Scholarship on various aspects of Muslim diasporas is increasing, generating conferences, monographs, papers, and edited volumes. Haideh Moghissi's edited volume Muslim Diaspora: Gender, Culture and Identity stands out as an interesting and useful contribution to the field. The book focuses primarily on Muslim immigrants from the Middle East (and Pakistan) who are living in Europe or North America, and many articles address post-9/11 trends in intercommunal relations. It differs from similar works because it steps back and looks at Muslim diasporas generally with several conceptual articles. It balances these conceptual articles with detailed case studies using a variety of approaches and addressing a wide range of topics.
Moghissi asks several major questions at the outset of the book: What aspects of diaspora life increase or decrease individuals' ties to their family's place of origin? Through which processes are transnational identities developed and deployed? How do forces of globalization interact with trends toward increasing ethnic and cultural identities? The book proceeds on the premises that group identity is “constructed” through experience in the host country and that these experiences can lead to more explicitly Islamic identities. Moghissi also argues that Islamic culture is heterogeneous and that contemporary Islamic identities are often inherently political and focused on “resistance” instead of merely shared culture (pp. xiv– xvii).
Three articles approach diasporas on a conceptual level. Denise Helly analyzes diaspora from the ground up, tracing its roots through history. She notes that for a group to be diasporic, it must not only have a memory of victimization but also internal institutions to maintain a sense of community. She argues that diasporic communities can be formed without any type of reference to a “real” or “imaginary” homeland. Multiple authors (Rahnema, Mojab, Tétreault, Afshar et al., and Hojabri) echo her emphasis on some type of collective experience that unites (or in Tétreault's case divides) the community, perhaps because they fear it happening again or because they are organized enough to keep its memory alive. Although she does not explicitly make the connection, the potential for diasporas united by an identity other than shared origin and the importance of the threat of violence in maintaining group cohesiveness have added significance for Muslim diasporas after the 9/11 and 7 July 2005 London terrorist attacks.
Mark Goodman critiques diaspora-theory views of ethnicity and identity, especially literature on hybridized identities, some of which focuses on self-imposed exile, during which an individual forges a new identity. He argues that hybridity and diasporic identity cannot be separated from power dynamics because identities are forged through both passive and active processes and involve interaction with the surrounding population. Furthermore, many diasporic individuals do not choose to relocate but are forced to by economic or political situations.
Shahrzad Mojab's article on the Kurdish diaspora begins with a critique of diasporic theories in light of the Kurdish case. She argues that analyses of transnational political and economic structures do not devote enough attention to gender and do not incorporate political or economic factors into explanations of population movement. She concludes that differences between East and West are artificially exaggerated (especially with respect to feminism, which is usually classed as Western), states play important roles in diasporic movements (despite postmodernist theories), transnationalism is limited as an analytical construct (the Kurds are still divided among four states), and the Kurdish diaspora is heterogeneous and should not be essentialized as strictly “Islamic.”
Three themes recur throughout many of the book's case studies: power dynamics that create violence and inequality, the contestation of memory, and issues confronting women. Regarding violence, Ezat Mossallanejad discusses the tremendous psychological impact of torture techniques—specifically stoning and holy rape—currently justified in Iran with references to Islam, an impact that continues well into life in the Canadian diaspora. Saeed Rahnema's well-documented study also discusses Canadian Muslims, arguing that despite being well educated and tolerated, unemployment and exclusion from certain social circles is high, which leads to an increase in Islamism. However, attempts to increase group rights under Canadian multiculturalism assume incorrectly that Canadian Muslims are a heterogeneous group. Furthermore, privileging conservative leaders threatens the universal human rights guaranteed to women and minority groups within the community. Reza Baraheni offers a postmodern critique of how Abrahamic scriptures are read, arguing that many Middle Easterners write from an exilic perspective.
Mary Ann Tétreault deftly describes conflict over memory in postwar Kuwait between those who stayed during the Iraqi invasion and those who went into exile. She argues that, despite factual inaccuracies, exile version of the occupation dominated reconstruction efforts. Hammed Shahidian argues that the Iranian diaspora remains voiceless inside Iran because both exiles and their lifestyles are routinely condemned in order to convince Iranians to stay in or return to Iran. Aylin Akpinar discusses various secular and religious identities among Turkish university students, tracing a shift from radical to more moderate forms of Islam among observant Turkish youth.
Marie McAndrew's article begins the final section, which focuses mainly on women, with an excellent theoretical overview of the issues surrounding wearing hijab in public schools in the West. She critiques three common approaches to this issue in media and scholarship: “cultural essentialism,” which classes argument as Islamophobia; “heterocentrist constructivism,” which declares gender equality more important than religious tolerance; and “individualistic constructivism,” which emphasizes an individual's right to chose over collective preferences. She argues that the focus should be on achieving a context-specific balance between pluralism, equality, and individual freedoms. An interesting, if slightly unfocused, contribution from Haleh Afshar, Rob Aitken, and Myfanwy Franks discusses Muslim women of Pakistani descent in Bradford (United Kingdom), arguing that they are frequently (and visibly) stuck between the demands of their host country and their community. Their conclusion argues that the “feminist” identities of these Muslim women emphasize their faith over citizenship and ethnic origin; their bond as Muslim women living in the British diaspora enables them to reject interpretations of Islam advocated by their parents or ethnic group.
Fataneh Farahani argues that Iranian ideals regarding virginity severely restricted the childhood activities and goals of Iranian women now living in Sweden. Her persuasive narrative vividly explains why such ideals are medically misguided and the myriad ways in which their impact on women's lives extends beyond the realm of sexual experiences. A fascinating and well-written contribution from Mary Elaine Hegland discusses the strategies—both constructive and destructive—used by older Iranians who moved to California to be near children and grandchildren yet have difficulty adjusting to the new, fast-paced lifestyles and mores of their offspring. Finally, Afsaneh Hojabri's study looks at the diasporic experiences of ten women from Pakistan, Iran, Afghanistan, and Palestine living in Canada. She argues that the Muslim diaspora is heterogeneous, especially with respect to religion, ethnic group, and degree of assimilation, yet all of the women had been treated as if they belonged to a monolithic Muslim diaspora.
Gender is an explicit focus of the book. However, although some contributions either do not focus primarily on gender (Helly, Baraheni, Goodman) or discuss both genders in detail (Rahnema, Tétreault, Shahidian, Hegland, Akpinar), almost half of the articles discuss only or primarily women's issues (Mossallanejad, Mojab, McAndrew, Afshar et al., Farahani, and Hojabri). It would have been interesting to see more explicit discussion of masculinity and male experiences in Muslim diasporas.
The book notably focuses on several countries and aspects of diasporic life that are not normally covered in literature on diaspora. However, a large number of contributions discuss either Iranians or Muslim experiences in Canada. Of the eight contributions focusing on particular origin countries, half (Mossallanejad, Shahidian, Farahani, Hegland) discuss Iranians and the remaining four discuss Pakistanis (Afshar et al.), Kurds (Mojab), Kuwaitis (Tétreault), and Turks (Akpinar). Of the six articles focusing on one main host country, half deal with Canada (Rahnema, Mossallanejad, Hojabri) and the other three deal with the United States (Hegland), the United Kingdom (Afshar), and Sweden (Farahani). The contributions on Iranians and Canada are all excellent; however, their large number inevitably decreases the overall spread of the book.
Finally, three of the contributions—Baraheni's discussion of scriptural reading practices, Akpinar's discussion of Islam in Turkey, and Farahani's work with Iranian women living in Sweden—do not directly address the themes set out at the beginning of the book. Baraheni's work explicitly discusses only the hybridized identities of writers living in the Middle East. Akpinar does argue that Turkish religious politics affect the lives of diasporic Turks, but most of her article (and apparently all of her fieldwork) addresses students studying in Istanbul or Ankara. Farahani's excellent article focuses on the childhood experiences of Iranian women living in Sweden; although diasporic life undoubtedly facilitates the telling of this story, the women's testimony primarily addresses their childhood experiences in Iran with little explicit consideration of how these experiences have affected their lives in Sweden. These contributions are all interesting contributions to the field, however.
These criticisms should not distract potential readers from the many merits of the book. Muslim Diaspora takes a wider, more comprehensive view than many other books on this topic and is well organized and executed. Of most importance, Moghissi has assembled a fine collection, some theoretical and others based on case studies, that gives readers a wider perspective not only on the specificities of various communities but also on the overall phenomenon of Muslim diaspora. This book is an essential read for anyone interested in the topic and will make a useful addition to library collections dealing with gender, religion, and culture in Muslim communities in Europe and North America.
