Every second summer in odd-numbered years sees the publication of selected essays from the previous biannual meeting of the British Legal History Conference (BLHC). The series, including the volume reviewed here from the twentieth meeting in 2011 in Cambridge, consistently offers some of the best new work in legal history, as well as strong evidence that the field is thriving. This was not always the case. When the BLHC first met in 1972, there was little in the way of an institutional structure for British legal history. The field lacked regular meetings, dedicated journals, and guidance or jobs for juniors. All this was to change, heralded and spurred on by Jenkins' 1971 invitation to the first meeting of what became the BLHC, the first meeting devoted to legal history since April 1913.
This volume stems from the twentieth occasion of that conference and its fortieth anniversary, and inevitably it embodies a degree of nostalgia, pride, and regret for absent friends (about which more later). But the occasion of a major anniversary permits reflection on the value of the BLHC series. Growing from ten papers, all of which were published, in 1971 to eighty-one speakers and fifteen published papers in 2011, the BLHC has remained a leading forum for legal history. A succession of editors and conveners has continued to invite a mix of senior and junior scholars, not only university-based scholars, but also archivists, independent scholars, and, occasionally, practitioners and judges. The conference has continued to feature both repeaters and rookies, including, occasionally, recent graduates and midcareer newcomers to legal history. The largest single portion of the presenters have come from the United Kingdom, with many from the United States, but the Commonwealth and Western Europe have always been generously represented as well, and from the early days there were speakers from Nigeria (the fourth BLHC), and Cold War Poland and the former Soviet Union (in the seventh and ninth BLHCs respectively).
As for content, the essays have ranged from broad syntheses to timely interventions on current debates, to concise summaries by leading figures and near-manifestos, from openly speculative papers to pointillist works. Papers have examined seemingly every legal history topic and from every angle: biography; prosopography; historical sociology; anthropology; critical theory; and institutional, constitutional, social, literary, and intellectual history, relying not only on legal and historical skills but also on paleographic, linguistic, econometric, and archival tools, to give an incomplete list. Papers have addressed Africa, Australia and New Zealand, North America and the Caribbean, Scandinavia, and Poland, but tilt heavily toward Britain and Ireland, and cover every period from Anglo-Saxon to modern with a heavy focus on the twelfth through the nineteenth centuries. Uniting all this is not only a common reliance on legal sources and questions, but a core area of geographic coverage and chronology, a loosely enforced set of values and vocabulary that respects archival work and is skeptical of grand theory, a shared standard of excellence, and an indifference to the political implication of good work; no “originalism” will be found here and little talk of history being prepared for a judicial or legislative hearing.
The 2011 volume has a theme of “law and legal process,” meaning “all aspects of the interactions between legal practice and legal doctrine” (xi). Capacious but coherent, the theme includes not only a sweeping essay addressing 1500 years from classical Roman lawyers to Milsom (Charles Donahue) but also studies of a single case (Clive Holmes), doctrine (Gwen Seabourne, Susanne Jenks, James Oldham, Phil Handler), prosecuting authority (Henry Mares), administrative innovation (Paul Brand), underlying rationale (David Ibbetson), and court (Neil Jones), from royal justices and clerks in the early common law (Brand) to humble northern solicitors' offices five centuries later (Baker). And by including essays that echo one another, the theme allows a reader to track similar problems and practices in different courts or centuries: arbitration in the fifteenth and nineteenth centuries (Musson and Michael Lobban, the former recalling papers by Carole Rawcliffe in the fifth BLHC and Edward Powell), litigation before different courts in the sixteenth (Jones and Ibbetson) or eighteenth century (Swain and Oldham) or for similar theories in different centuries (Ibbetson and Swain), and the complex judicial responses to women and the special strategies open to them and their opponents in the fourteenth and eighteenth centuries (Seabourne and Oldham, the former recalling papers by J.B. Post in the second BLHC and Sue Sheridan Walker in the eighth, tenth, and fourteenth). Other themes relevant to practice more than doctrine also intriguingly recur throughout the volume, such as judges from different courts consulting and coordinating with each other or talking to jurors and arbitrators.
To this reviewer's taste, the most remarkable essay is that by Sir John Baker. This may seem to be a safe reaction, as Baker is commonly reckoned the pre-eminent legal historian of the past generation. (It is a measure of his longevity and excellence that the most significant essay in the first BLHC volume 40 years ago was also by Baker.) But he has been relatively sparing in publishing in BLHC volumes over the years—although insiders know that he has helped organize every conference—and his essay here at first glance seems modest, concerning not grand doctrine, but rather country practitioners. Behind his discussion is a new and fruitful source of evidence, the value of which Baker is the first to see; namely, business correspondence between local attorneys and the London lawyers and clerks whom they retained as agents. Revenue legislation of 1785 made it prohibitively expensive for attorneys to practice infrequently in London, but it seems to have been common well before that for provincial attorneys to maintain agents, with whom they communicated regularly. There must once have been mountains of such letters between agents and provincial advisors and even clients, but they have rarely been examined and more often must have been discarded. Not only is Baker the first scholar to use these letters for legal as opposed to local history; he also acted as steward and preservationist, saving a few collections from being sold to philatelists or souvenir hunters. The correspondence can open a vista onto how long-term litigation allies shared their candid assessment of doctrine, strategy, motive, and personnel. Baker also found in the letters a few more unreported cases. One expects no less from the scholar who brought fifteenth century readings and moots (with Thorne) and early sixteenth century judicial notebooks to scholarly notice early in his career.
This innovative essay should not obscure the other superb essays in this volume. Donahue, for example, starts slowly, as if needing to address largely American concerns about Holmes and positivism, but then delivers a masterful survey of the relationship between proof and evidence on the one hand and doctrine on the other. Brand, the most frequent contributor to the BLHC series since 1975, offers another formidably researched study on perhaps the most challenging area in legal history: the first century of the common law, the focus of Maitland and Milsom. Brand explores who in the royal bureaucracy “grew” the common law, and he answers by showing that justices as well as clerks devised and issued new writs, both before and after statutory authorization. Also of keen interest is Jenks' essay on the immunities that common law courts gave their officials and litigants. Aside from Donahue, Jenks is the only first-time contributor to the BLHC series, and her participation is welcome because of her special knowledge of the plea rolls gleaned through her work on Robert Palmer's Anglo-American legal tradition project, which so many of the other chapters also use. Her description of the scope and extent of immunity is persuasive, although her speculation that its roots lie in the practice of Exchequer (for litigants) and Parliament (for officials) must await further evidence.
For the postmedieval period, Neil Jones offers another in his series of articles on equity in the sixteenth century, focusing here on the interaction between litigation in Chancery and in other courts. Taken together, his essays, commencing in the twelfth BLHC, offer a detailed picture of equity doctrine, jurisdiction, and practice in the sixteenth century, a bookend to the work done on the seventeenth by David Yale, Henry Horwitz, and, more recently, Mike McNair. Jones leaves a reader eager to learn more about secret, illegal Marian trusts (104, 115, 116). Ibbetson and Oldham also offer papers that are part of larger projects into early modern private law and Lord Mansfield and his contemporaries. Both essays are, as usual, strongly supported, with Ibbetson drawing on large databases (as do Jones and Mares for other courts) over time to show the shifting receptivity of the common law courts and the remedies in contract, including costs and fees, given to successful Elizabethan litigants. Phil Handler adds to his work on nineteenth century criminal law with a chapter showing that legal development was motivated by Victorian judges' desire for severity and certainty but was shaped in practice by procedural and legislative changes. Like Martin Wiener (in the eighth BLHC), Handler points to changing middle class and elite views of crime and juries, but a significant conclusion is the underlying stability of popular notions, because by focusing on intoxication in homicide and nonfatal assault, Handler reveals an area in which jurors consistently tended to mitigate before and after the great change in criminal process. Last is Lobban's study of arbitration in three huge bankruptcies from the 1860s, in which he displays not only legal and corporate sophistication, but also the storytelling skill of a leading financial journalist, no easy task where even the simplest of the three involved forty-nine chancery claims, eighty-four common law suits, and thirty-two claims to the arbitrator (294–95).
Anyone who has ever attended a BLHC meeting or even wondered about the flourishing state of legal history will feel indebted to Patrick Polden's essay, which surely must be seen as the “bonus track” on this album. Polden is a longtime attendee of the conference and has published fine papers (in the twelfth and nineteenth BLHC volumes). Here, he reviews the institutional history, if that is not too incongruous a term for a congery that has resolutely resisted an office, mailing address, officers, incorporated status, or an endowment, but whose significance is that the story of legal history in the United Kingdom today is firmly intertwined with its history. Polden goes through speakers, organizers, and attendees by age, gender, geographic origin, and institutional affiliation, and surveys the topics that have been presented, but like a village elder retelling stories of the ancestors around a campfire, he also recalls the highlights and missteps of previous conferences and volumes. With a light hand and humorous touches, he writes of the spirit of founder Dafydd Jenkins, the resolute presentations of barrister Martin Burr (329, 331), the contentious interventions of the curmudgeonly Sirs Geoffrey Elton and James Holt and Mr John Cooper (322, 324, 326), and the peerless raconteur Brian Simpson (324, 330). A reader is reminded of a tell-all book in politics or Hollywood where buyers rush to see themselves in the index, but it is all written with a gentle spirit. As Polden concludes, the most significant points were often made not during presentations or question time, but in informal discussions continued in the bar (334). In this as in so much else, Polden's generous description is exactly right.
The complaints to be made about this volume are tiny. This review began by mentioning that the BLHC volumes come out like clockwork every 2 years. For a few years that did not occur, and Cambridge University Press is to be commended for taking on the often-unwanted task of publishing a conference volume. Presumably to promote sales by making each volume seem a unified study rather than disparate essays, the publisher has removed from the subtitle or title page any mention that the book stems from a conference, upsetting the practice of 30 years and perhaps misleading readers. It also chose not to revive the practice that earlier publishers of BLHC proceedings (the University of Wales, the British Academy, the much-mourned Hambledon Press, and Hart Publishing), generally followed of listing all conference papers not printed in the volume and, if known, where those papers had been published. Such a list requires no more than two or three pages, but its omission makes the recent Cambridge volumes, including the book under review, slightly less useful. And notwithstanding the need for a volume of manageable length, it is a regret that the editors were constrained to exclude anything relating to Scotland, Wales, and Ireland, which were often included in prior BLHC volumes. With these small exceptions, this book is a worthy addition to what is arguably the leading legal history publication series.
