the Oberlandesgericht (Court of Appeal) Düsseldorf in 2007.Footnote 10 The plaintiffs, a well-known choir and music society, the Sing-Akademie, took action against the performance of Motezuma, an opera written by Antonio Vivaldi (1678–1741). The Sing-Akademie claims rights to the score of Motezuma, relying on § 71 Urheberrechtsgesetz (the German Copyright Act), which provides that the rights to a work not published during the copyright term belong to the person arranging the first publication of the work. The composition seems to have been lost for a very long time. In 2002 a facsimile of the opera was found in the archives of the Sing-Akademie. Motezuma was first staged in 1733. Despite the staging, music of Motezuma might not have been published at that time and not until the Sing-Akademie issued it on the Internet. The court held that the Sing-Akademie could not rely on § 71 Urheberrechtsgesetz, because it could not prove that the work had not been published before.
Attorney-at-Law Astrid Müller-Katzenburg, LL.M. (Berlin) talked about the droit de suite and gave an outline of the current issues in legislature and jurisdiction. She described the process of European harmonization of the droit de suite and pointed out the effect of that harmonization on the art market. Astrid Müller-Katzenburg gave examples illustrating the problems of determining the applicable law in international art sales. Additionally, she elaborated on the role of collecting societies and their influence on the regulation of the art market.
In the conference's final speech, Thomas Dreier (Karlsruhe) discussed the right of exploitation of art works, outlining the current legal situation and giving an overview of possible future developments. He brought up aspects of the sociology of law and the changing role of artists in society. Dreier gave a perspective of future developments of European law concerning copyright issues, referring to the function of collecting societies and new forms of exploitation of artistic works taking into account the concepts of “copyleft,” “open content,” and “creative commons.”
The conference papers of the First Heidelberg Day of Art Law have been published by the Nomos Verlag.Footnote 11 The Second Heidelberg Day of Art Law took place on September 6, 2008.
