No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 August 2004
Samir Khalaf's Civil and Uncivil Violence in Lebanon is a study in the sociology and history of communal violence and how political conflicts in Lebanon have deteriorated into protracted and visceral violence. However, on another equally profound level, this is a book that seeks to imagine and narrate a Lebanon that goes beyond the contradictory clichés of its past as either Switzerland of the Middle East, or a failed and inherently dysfunctional nation. On both levels, Khalaf succeeds in crafting a narrative that is engaging, scholarly—and, perhaps most refreshing—hopeful.
Samir Khalaf's Civil and Uncivil Violence in Lebanon is a study in the sociology and history of communal violence and how political conflicts in Lebanon have deteriorated into protracted and visceral violence. However, on another equally profound level, this is a book that seeks to imagine and narrate a Lebanon that goes beyond the contradictory clichés of its past as either Switzerland of the Middle East, or a failed and inherently dysfunctional nation. On both levels, Khalaf succeeds in crafting a narrative that is engaging, scholarly—and, perhaps most refreshing—hopeful.
As an eminent Lebanese sociologist, Khalaf seeks to answer a question that has puzzled many observers of Lebanon—namely, why does Lebanon appear as the Janus of nations, a seemingly prosperous and peaceful multicultural society that suddenly and collectively descends into long episodes of wanton killing, leaving behind a trail of woe and destruction? Most previous observers have tended to emphasize one of two answers. Some have argued that Lebanon as a polity and social entity is untenable because it is built on deeply divisive socio-economic inequalities and cultural chasms. Others contend that external factors (Ottoman–European rivalry, the Cold War, the Arab–Israeli conflicts, etc.) rather than internal structural problems are to blame for each and every one of the three major episodes of communal violence.
Khalaf sees the answer as a combination of both factors. In the first two chapters of the book, he explores these themes in detail. He argues that in the past 150 years, communal identities in Lebanon have remained a critical part of the socio-cultural map of the country. At historical moments when sectarian lines were beginning to fade in the face of emerging socio-economic solidarities, traditional leaders (fearing loss of their power) and regional powers (seeking greater power in the Mountain) would intervene to subvert such developments and to divert political tensions into communal conflict. To illustrate this point, Khalaf examines—in Chapters 4–7—the civil war of 1860, the conflict in 1858, and the most destructive of all episodes of communal violence, the civil war of 1975–90. In each of these instances we find that the confluence of external rivalries with internal tensions unleashes inter-communal conflict.
In 1860, for example, the external factor was the contention between the Ottoman Empire and various European powers (most notably, the French and the British) over who would control the Eastern Mediterranean. Internally, the Maronite church sought to exercise greater influence over the affairs of Maronite peasants, and a new mercantile class sought to extend its economic control from the coastal cities to the mountain villages. Both trends clashed with the entrenched interests of existing Maronite and Druze overlords, who sought to safeguard their political, social, and economic power. The socio-economic discontent of the peasantry (particularly in the Maronite region of Lebanon) was encouraged by church and merchants, which gave it a sectarian ideological bent. The lords of the mountain sought to undermine the claims of the peasantry by focusing on the sectarian aspects of the revolt of 1860 and by presenting themselves as the champions of a counter-sectarian claim. Ottoman and European officials only exacerbated the conflict by providing weapons and support for one side or the other in the conflict and by emphasizing the “primordial” sectarian identities. In this manner, what started as a legitimate socio-economic grievance that could have created a new multi-religious social movement was diverted into senseless violence that only intensified sectarian divisions. The same story was repeated, with variations in historical actors and intensities, in 1958 and 1975.
But Khalaf extends his explanation beyond this thesis (which others, most notably Ussama Makdisi in his highly original study of the 1860 conflict, have articulated before) to argue that a third factor accounts for the viciousness of communal violence. In a very insightful chapter (chap. 3), he argues that violence creates its own momentum. It is not only that killing engenders the desire for revenge, or that the availability of lethal weapons makes internecine wars all the more destructive. Rather, and but for the most pathological of individuals, killing requires a “legitimate” reason that exonerates the killer and the act itself. In Lebanon, religious and communal ideology played a critical role in legitimizing the violence and thus in perpetuating it. Combatants were told that the massacres they committed were acceptable either because God was on their side or because the other side was “fascist” or “foreign.” In all of these cases, the history of communal tensions and suspicions helped create an insular and circular logic in which such stereotypes acquired coherence and meaning. This legitimating language de-humanized the “other” in the conflict and quickly turned neighbor, co-worker, relative, or simply fellow citizen into an alien whose very existence threatened one's own existence. Thus, violence descended from “just war” into wanton killing.
Khalaf concludes this insightful book by leaving behind the past to cast a hopeful personal and scholarly look at the future of Lebanon. He argues that today in Lebanon there are three competing reactions to the post-war traumas, reconstruction, and embroilment in globalization. The first reaction is one perfected during the 1975–90 civil war, which entails a numbness that deadens any reaction to the flurry of problems or conflicts swirling around the country. This cultural and social inertia allows people to retreat from what they perceive as overwhelming and seemingly chronic problems. The second response has been a “flight” into hyper-commercialized existence, where the woes of the present and uncertainties of the future are drowned out in a kitsch reproduction that romanticizes bygone eras without engaging that history in a meaningful and honest dialogue. The last and most promising reaction has been new forms of collective action that range from new urban planning and environmental politics to the establishment of artistic neighborhoods. These seemingly innocuous movements in fact have the capacity to transcend painfully divisive memories by creating new spaces for inter-communal action and existence at the same time that they draw on elements of the past. By focusing, for example, on the fact that quarries are devastating the Lebanese (and not Christian or Muslim, rich or poor) environment, “green” organizations create structures and mechanisms for the creation of a civil society in Lebanon and for mobilizing citizens to act outside the rubric of the “state” and the violent “street.” Ultimately, Khalaf argues that it is this new type of civil society that holds the potential to create a new Lebanon that draws on the richness of multi-cultural society even as it transcends parochial communal boundaries. In that sense, Lebanon would stand in clear juxtaposition to a Middle East descending in its totality into the morass of tribalism.
This whirlwind of a book gathers between its pages a most cogent discussion of the pitfalls and promises of Lebanon as a metaphor for new civil society. Its reliance on some older sources and its reintroduction of some ideas discussed elsewhere does not in the least detract from its breadth and depth. For that reason, this book should be read by those seeking to learn more not only about Lebanon but also about the Middle East and communal violence in general.