In India, during the first half of the twentieth century—the period at the heart of Abha Sur's ground-breaking academic history, Dispersed Radiance—Indian scientists made some remarkable scientific discoveries. They included the physicist and biologist Jagadish Chandra Bose, the mathematician and physicist Satyendra Nath Bose, the physicist C. V. Raman and the astrophysicist Meghnad Saha. All of them were internationally published, recognised and honoured; Raman won India's first Nobel prize in science (in 1930), while S. N. Bose gave his name to Bose-Einstein statistics and the boson, a class of subatomic particles, which includes the photon. In addition, India produced a great mathematician, Srinivasa Ramanujan, the first Indian to be made a fellow of the Royal Society purely for his intellectual achievement, whose astonishing career, beginning as a humble clerk in Chennai, has been the subject of a compelling biography (The Man Who Knew Infinity by Robert Kanigel), a novel and a television documentary—with the possibility of a feature film under consideration.
Since the 1950s, however, Indian science has been notable more for its lack of originality. Indian-born scientists have continued to make discoveries—as witness the Nobel prizes for the biochemist Hargobind Khorana (1968), the astrophysicist Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar (1983), and the biologist Venkataraman Ramakrishnan (2009)—but their research was in each case conducted outside India, mainly in the United States and the United Kingdom. This was despite the expansion of Indian science post-1947 as a result of the money and staff poured into scientific higher education and research—for instance, the various Indian Institutes of Technology—by the Indian government under Jawaharlal Nehru; of India's burgeoning nuclear and space programmes; and, since the early 1990s, of the economic boom in Indian manufacturing, especially its IT industry. Although Indian laboratories for some years after Indian independence continued to be underfunded compared to western and Japanese laboratories, in the past few decades its leading institutions, such as the Tata Institute for Fundamental Research in Mumbai and the Indian Institute of Science in Bangalore, have caught up with their foreign equivalents in terms of financial support, if not in achievement.
This striking difference in Indian scientific innovation between the first and the second halves of the last century compels observers to ask why. Is there, perhaps, something in contemporary Indian culture that is inimical to scientific originality? As a self-declared “micro-history of physics in India in the first half of the twentieth century”, Dispersed Radiance does not set out to answer this important question directly. Yet the book has the issue very much in mind, given the author's background as a US-trained, Indian-origin scientist who switched her career from researching physical chemistry to lecturing on the history of Indian science in the women's and gender studies programme of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
The short answer Sur appears to give is that current Indian science suffers from a uniquely Indian handicap: a historic and continuing caste consciousness (with a concurrent inequity towards women scientists) that stifles the democratic openness and the challenging skepticism required for innovative science by encouraging deadening caste-based hierarchies, politicking and disdain for manual work. But although her book makes a convincing case for this, the thesis is somewhat weakened by the strong evidence she produces for the prevalence of the same attitudes in Indian science pre-1947—when scientific innovation flourished, relatively speaking. “The interaction of Brahmanic culture, where privilege is ascribed by birth, with the precarious status accorded to indigenous scientists in British India created a culture of arrogant assertiveness”, writes Sur. Thus Raman, a south Indian Brahmin from a privileged background, ran his laboratory like a benevolent dictator and would brook almost no criticism of his key ideas, not even from leading western physicists such as Max Born. Whereas Saha, the low-caste son of a poor grocer from East Bengal, was excluded from almost all influence on official policy, largely because of his determined advocacy of democracy and openness in science (including India's nuclear programme), despite his having founded the National Planning Committee in 1938 with Nehru's approval and having been elected an independent MP in 1952, beating the Congress Party candidate by a huge margin.
For example, in 1917 Saha, as a former student of science at the University of Calcutta and now a junior researcher, informed the Calcutta University Commission established by the governor general of India that: “It is a standing complaint that, at the present time, the hostels that are attached to colleges are practically the monopoly of a few aristocratic classes—viz., of the Brahmins, the Kayasthas, the Vaidyas, and the Nabasaks. Members of democratic classes are either not admitted, or if at all admitted, they are allowed to live not as a matter of right, but as a matter of grace. If any student of the orthodox type demurs [about] living with them in the same room, and taking meals in the same dining hall, the unfortunate student is asked to remove to some other place, and take his meals in his own room. The writer knows of several instances where this state of things has actually existed”. Saha, throughout his life, was disinclined to mention his personal experience of such caste discrimination. But his close friend S. N. Bose confessed, while reminiscing about their student days in Calcutta to his own students: “We were like animals in those days. Meghnad and I sat together in all the same classes and yet I thought nothing of the fact that in the student hostel Meghnad had to eat separately as he was not allowed to eat with us because of his ‘low’ caste.”
By intelligent use of the Saha papers—one of the few scientific archives in India to be made widely available to historians (unlike the closely guarded Raman archives)—combined with assiduous interviewing of scientists with personal knowledge of the period, including a single woman scientist, the meteorologist Anna Mani (who died in 2001), a onetime student of Raman forced to work in a strictly segregated laboratory!, Sur builds up a nuanced picture of modern Indian science during its formative period. It is a pity that she indulges in too much tedious post-colonial jargon, with occasional lapses into political correctness, and regrettable that the book contains factual slips and sloppy referencing. But readers can glide over most of these faults and concentrate on the fascinating, largely unfamiliar, material that shines light into some murky areas of twentieth-century Indian history.
